Senate To Vote On Gun Background Checks Wednesday | TPMDC
Can't even have reasoned background checks. Can't even do that. And meanwhile John Cornyn wants a bill that would require all states to allow concealed carry if you have a permit from a state like Arizona. As David Frum noted, conservatives love state's rights until, well, they don't.
More guns. More guns. More guns. Fuck it. You guys win. But this is where you will be on the hot seat. The next shooting will be on the NRA, because they wouldn't even budge on reasoned responses. So fuck them.
April 17, 2013
April 12, 2013
Gun culture and the conservative reliance on the false specter of the "slippery slope"
GOP Congressman Duncan offers us a great example of "gun culture" when he compared a possible gun registry to genocide. Of course, a gun registry is not up for debate now, but the NRA and gun culture people are warning that more background checks will result in one. It is a "slippery slope," in this case leading us to genocide, evidently, with a stop in a national registry of gun owners.
I am not suggesting that there are no slippery slopes in politics, mind you. But I believe that conservatives have used that in a very cynical and dishonest way over the past 10 years. Raising taxes is a good one. Once you raise taxes, we are told, then the government will just raise more and spend more.
Except that nothing has proven politically easier than cutting taxes. Raising taxes is the hard thing to do. Cutting taxes is actually the slippery slope, because it has led us to the place where any tax increase is tantamount to tyranny. Or have we forgotten the origins of the modern Idiot Party--oops, that is supposed to read Tea Party.
Likewise, since the heyday of modern gun control in the 1990s, the slippery slope has been to move away from control toward freer access to guns--giving us the Arizona's of the world where access to guns is much easier than access to healthcare or reason. But those Arizona idiots aside, the general tenor of the American public has been less supportive of gun control over those years. As a result, it has been much easier to ease restrictions on guns than to restrict them. And here we are a few months after Newtown when the initial response was going to be AWB and other restrictions to the now where we might get universal background checks, but probably won't get anything.
But somehow, in the gun culture mindset, even this minor move forward is a step on a slippery slope to registration and then, of course, genocide.
I am not suggesting that there are no slippery slopes in politics, mind you. But I believe that conservatives have used that in a very cynical and dishonest way over the past 10 years. Raising taxes is a good one. Once you raise taxes, we are told, then the government will just raise more and spend more.
Except that nothing has proven politically easier than cutting taxes. Raising taxes is the hard thing to do. Cutting taxes is actually the slippery slope, because it has led us to the place where any tax increase is tantamount to tyranny. Or have we forgotten the origins of the modern Idiot Party--oops, that is supposed to read Tea Party.
Likewise, since the heyday of modern gun control in the 1990s, the slippery slope has been to move away from control toward freer access to guns--giving us the Arizona's of the world where access to guns is much easier than access to healthcare or reason. But those Arizona idiots aside, the general tenor of the American public has been less supportive of gun control over those years. As a result, it has been much easier to ease restrictions on guns than to restrict them. And here we are a few months after Newtown when the initial response was going to be AWB and other restrictions to the now where we might get universal background checks, but probably won't get anything.
But somehow, in the gun culture mindset, even this minor move forward is a step on a slippery slope to registration and then, of course, genocide.
April 9, 2013
And btw, but this is gun culture
Senator To Newtown Families: The Gun Debate Has Nothing To Do With You | ThinkProgress
When the NRA and their Senator tell people who lost their children in a massacre that they have nothing to do with this debate--that they have no voice here--that is gun culture. Is it all about those families? Nope. but good god. Their young children were butchered by guns. They get a voice here.
When the NRA and their Senator tell people who lost their children in a massacre that they have nothing to do with this debate--that they have no voice here--that is gun culture. Is it all about those families? Nope. but good god. Their young children were butchered by guns. They get a voice here.
Pro-Gun Absolutism: or the move to privatize law and order
Always nice when a journalist echoes almost exactly what I said last December about this attack on our basic sense of community. Take away the basic arguments about the second amendment, and replete through all the pro-gun rhetoric is this basic idea: government can't (or won't) protect you, so you have to do it yourself.
This piece echoes that sentiment:
This, ultimately, is my biggest complaint with the gun culture argument. I don't want to kill, and I don't want bars on my home. I want to pay for police and good governance and good community that eases tensions and crime. I understand that none of that guarantees that I won't be a crime victim (though me having a gun has no guarantee either). As I have noted repeatedly, it is the height of cynicism to go out of your way to gut government programs and then claim that as a justification for self-arming.
Let's make this very clear. The pro-gun lobby didn't used to make this their centerpiece, but every but of lobbying I have seen from that side suggests that Obama or some Diane Feinstein-led raid will join a UN raid to take away your guns. Or make you get healthcare. I am not exactly sure which. (And I can't reiterate enough that many of the people paranoid about government tyranny are crying foul because of getting healthcare to poor people.)
Steve suggested that I was naive about our system, and that I should not believe it works all the time. I disagree with the charge of naivete and would suggest that I am probably more informed on the history of our country than he suggests--but at the end of the day, we are left with this suggestion that we should be planning for a potential armed revolution where we shoot at our fellow Americans in the Armed forces or Reserve--or at our community's cops, or at government agents (Americans) trying to enforce the law.
Smitty, in his fine Tyranny of the Lunatics, notes that this paranoid fantasy also disparages our military and military leadership:
This piece echoes that sentiment:
In the gun lobby’s dystopic view, Americans can no longer rely on government to keep them safe, so they have to do the job themselves. When everybody is armed and dangerous, the predators among us won’t be able to find any victims. Banning assault weapons and high-capacity clips is tantamount to unilateral disarmament, since it would leave law-abiding citizens outgunned in their confrontation with thugs and criminals.And
By this warped logic, it’s better to outsource public safety and law enforcement to private vigilantes than to curb public access to weapons of war. Conceived in paranoia, this mad project will make all of us more vulnerable to sociopaths with unlimited firepower. It would make America a less civilized country.And this very good point that for the NRA, government is both all powerful and will take your guns, and equally powerless and incapable of law and order.
The NRA has a schizoid attitude toward government. In fundraising appeals to members, it fans fears that jackbooted feds are coming for your guns. In the political arena, it depicts government as pathetically weak, overwhelmed by the orgy of violent criminality and insanity engulfing our society.
This, ultimately, is my biggest complaint with the gun culture argument. I don't want to kill, and I don't want bars on my home. I want to pay for police and good governance and good community that eases tensions and crime. I understand that none of that guarantees that I won't be a crime victim (though me having a gun has no guarantee either). As I have noted repeatedly, it is the height of cynicism to go out of your way to gut government programs and then claim that as a justification for self-arming.
Let's make this very clear. The pro-gun lobby didn't used to make this their centerpiece, but every but of lobbying I have seen from that side suggests that Obama or some Diane Feinstein-led raid will join a UN raid to take away your guns. Or make you get healthcare. I am not exactly sure which. (And I can't reiterate enough that many of the people paranoid about government tyranny are crying foul because of getting healthcare to poor people.)
Steve suggested that I was naive about our system, and that I should not believe it works all the time. I disagree with the charge of naivete and would suggest that I am probably more informed on the history of our country than he suggests--but at the end of the day, we are left with this suggestion that we should be planning for a potential armed revolution where we shoot at our fellow Americans in the Armed forces or Reserve--or at our community's cops, or at government agents (Americans) trying to enforce the law.
Smitty, in his fine Tyranny of the Lunatics, notes that this paranoid fantasy also disparages our military and military leadership:
I want good government. I want competent and trained police. I am not trying to take away your gun, but don't tell me that my only choice for safety for my community and neighborhood and household is to buy an AR and hunker down. Don't tell my neighbors that the only thing you will support to help secure their kids during the school day is to arm their teachers. And don't tell me that people who constantly rant about tyranny are patriotic.
Also, that fails to take into account that our troops are A) sworn to uphold the constitution; and 2) sworn to obey lawful orders. So for your delusion to come true, that means American troops would have no problem at all firing on....other fellow Americans. No. That's just fucking stupid.
Why southern heritage is just code for racism
I have friends who defend the "southern heritage" argument and who talk about the fact that most rebel soldiers didn't own slaves, that the flag was "battle flag," and of course, that the Civil War wasn't really about slavery.
The buzz is now about a duet between Brad Paisley and LL Cool J with the line: "if you don't judge my do-rag, I won't judge your red flag" and "if you don't judge my gold chains, I'll forget the iron chains."
Sigh. As Time's James Poniewozik notes, this may be the worst song on race relations since GOB Bluth wrote "It ain't easy being white or brown."
Ta-Nehisi Coates has the best take on why 'Accidental Racist' Is actually just racist. His main point is that picking LL Cool J to represent all of black America is exactly what racism is, not what it isn't. But his best point is one that seems so damn obvious, but not one I had noticed before:
The buzz is now about a duet between Brad Paisley and LL Cool J with the line: "if you don't judge my do-rag, I won't judge your red flag" and "if you don't judge my gold chains, I'll forget the iron chains."
Sigh. As Time's James Poniewozik notes, this may be the worst song on race relations since GOB Bluth wrote "It ain't easy being white or brown."
Ta-Nehisi Coates has the best take on why 'Accidental Racist' Is actually just racist. His main point is that picking LL Cool J to represent all of black America is exactly what racism is, not what it isn't. But his best point is one that seems so damn obvious, but not one I had noticed before:
Paisley wants to know how he can express his Southern Pride. Here are some ways. He could hold a huge party on Martin Luther King's birthday, to celebrate a Southerner's contribution to the world of democracy. He could rock a T-shirt emblazoned with Faulkner's Light In August, and celebrate the South's immense contribution to American literature. He could preach about the contributions of unknown Southern soldiers like Andrew Jackson Smith. He could tell the world about the original Cassius Clay. He could insist that Tennessee raise a statue to Ida B. Wells.
Every one of these people are Southerners. And every one of them contributed to this great country. But to do that Paisley would have to be more interested in a challenging conversation and less interested in a comforting lecture.Exactly. When all your Southern heritage is white you don't really get to claim that it isn't racist.
April 8, 2013
Blergh
This has been one of those Mondays. To be fair, the last few days have been rough around here. The weekend was the two year anniversary of losing Streak, and on top of all the loss in SOF's family, it has just been a downer time. This morning, I learned that one of my employers will no longer employ me for online classes. I had kind of expected something like this, but the sheer stupidity of their decision angered me almost more than the loss of a section. That is the adjunct's lot, of course. We are the migrant worker of academia--taking only what the tenured class doesn't want to teach, and doing it for pennies. Yeah, it has been one of those Mondays.
As you all know (probably) we have a fish pond in our backyard. Over the last year and a half, a blue heron has made our pond one of his stops, and we have significantly fewer fish than we used to. For a while, that seemed ok. The heron is huge and beautiful and just so amazing to see when he lands in our yard, and our fish have never been anything other than fish. We don't feed them and we don't name them. They are just there.
But we have one exception--or partial exception to that rule. We bought a koi several years ago at Petsmart for a couple of bucks. They are colorful and pretty and we thought it would be nice. (Part of the reason we don't feed them, btw, is that I have seen huge koi in ponds with feeding and they come to the surface in a really creepy begging style. Ugh.)
So our koi has made it through this last year and a half of heron visits. But on Saturday, I was kicking the ball with the dogs and saw something orange near the pond where there should be no orange. I went over there to find our koi gasping and twitching about two feet from the pond. I quickly grabbed him and put him back in the water, thinking that he was probably done for, but it was worth a shot. He moved down, then started to float. I was sure he was done. But as I neared, I realized he was just gasping for air. His gills were going crazy. After a few minutes of that, he swam off and is still doing ok.
I am not sure why, but this incident has bothered me a lot. Obviously, I am glad I was there in time. I must have interrupted the heron. The koi could not have lasted much longer out of the water. I have heard of herons grabbing koi that are too big for them, but still either killing them or throwing them out of the water.
But I found myself very sad. Perhaps it was the anniversary of Streak's loss. Perhaps it is all the loss in our family. Perhaps it is my own fear of losing those I love. Perhaps it was the sense of complete vulnerability that I saw in the koi. But I went from not caring if the koi was there or not to feeling a connection with him, and kind of pissed at the heron.
Mondays happen. I will move on. And I will work to give the koi as many hiding places as I can to protect him from the heron. And I will try to make peace with the academic world. Eventually.
In the meantime, I am going to get a beer and make some dinner.
David Kuo, RIP
Joe Klein has one of the nicest remembrances of his friend David Kuo, who passed away last week. David Kuo | TIME.com I read Kuo's book on his days in the Bush administration and, at the time, thought his words would spur christian conservatives to rethink their loyalty to the conservative movement.
Of course, that was folly. The people who defended torture weren't really that concerned about "faith based" organizations and were not at all interested in the "compassionate" brand of conservatism that Bush supposedly pushed.
But Kuo was, and there are a lot of people out there who are. It is my hope that his legacy will live on in those people of faith who work tirelessly to help the least of these.
Of course, that was folly. The people who defended torture weren't really that concerned about "faith based" organizations and were not at all interested in the "compassionate" brand of conservatism that Bush supposedly pushed.
But Kuo was, and there are a lot of people out there who are. It is my hope that his legacy will live on in those people of faith who work tirelessly to help the least of these.
April 7, 2013
April 5, 2013
April 4, 2013
Don't tell me the NRA political people are reasonable
As Senate Prepares To Take Up Background Checks, NRA Warns Of Outright Gun Confiscation | ThinkProgress
They are, as my friend Steve said in a different context, assbags. Unfortunately, adult gun owners seem to defend this shit.
They are, as my friend Steve said in a different context, assbags. Unfortunately, adult gun owners seem to defend this shit.
April 3, 2013
Yeah, this is also Gun Culture.
Gun Freedom Is Behind Proposed Amendment to North Carolina Constitution, Lawmaker Says
Don't ask me to respect people pushing laws because they are readying themselves for a gun battle with the federal government.
Don't ask me to respect people pushing laws because they are readying themselves for a gun battle with the federal government.
Gun culture revisited
Yes, Steve, the NRA's suggestion that more guns in schools will make them safer is a part of gun culture. I await your derision. Perhaps you will suggest that I am not patriotic enough. Or I hate the constitution.
Actually, the expert in this story agrees that national laws will probably not stop school shootings. I get that. Despite Steve's selective reading, I have been pretty open to the suggestion that gun regulations will have limited effectiveness. What I have suggested is that we, as a culture start to stand up to this gun culture that deifies weapons.
Expert warns against ‘blindly’ implementing NRA’s ‘superficially simple solution’ to gun violence | The Raw Story
Perhaps a start is that we start shaming or pushing people who hoard weapons to stop doing that. Perhaps we stop encouraging the paranoia of the right and somehow legitimizing it as reasonable. It would be nice if the grownup gun people would somehow differentiate themselves in the public sphere from LaPierre and Ted Nugent. That, of course, would gut the entire idiot base of the Republican party, I am well aware, but it would be better for all of us.
I won't hold my breath. In the meantime, be sure to take offense at this post.
Actually, the expert in this story agrees that national laws will probably not stop school shootings. I get that. Despite Steve's selective reading, I have been pretty open to the suggestion that gun regulations will have limited effectiveness. What I have suggested is that we, as a culture start to stand up to this gun culture that deifies weapons.
Expert warns against ‘blindly’ implementing NRA’s ‘superficially simple solution’ to gun violence | The Raw Story
Perhaps a start is that we start shaming or pushing people who hoard weapons to stop doing that. Perhaps we stop encouraging the paranoia of the right and somehow legitimizing it as reasonable. It would be nice if the grownup gun people would somehow differentiate themselves in the public sphere from LaPierre and Ted Nugent. That, of course, would gut the entire idiot base of the Republican party, I am well aware, but it would be better for all of us.
I won't hold my breath. In the meantime, be sure to take offense at this post.
Gun culture simplified
Since some of my readers have difficulty with the concept. Here is how this works.
Gohmert: Gun Control Somehow Leads to Bestiality -- Daily Intelligencer
- Read this story.
- See if this person's actions or opinions match yours.
- If they don't, then don't be insulted by the story because it refers to the "gun culture" of which I speak.
- See how simple that is?
Gohmert: Gun Control Somehow Leads to Bestiality -- Daily Intelligencer
April 2, 2013
NRA says more guns--and that is their entire argument
I post this not to just piss Steve off, but because I can't quite rap my mind around this. We have had 20 school kids slaughtered and the NRA's best response is to say, let's just put an armed person in each building. That is their entire approach Hutchinson Recommends One Armed Person In Every School Building | TPM LiveWire
Well, not completely. They don't want to do universal background checks. They don't want any limitation on the people who like to play army on the weekends. Or who fantasize about Obama coming in a Black Helicopter to take away all their guns. Those people must be respected. Their paranoia isn't bad, it is a good thing for the NRA--and something that should be stoked and encouraged. Fear your government and get ready to die in a hail of bullets as you stand your ground and defend your castle. Or perhaps, you just shoot an innocent person or yourself in a fit of suicidal depression.
Either way, the NRA don't care.
Until Adam Lanza went into that school building shooting, he was the poster child for the gun culture (again, not responsible and sober gun owners). He had, as we now know, a virtual arsenal of guns and ammo (all helped by his mother, of course) and was ready for whatever came his way.
So Asa Hutchinson's response from the NRA is that we just need more armed people. It don't matter if they occasionally fire their weapon accidentally in school, or even if they leave their loaded weapon in the bathroom. No. More guns are better.
Of course, if we think about this, the absolute lack of response here is unbelievable. As I think John Oliver has quipped, one guy tried to blow up a plane with his shoe and we all have to take our shoes off. People shoot up schools, movie theaters and political rallies and our only response is to have more guns.
5 minutes. Reminds me of a great Gretchen Peters' song by the same name. "In just five minutes, your whole life can change." A shooter, possibly with body armor, and certainly armed with an arsenal (as they all are in these cases) moving quickly with purpose, and our response is one armed person--not in body armor, and not armed to the teeth. One magical gun will stop those shooters.
It better, because according to the NRA we aren't going to do one thing more to stop or prevent these shootings. Not one thing. No gun owner should ever be inconvenienced at all.
Well, not completely. They don't want to do universal background checks. They don't want any limitation on the people who like to play army on the weekends. Or who fantasize about Obama coming in a Black Helicopter to take away all their guns. Those people must be respected. Their paranoia isn't bad, it is a good thing for the NRA--and something that should be stoked and encouraged. Fear your government and get ready to die in a hail of bullets as you stand your ground and defend your castle. Or perhaps, you just shoot an innocent person or yourself in a fit of suicidal depression.
Either way, the NRA don't care.
Until Adam Lanza went into that school building shooting, he was the poster child for the gun culture (again, not responsible and sober gun owners). He had, as we now know, a virtual arsenal of guns and ammo (all helped by his mother, of course) and was ready for whatever came his way.
So Asa Hutchinson's response from the NRA is that we just need more armed people. It don't matter if they occasionally fire their weapon accidentally in school, or even if they leave their loaded weapon in the bathroom. No. More guns are better.
Of course, if we think about this, the absolute lack of response here is unbelievable. As I think John Oliver has quipped, one guy tried to blow up a plane with his shoe and we all have to take our shoes off. People shoot up schools, movie theaters and political rallies and our only response is to have more guns.
5 minutes. Reminds me of a great Gretchen Peters' song by the same name. "In just five minutes, your whole life can change." A shooter, possibly with body armor, and certainly armed with an arsenal (as they all are in these cases) moving quickly with purpose, and our response is one armed person--not in body armor, and not armed to the teeth. One magical gun will stop those shooters.
It better, because according to the NRA we aren't going to do one thing more to stop or prevent these shootings. Not one thing. No gun owner should ever be inconvenienced at all.
March 31, 2013
Law Enforcement Officials Gunned Down In Possible White Supremacist Plot | ThinkProgress
We never refer to this as terrorism. And we will do nothing to make it harder for these groups to arm themselves.
Law Enforcement Officials Gunned Down In Possible White Supremacist Plot | ThinkProgress
Law Enforcement Officials Gunned Down In Possible White Supremacist Plot | ThinkProgress
March 30, 2013
Religious persecution and the gay marriage debate
We have talked about the victimization complex so often employed by the religious right. Well represented in our political system, and hardly discriminated against, the victimology is a little tiresome. But not terribly surprising, as that has been their MO for the last 30 years.
Now, those opposed to same-sex marriage are claiming that they are now the victims and one even claiming that they are "more scorned than homosexuals." Forget the tacit admission that they have been scorning others for years. This is the part of the evangelical world that drives me crazy. When people criticize you, it isn't necessarily because you hold dear to values while others around you change with the wind. You are not always the principled one and they are not always the people without any morals. In fact, Christians have demonstrated one hell of a lot of scorn and hatred toward gay people over the years. They had their chance a long time ago to embrace their gay brothers and sisters and push for equal rights. Opposing gay marriage might have looked ok in that light, because they could have claimed some vague "traditional" marriage claim, but held up their allegiance to legal rights and treatment of gay couples. But they didn't. They opposed every step out of that closet, and scorned and shamed along the way. They told gay people to get therapy and force themselves to be straight.
As Josh Marshall wrote yesterday, religious conservatives are watching the polling changes too, and fear that they might be witnessing a sea change where openly espousing anti-gay sentiments may be politically and publicly unacceptable. Just as the 1960s saw that change where politicians and public figures could no longer espouse white supremacy without a backlash.
Here is my prediction. In 20 years, most evangelical organizations and even evangelical individuals are going to be claiming that they were always for committed and monogamous gay marriages. They will rewrite their past and claim that their only objection was promiscuity, but they were always for committed relationships.
Mark my words.
Now, those opposed to same-sex marriage are claiming that they are now the victims and one even claiming that they are "more scorned than homosexuals." Forget the tacit admission that they have been scorning others for years. This is the part of the evangelical world that drives me crazy. When people criticize you, it isn't necessarily because you hold dear to values while others around you change with the wind. You are not always the principled one and they are not always the people without any morals. In fact, Christians have demonstrated one hell of a lot of scorn and hatred toward gay people over the years. They had their chance a long time ago to embrace their gay brothers and sisters and push for equal rights. Opposing gay marriage might have looked ok in that light, because they could have claimed some vague "traditional" marriage claim, but held up their allegiance to legal rights and treatment of gay couples. But they didn't. They opposed every step out of that closet, and scorned and shamed along the way. They told gay people to get therapy and force themselves to be straight.
As Josh Marshall wrote yesterday, religious conservatives are watching the polling changes too, and fear that they might be witnessing a sea change where openly espousing anti-gay sentiments may be politically and publicly unacceptable. Just as the 1960s saw that change where politicians and public figures could no longer espouse white supremacy without a backlash.
Here is my prediction. In 20 years, most evangelical organizations and even evangelical individuals are going to be claiming that they were always for committed and monogamous gay marriages. They will rewrite their past and claim that their only objection was promiscuity, but they were always for committed relationships.
Mark my words.
March 26, 2013
Gay Marriage, pro and con
Watching this debate unfold over the past decade, it is hard to imagine another social issue that has changed as much as gay marriage. As many observers have noted, it was just in 2004 when Bush (with the help of then closeted gay RNC chair, Ken Mehlman) made gay marriage the wedge issue that would make sure social conservatives got to the polls. It worked, and Bush narrowly won reelection. There were some attempts at the same thing in 08 and 12, but clearly, that argument has fallen by the wayside.
Not only is the national scene shifting, with over half the country in support of gay marriage, but the polling is even more eye-popping when you look at younger people. Their numbers, across political and religious lines, are much higher for gay marriage than people over 50.
And some of this is the reason why the argument against gay marriage is losing ground, and the opponents know it. After all, it was not that long ago that opponents said that our civilization would crumble and our culture would fall apart if we allowed gays to marry. Several states have passed gay marriage, and the sky has not fallen. Our younger people know very well that gay people are just as good, bad and indifferent as straight people. They know kids who have gay parents, and their parents are just as messed up as anyone else.
The biggest problem for the traditional defense, I think, is that they are defending an institution that has largely never been what they thought. Marriage has always evolved and changed, as ideas about the family changed, and as economic pressures changed. Marriage was originally about property, but that no longer is even a requirement. It was about family too, but family, like marriage has changed tremendously. We all know divorced, cobbled, single, unmarried families, and often will put all of those varied versions of the family up against the traditional model.
This isn't just about hypocrisy, but it is incredibly hard to shout piously for traditional marriage when so many people are divorced or live in highly dysfunctional families. And I think most of the American people reflect this basic reality. They know full well that their relationships all need work, and who are they to tell others how to live.
Not only is the national scene shifting, with over half the country in support of gay marriage, but the polling is even more eye-popping when you look at younger people. Their numbers, across political and religious lines, are much higher for gay marriage than people over 50.
And some of this is the reason why the argument against gay marriage is losing ground, and the opponents know it. After all, it was not that long ago that opponents said that our civilization would crumble and our culture would fall apart if we allowed gays to marry. Several states have passed gay marriage, and the sky has not fallen. Our younger people know very well that gay people are just as good, bad and indifferent as straight people. They know kids who have gay parents, and their parents are just as messed up as anyone else.
The biggest problem for the traditional defense, I think, is that they are defending an institution that has largely never been what they thought. Marriage has always evolved and changed, as ideas about the family changed, and as economic pressures changed. Marriage was originally about property, but that no longer is even a requirement. It was about family too, but family, like marriage has changed tremendously. We all know divorced, cobbled, single, unmarried families, and often will put all of those varied versions of the family up against the traditional model.
This isn't just about hypocrisy, but it is incredibly hard to shout piously for traditional marriage when so many people are divorced or live in highly dysfunctional families. And I think most of the American people reflect this basic reality. They know full well that their relationships all need work, and who are they to tell others how to live.
March 21, 2013
Do conservatives only care when they can personally relate?
I don't think that is true, but unfortunately, it seems to be the case. As Fred notes, there are several cases where conservatives change their approach when they have a personal connection. With Mark Kirk, it was a stroke that made him realize that poor people with the same issue would never be able to recover. With Rob Portman, a gay son made him realize that he didn't oppose marriage for his son.
Why then? Is it too difficult for conservatives to imagine life for poor people struggling with a major illness or what it might be like to be gay? To be very fair, of course, the other conservatives could not wait to say that they would still oppose gay rights even if their own kids were gay. When you are in the conservative tribe, nothing loses you membership like backing off of bigotry.
Why then? Is it too difficult for conservatives to imagine life for poor people struggling with a major illness or what it might be like to be gay? To be very fair, of course, the other conservatives could not wait to say that they would still oppose gay rights even if their own kids were gay. When you are in the conservative tribe, nothing loses you membership like backing off of bigotry.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)