NRA Warns Members That Confiscation Could Be Next | TPMMuckraker
Because regardless of what we liberals say, we really want to take all your guns and turn you into slaves--well, just before we load you into railroad cars to ship to concentration camps.
Yep. Reasonable. Sane. That's your NRA
January 17, 2013
January 16, 2013
David Frum weighs in
on the NRA's ad attacking the Obama family:
And Tomasky agrees:
Both men point out that the President's kids should be off limits.
the NRA's sneering references to the president's family are beyond the pale. As the makers of the NRA ad should know, and probably do know, the First Family has come under years of racially coded attack for their "uppityism," as Rush Limbaugh phrased it. This latest attack ad looks to many like only one more attempt to enflame an ancient American wound.
And Tomasky agrees:
Let’s start with the ad’s broken logic. A, the Obama family has Secret Service protection; B, other American families do not; C, because of this, Obama is an elitist and a hypocrite. It’s pretty ludicrous. Malia and Sasha Obama get lots of things because their father won the presidency. They also have a chauffeur; get to ride on a big fancy airplane free of charge and don’t have to endure any TSA-related indignities; live in a beautiful big house rent-free; and so on. By the ad’s logic, all of these are instances of hypocrisy.
Both men point out that the President's kids should be off limits.
No, the NRA isn't sociopathic at all. Not one bit.
Nope, they just attack the President for having armed guards for his kids. Because, of course, that is the real debate. Securing the first family who is vulnerable for reasons that the rest of us don't even conceptualize, or having armed teachers in our schools.
Don't tell me the NRA is a reasonable organization. Just don't. This same week they issued a shooting app for the Iphone that included targets that were little coffins. Good grief.
And this dawned on me. If the Assault Weapon ban was so ineffective and did nothing, why does the NRA and gun groups hate it so much? If it is just symbolic, then why would they care?
Don't tell me the NRA is a reasonable organization. Just don't. This same week they issued a shooting app for the Iphone that included targets that were little coffins. Good grief.
And this dawned on me. If the Assault Weapon ban was so ineffective and did nothing, why does the NRA and gun groups hate it so much? If it is just symbolic, then why would they care?
January 11, 2013
Statement from Sociopathic Guns and Shooting People Organization
NRA-ILA | Statement From the NRA Regarding Today's White House Task Force Meeting
Don't tell me the NRA is reasonable. I have heard their robo calls telling me how Obama was in league with the UN tohelp disabled people around the world take away our guns. I have seen them blame 20 year old video games and suggest that all we need are armed teachers and principles.
I am not anti-second amendment. I am not anti-gun, and I am not anti-gun owners. But do not tell me that the NRA is anything other than a reactionary and sociopathic organization.
While claiming that no policy proposals would be “prejudged,” this Task Force spent most of its time on proposed restrictions on lawful firearms owners - honest, taxpaying, hardworking Americans. It is unfortunate that this Administration continues to insist on pushing failed solutions to our nation's most pressing problems. We will not allow law-abiding gun owners to be blamed for the acts of criminals and madmen.The rich statement of accusing the White House of coming in with their mind made up (pot, kettle), but only better when asking for background checks and closing loopholes on gun sales is an attack on honest Americans.
Don't tell me the NRA is reasonable. I have heard their robo calls telling me how Obama was in league with the UN to
I am not anti-second amendment. I am not anti-gun, and I am not anti-gun owners. But do not tell me that the NRA is anything other than a reactionary and sociopathic organization.
January 5, 2013
Report: States With Stand Your Ground Laws See More Homicides | ThinkProgress
Report: States With Stand Your Ground Laws See More Homicides | ThinkProgress
I have no idea if the study is well done or not. Just interesting.
I have no idea if the study is well done or not. Just interesting.
Republicans have been busy defending rapists and voting against storm victims
There are two things that used to be less political. Trying to help women in domestic violence situations and responding to storm victims. As Chris Christie said of storms, they hit blue states and red states alike. It is an American issue. Yet Republicans, including my two senators from a state prone to natural disasters voted against the funding for Hurricane Sandy victims.
That is bad enough. For many of them, it is just fiscal blindness. For others, I suspect a basic lack of compassion. But the Republican House killing the Violence against Women Act is, as this writer put it, "Protecting rapists, murderers by killing VAWA." I just read Louise Erdrich's The Round House, which is a novel about rape and violence against Indian women. Turns out that something like 1 in 3 reservation women will be raped, and Indian mothers are often teaching their daughters to expect it. But here is the thing. Agood many of those rapes are by non-reservation males, and when they are not tribal members, the tribal justice system doesn't have the jurisdiction to prosecute those attacks on tribal land. And those with the jurisdiction often decide to not prosecute. This bill would have given more control to tribal authorities. And that, as it turns out, is Eric Cantor's big sticking point. Other Republicans don't like the protection extended to non citizens or lesbians. Evidently because Republicans don't approve of those groups, their women don't deserve protection. But there appears to be room to negotiate on those points. Cantor, from what I read, will not budge on protecting Native women. I even called Cantor's office to ask the reason, but the staffer had nothing for me. No spin about civil liberties or transparency or whatever. Nothing.
I read that Phyllis Schafly hates the bill because, it
But I expect this from people like Schafley. She is reflexively and tribally conservative and if liberals want this bill, it has to be bad for her. Cantor's insistence on protecting rapists and killers of Indian women, however, strikes me as even worse than anything Schafley has ever spewed.
Republicans appear to be outdoing themselves in their disdain for anyone who isn't white, male, fully abled, rich, Christian (conservative Protestant or Catholic).
That is bad enough. For many of them, it is just fiscal blindness. For others, I suspect a basic lack of compassion. But the Republican House killing the Violence against Women Act is, as this writer put it, "Protecting rapists, murderers by killing VAWA." I just read Louise Erdrich's The Round House, which is a novel about rape and violence against Indian women. Turns out that something like 1 in 3 reservation women will be raped, and Indian mothers are often teaching their daughters to expect it. But here is the thing. Agood many of those rapes are by non-reservation males, and when they are not tribal members, the tribal justice system doesn't have the jurisdiction to prosecute those attacks on tribal land. And those with the jurisdiction often decide to not prosecute. This bill would have given more control to tribal authorities. And that, as it turns out, is Eric Cantor's big sticking point. Other Republicans don't like the protection extended to non citizens or lesbians. Evidently because Republicans don't approve of those groups, their women don't deserve protection. But there appears to be room to negotiate on those points. Cantor, from what I read, will not budge on protecting Native women. I even called Cantor's office to ask the reason, but the staffer had nothing for me. No spin about civil liberties or transparency or whatever. Nothing.
I read that Phyllis Schafly hates the bill because, it
is “as sex-discriminatory as legislation can get.” Why? Because it isn’t designed to protect men. Schlafly argues that domestic violence is a problem that affects men and women equally: “A Centers for Disease Control survey found that half of all partner violence was mutual, and 282 scholarly studies reported that women are as physically aggressive, or more aggressive, than men.”That's right. The same people who insist that feminists and liberals are the ones equating men and women and not understanding physical differences are now asserting that actually women are just as aggressive and violent as men. The numbers don't match that, but who the hell cares about facts?
But I expect this from people like Schafley. She is reflexively and tribally conservative and if liberals want this bill, it has to be bad for her. Cantor's insistence on protecting rapists and killers of Indian women, however, strikes me as even worse than anything Schafley has ever spewed.
Republicans appear to be outdoing themselves in their disdain for anyone who isn't white, male, fully abled, rich, Christian (conservative Protestant or Catholic).
December 21, 2012
It isn't the guns. It is the stupid.
God knows I find Joe Scarborough annoying and never watch his show. His occasional moments of lucidity don't make up for the rest. And that also applies to his conversion to the gun control side. But here, I was more listening to the Republican mouthpiece for the NRA, and have to say that Joe is more right here than the doofus. And you can see the NRA speak here--1) talking about guns is "politicizing" a tragedy. 2) Whatever we say, we can never say that any particular "gun" is a problem. The problem has to be something else--video games, movies. His mom.
Meanwhile, here is a little sanity on the suggestion that all of these people are just mentally ill--or at least, mentally ill in any technical way.
But by all means, let's fund mental health treatment, and we should do that even if doing so doesn't stop any shootings. We should do that because it is the right thing to do. And we can talk about video games and films. I am unsure their impact, but have no problem with that discussion. But we also have to talk about angry white males and we have to talk about guns.
Meanwhile, here is a little sanity on the suggestion that all of these people are just mentally ill--or at least, mentally ill in any technical way.
But there is overwhelming epidemiological evidence that the vast majority of people with psychiatric disorders do not commit violent acts. Only about 4 percent of violence in the United States can be attributed to people with mental illness.Again, I am not saying that the only problem here is guns. I am not convinced that anyone needs a Bushmaster AR 15 for any legitimate reason beyond just liking the gun. Nor am I convinced that the Second Amendment was really meant to be a license for everyone to have as many guns as they want. That "well regulated militia" part just seems to have disappeared.
But by all means, let's fund mental health treatment, and we should do that even if doing so doesn't stop any shootings. We should do that because it is the right thing to do. And we can talk about video games and films. I am unsure their impact, but have no problem with that discussion. But we also have to talk about angry white males and we have to talk about guns.
December 19, 2012
Does the NRA defend hunters?
Just read this (A Moderate NRA - The Dish | By Andrew Sullivan - The Daily Beast) and was reminded that my early years with the NRA (yes, I was a Junior Member) were all about hunting, and hunter's safety. As this post suggests, an NRA devoted to that would be more moderate on a lot of environmental issues even if they were still pretty conservative on access to guns.
But they aren't. I get the sense that the NRA is really only about defending the right to own guns that are about killing people.
And that is a shame.
But they aren't. I get the sense that the NRA is really only about defending the right to own guns that are about killing people.
And that is a shame.
More on this idea of privatizing security
From Alan Jacobs, via Ta-Nehisi Coates: ('Order at Universal Gunpoint' - Ta-Nehisi Coates - The Atlantic):
Of course, this breaks down if you are female and pregnant, and not ready to have a child. You are not on your own there--sadly unless you want to keep the child. But if you want safe schools? Go buy a gun and prepared to shoot someone.
But what troubles me most about this suggestion -- and the general More Guns approach to social ills -- is the absolute abandonment of civil society it represents. It gives up on the rule of law in favor of a Hobbesian "war of every man against every man" in which we no longer have genuine neighbors, only potential enemies. You may trust your neighbor for now -- but you have high-powered recourse if he ever acts wrongly.As I have said, I think this is more about community than guns, per se. As I posted on FB a few minutes ago, this is part and parcel of the anti-tax mantra that has nothing to do with job creation, but everything to do with disconnecting from the community and the social contract. You want clean air? Suck it up. You want lighted streets? Pull out your checkbook. Same for maintained parks.
Whatever lack of open violence may be procured by this method is not peace or civil order, but rather a standoff, a Cold War maintained by the threat of mutually assured destruction. Moreover, the person who wishes to live this way, to maintain order at universal gunpoint, has an absolute trust in his own ability to use weapons wisely and well: he never for a moment asks whether he can be trusted with a gun. Of course he can! (But in literature we call this hubris.)
Is this really the best we can do? It might be if we lived in, say, the world described by Cormac McCarthy in The Road. But we don't. Our social order is flawed, but by no means bankrupt. Most of us live in peace and safety without the use of guns. It makes more sense to try to make that social order safer and safer, more and more genuinely peaceful, rather than descend voluntarily into a world governed by paranoia, in which one can only feel safe -- or, really, "safe" -- with cold steel strapped to one's ribcage.
Of course, this breaks down if you are female and pregnant, and not ready to have a child. You are not on your own there--sadly unless you want to keep the child. But if you want safe schools? Go buy a gun and prepared to shoot someone.
December 18, 2012
On Gun control and community
Like many Americans, I have been thinking about this latest mass shooting. Clearly the dynamic has changed since Friday, and some of that is probably good. I am not completely sure why the 20 dead kids are that much more tragic than the 6 dead adults (excluding the shooter, of course, though that is also tragic). Certainly no less tragic than the KC Chief player shooting the mother of his child and then himself to leave that child parentless.
But that aside, one thing I really like is that the conversation in certain circles is really honest and thoughtful. Some liberals and progressives are genuinely asking about gun control and not just assuming that it is automatically going to help. Josh Marshall asked about studies that purport to show lower violence in states with more restriction (can't find the link, sorry). James Fallows and Jeffrey Goldberg are engaging with the idea that gun control may not be able to do what we want. Talking points published this informed discussion (I think posted this the other day) on the changing nature of the gun culture, and that Fallows link also lists some reader responses trying to educate the non-gun public on the perils of restricting scary looking guns (as evidently the assault weapon ban did) rather than anything meaningful.
There has been more than our share of stupidity. Mike Huckabee and James Dobson have both claimed that we are witnessing the result of moral decline, and Megan McCardle evidently (I didn't read the entire thing) suggested that we teach our kids to rush gunmen. Ugh. Tennessee and Michigan both moved to allow teachers to arm themselves in classrooms. Double ugh.
But around the periphery of this discussion, I think, is a discussion about community. I think it is completely reasonable to suggest that gun restrictions are no more helpful to society than our war on drugs--though I am not sure I completely agree. But there are absolutely legitimate 2nd amendment issues at play here--regardless of what liberals believe. I get that. But the suggestion that teachers need to arm themselves struck a chord about community, or the lack there of.
Consider it this way. On one hand, we are being told by conservatives that gun restrictions won't work and should not be used--but many of those same conservatives are also pushing to reduce elements of our community fabric. Less money for cops and firemen--and of course less money for public health and mental health facilities. In that context, telling the teacher to arm themselves sounds more like outsourcing than some Rambo approach to teaching. It sounds, to my ear, as conservatives saying, "we won't pay for those things that might help, and we absolutely won't give up our right to purchase whatever crazy gun or bullet we want--but we will tell you that you are on your own and you better provide your own security."
Perfectly reasonable, as many of my conservative friends have said, to suggest that gun control simply won't make us safer. But less reasonable to then ignore that Republicans are purposefully cutting programs that might make us more safe and which have nothing to do with guns. Mental health professionals have told me that assistance for families dealing with mental illness is often one of the first budget cuts. Putting more cops on the street is unthinkable in a context where raising taxes just a few percentage points is harder than getting authorization to invade a country. And think about all of those health clinics that have closed over the past two decades. Not saying that all of those in place would make us immune from school shootings, but those are policies that have a track record of helping communities be safer.
Focusing on the guns misses that broader connection, I think. Part of our battle here is between conservatives who really don't want a broader "we are all in this together" and liberals who, however misguided on banning handguns (for example), who believe that that individual right is running straight into a crowd of innocent people.
But that aside, one thing I really like is that the conversation in certain circles is really honest and thoughtful. Some liberals and progressives are genuinely asking about gun control and not just assuming that it is automatically going to help. Josh Marshall asked about studies that purport to show lower violence in states with more restriction (can't find the link, sorry). James Fallows and Jeffrey Goldberg are engaging with the idea that gun control may not be able to do what we want. Talking points published this informed discussion (I think posted this the other day) on the changing nature of the gun culture, and that Fallows link also lists some reader responses trying to educate the non-gun public on the perils of restricting scary looking guns (as evidently the assault weapon ban did) rather than anything meaningful.
There has been more than our share of stupidity. Mike Huckabee and James Dobson have both claimed that we are witnessing the result of moral decline, and Megan McCardle evidently (I didn't read the entire thing) suggested that we teach our kids to rush gunmen. Ugh. Tennessee and Michigan both moved to allow teachers to arm themselves in classrooms. Double ugh.
But around the periphery of this discussion, I think, is a discussion about community. I think it is completely reasonable to suggest that gun restrictions are no more helpful to society than our war on drugs--though I am not sure I completely agree. But there are absolutely legitimate 2nd amendment issues at play here--regardless of what liberals believe. I get that. But the suggestion that teachers need to arm themselves struck a chord about community, or the lack there of.
Consider it this way. On one hand, we are being told by conservatives that gun restrictions won't work and should not be used--but many of those same conservatives are also pushing to reduce elements of our community fabric. Less money for cops and firemen--and of course less money for public health and mental health facilities. In that context, telling the teacher to arm themselves sounds more like outsourcing than some Rambo approach to teaching. It sounds, to my ear, as conservatives saying, "we won't pay for those things that might help, and we absolutely won't give up our right to purchase whatever crazy gun or bullet we want--but we will tell you that you are on your own and you better provide your own security."
Perfectly reasonable, as many of my conservative friends have said, to suggest that gun control simply won't make us safer. But less reasonable to then ignore that Republicans are purposefully cutting programs that might make us more safe and which have nothing to do with guns. Mental health professionals have told me that assistance for families dealing with mental illness is often one of the first budget cuts. Putting more cops on the street is unthinkable in a context where raising taxes just a few percentage points is harder than getting authorization to invade a country. And think about all of those health clinics that have closed over the past two decades. Not saying that all of those in place would make us immune from school shootings, but those are policies that have a track record of helping communities be safer.
Focusing on the guns misses that broader connection, I think. Part of our battle here is between conservatives who really don't want a broader "we are all in this together" and liberals who, however misguided on banning handguns (for example), who believe that that individual right is running straight into a crowd of innocent people.
December 16, 2012
More guns? Really?
Well, here we are again. Another mass shooting. Another discussion where people on the right say that "it isn't the right time to talk about gun violence or control," and another time where we decide to discuss only the issues of mental health treatment. And I get that part, especially, and think that we need to devote far more resources to mental health and general health treatment.
But the right has already said that we need more guns in the mix. Michigan just authorized more guns, and Nevada wants to add more. Oklahoma authorized more legalized carry and on the talk shows, idiots like Louis Gohmert said that all of this would be better if the Principal had a gun in her office. (Protection Or Peril? Gun Possession Of Questionable Value In An Assault, Study Finds).
A), as I posted on Facebook, I am tired of any discussion that includes the NRA. They revealed themselves to be irresponsible when they defended everything from cop killer bullets to guns that could evade x-ray, and then catapulted the anti-government movement with the "jack booted thug" name for the ATF. They aren't the voice of reasonable and responsible gun owners. They may have been at one time, but no longer.
B) Mental illness may be a big factor here, but we need to stop assuming that because some white kid goes shooting that it is mental illness and not some other factor of privilege and resentment. Easier, I guess, to believe that only mentally ill people would do this kind of evil thing, but we know from history that sane people can do amazingly awful things.
C) We have to be able to talk about reducing some access to mass killing machines. This TPM reader talks about the slide from the NRA defending hunting rights to the gun culture of today--which is paranoid, about hoarding guns, and actually sells the idea that you should buy a gun to protect yourself because a Black president is dangerous to you. That people can easily buy Kevlar vests, clips that hold unbelievable amount of rounds, and bullets that are far more dangerous--and do so with ease--should bother all of us. Including gun owners.
D) And my most amazing anger is reserved for idiots like Mike Huckabee, who famously already blamed this last shooting on "removing God from the classroom." Hey, fuckwad, if your God can be removed from the classroom by a bureaucrat or elderly justice, what kind of God is he or she? Or is he or she the kid of God who pouts because his privilege has been revoked, and so decides to let 20 children die in a fit of spite? Unbelievable stupidity, and Mike Huckabee is still talked about as a GOP PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE! Jesus Christ. Surely Christians can think some of this through.
I am tired of guns, and I am really tired of people who seem to worship guns.
But the right has already said that we need more guns in the mix. Michigan just authorized more guns, and Nevada wants to add more. Oklahoma authorized more legalized carry and on the talk shows, idiots like Louis Gohmert said that all of this would be better if the Principal had a gun in her office. (Protection Or Peril? Gun Possession Of Questionable Value In An Assault, Study Finds).
A), as I posted on Facebook, I am tired of any discussion that includes the NRA. They revealed themselves to be irresponsible when they defended everything from cop killer bullets to guns that could evade x-ray, and then catapulted the anti-government movement with the "jack booted thug" name for the ATF. They aren't the voice of reasonable and responsible gun owners. They may have been at one time, but no longer.
B) Mental illness may be a big factor here, but we need to stop assuming that because some white kid goes shooting that it is mental illness and not some other factor of privilege and resentment. Easier, I guess, to believe that only mentally ill people would do this kind of evil thing, but we know from history that sane people can do amazingly awful things.
C) We have to be able to talk about reducing some access to mass killing machines. This TPM reader talks about the slide from the NRA defending hunting rights to the gun culture of today--which is paranoid, about hoarding guns, and actually sells the idea that you should buy a gun to protect yourself because a Black president is dangerous to you. That people can easily buy Kevlar vests, clips that hold unbelievable amount of rounds, and bullets that are far more dangerous--and do so with ease--should bother all of us. Including gun owners.
D) And my most amazing anger is reserved for idiots like Mike Huckabee, who famously already blamed this last shooting on "removing God from the classroom." Hey, fuckwad, if your God can be removed from the classroom by a bureaucrat or elderly justice, what kind of God is he or she? Or is he or she the kid of God who pouts because his privilege has been revoked, and so decides to let 20 children die in a fit of spite? Unbelievable stupidity, and Mike Huckabee is still talked about as a GOP PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE! Jesus Christ. Surely Christians can think some of this through.
I am tired of guns, and I am really tired of people who seem to worship guns.
December 11, 2012
Workers march on the Michigan capitol
Smitty sent me these images from this morning's protest. Votes matter. Especially when you vote for Republicans who would rather protect the rich than anything else.
The attack on workers continues in Michigan
It would be funny if it weren't so serious. The national republican party justified voting against the UN Treaty on the rights of the Disabled because several of them suggested that the Senate should not ratify treaties during the lame duck session. In Michigan, state Republicans decided that the lame duck was a perfect time to gut the unions that have built the middle class. Our friend Smitty has more on this, and I just found this Youtube of a very angry Democratic senator speaking very eloquently about the people who will be harmed by this bill.
Conservatives have won over the last 30 years in their attacks on unions. It started with Reagan taking on the air traffic controllers union and has culminated in this most recent attack on public sector unions. I am constantly amazed to hear most of my conservative friends bash unions as corrupt and encouraging laziness instead of hard work. But not one of them has explained how lower wages will actually help our economy. We have seen wages stagnate at the lower middle class and working class level for the last 30 years. Lower wages have not stopped outsourcing. They have not made us more competitive, nor reduced poverty.
These moves have simply made the rich richer. They have made the worker less safe (about which my Republican friends seem to care little), and they have served to whittle down benefits and pensions. Contract, as it turns out, is only unassailable when it is about executive bonuses, not about teacher pensions. Conservatives have appealed to some kind of resentment culture, and appealed effectively. My conservative friends resent the idea that a laborers might make a good wage doing unremarkable, or unglamorous work. Teachers, nurses, auto-workers, firefighters, bureaucrats--all of them should not make too much money. God forbid they make a wage that allows them to purchase goods and services and contribute to the broader economy.
No, as the Walmart model shows us, better that the worker be paid so little that he or she has to rely on food stamps and Medicaid for food and healthcare. And better, savagely, to then lobby to reduce both programs.
There is a vein of cruelty in the conservative mind that I think most conservatives are afraid to acknowledge. Cruelty toward pregnant women, gays, and minorities--and as Michigan and Wisconsin demonstrate, toward people who work for a living.
Conservatives have won over the last 30 years in their attacks on unions. It started with Reagan taking on the air traffic controllers union and has culminated in this most recent attack on public sector unions. I am constantly amazed to hear most of my conservative friends bash unions as corrupt and encouraging laziness instead of hard work. But not one of them has explained how lower wages will actually help our economy. We have seen wages stagnate at the lower middle class and working class level for the last 30 years. Lower wages have not stopped outsourcing. They have not made us more competitive, nor reduced poverty.
These moves have simply made the rich richer. They have made the worker less safe (about which my Republican friends seem to care little), and they have served to whittle down benefits and pensions. Contract, as it turns out, is only unassailable when it is about executive bonuses, not about teacher pensions. Conservatives have appealed to some kind of resentment culture, and appealed effectively. My conservative friends resent the idea that a laborers might make a good wage doing unremarkable, or unglamorous work. Teachers, nurses, auto-workers, firefighters, bureaucrats--all of them should not make too much money. God forbid they make a wage that allows them to purchase goods and services and contribute to the broader economy.
No, as the Walmart model shows us, better that the worker be paid so little that he or she has to rely on food stamps and Medicaid for food and healthcare. And better, savagely, to then lobby to reduce both programs.
There is a vein of cruelty in the conservative mind that I think most conservatives are afraid to acknowledge. Cruelty toward pregnant women, gays, and minorities--and as Michigan and Wisconsin demonstrate, toward people who work for a living.
December 7, 2012
Senate Republicans block treaty on the disabled--led by the religious right
Good example of everything that is wrong with the religious right's approach to knowledge and policy. (Why the US just rejected a treaty based on its own laws - Quartz). Religious conservatives objected to this treaty (based on the ADA) because many feared it would infringe on homeschoolers and/or encourage abortions of disabled fetuses. I honestly don't understand how one could legitimately fear either, and neither did most adults in the room.
This is a good example of religious conservatives pushing fringe and conspiracy theories and a great example of how far to the right the GOP has moved in the last 16 years. On the floor for the vote, was former Senator and Presidential candidate Bob Dole. Dole is in ill health and left the hospital to try and lobby for this ratification vote--after all he worked this treaty for years. But for 38 Republicans, Bob Dole was part of the establishment who would surrender American sovereignty to the evil UN. We often joke that Ronald Reagan could not get elected in this context, but the party may be shifting so far to the right that even George W. Bush may have trouble with the base today.
Either way it is sad for both people of faith and for our public policy.
This is a good example of religious conservatives pushing fringe and conspiracy theories and a great example of how far to the right the GOP has moved in the last 16 years. On the floor for the vote, was former Senator and Presidential candidate Bob Dole. Dole is in ill health and left the hospital to try and lobby for this ratification vote--after all he worked this treaty for years. But for 38 Republicans, Bob Dole was part of the establishment who would surrender American sovereignty to the evil UN. We often joke that Ronald Reagan could not get elected in this context, but the party may be shifting so far to the right that even George W. Bush may have trouble with the base today.
Either way it is sad for both people of faith and for our public policy.
November 28, 2012
The GOP's disdain for the poor
I almost titled this, "the GOP's war on poor people," but decided that we are using the phrase "war on" far too many times to indicate something where people are not shot with guns or drones. War is something else.
But the fact does remain, that the GOP continues to make life harder on the poor. Here in Oklahoma, our Governor Fallin joins other Republican governors in rejecting both the expansion of Medicaid and the option to create a state healthcare exchange. Both appear to be more about their ongoing battle with Obama and less to do with any heart-felt principled belief. For all the talk about "unfunded mandates," both of these programs could be funded, and would have allowed thousands of Oklahomans access to healthcare.
I understand (though do not share) the argument that people must be required to try to work in order to get public assistance. For me, I don't care if the person is drug addled or stupid or lazy or craven. Their access to the basics of life are disconnected from whether or not I like or respect them. But I get the idea that people might be discouraged from working if they can get food stamps or public assistance (even though the SNAP program is designed to push people off food stamps and discourage dependency).
But I do not understand this in the context of healthcare. We spent last evening at a film premier for a local autism group, and came away quite impressed with the art and the autistic individuals. But we also noted that most of them will need assistance and healthcare--that they will probably not be able to afford for most of their life. Effort isn't an issue here. Nor is it with most of those effected by Governor Fallin's decision. This will disallow access to care for a lot of Oklahomans who work at jobs that pay too little or offer too few hours to qualify for benefits.
As Jon Stewart put it, we are seeing more and more rich Republicans try to disconnect from the social contract and just allow people at the bottom to fall. Walmart pays their employees so little that most of them end up using food stamps or Medicaid--all while Walmart lobbies for Republican efforts to dismantle that very same safety net. At that film premier last night, we noticed a lot of Republican voters who will benefit from Obama's policies for their children, but who (in most likelihood) voted for Romney's promise to repeal those same policies.
We are once again in the place where those who shout "Jesus" the loudest are working the hardest to make life harder on the poor and the sick. And while I am no longer surprised by this, it still makes me sad.
But the fact does remain, that the GOP continues to make life harder on the poor. Here in Oklahoma, our Governor Fallin joins other Republican governors in rejecting both the expansion of Medicaid and the option to create a state healthcare exchange. Both appear to be more about their ongoing battle with Obama and less to do with any heart-felt principled belief. For all the talk about "unfunded mandates," both of these programs could be funded, and would have allowed thousands of Oklahomans access to healthcare.
I understand (though do not share) the argument that people must be required to try to work in order to get public assistance. For me, I don't care if the person is drug addled or stupid or lazy or craven. Their access to the basics of life are disconnected from whether or not I like or respect them. But I get the idea that people might be discouraged from working if they can get food stamps or public assistance (even though the SNAP program is designed to push people off food stamps and discourage dependency).
But I do not understand this in the context of healthcare. We spent last evening at a film premier for a local autism group, and came away quite impressed with the art and the autistic individuals. But we also noted that most of them will need assistance and healthcare--that they will probably not be able to afford for most of their life. Effort isn't an issue here. Nor is it with most of those effected by Governor Fallin's decision. This will disallow access to care for a lot of Oklahomans who work at jobs that pay too little or offer too few hours to qualify for benefits.
As Jon Stewart put it, we are seeing more and more rich Republicans try to disconnect from the social contract and just allow people at the bottom to fall. Walmart pays their employees so little that most of them end up using food stamps or Medicaid--all while Walmart lobbies for Republican efforts to dismantle that very same safety net. At that film premier last night, we noticed a lot of Republican voters who will benefit from Obama's policies for their children, but who (in most likelihood) voted for Romney's promise to repeal those same policies.
We are once again in the place where those who shout "Jesus" the loudest are working the hardest to make life harder on the poor and the sick. And while I am no longer surprised by this, it still makes me sad.
November 15, 2012
November 14, 2012
Romney is exactly what we thought
There was always a part of me wondering if the Romney we imagined through the campaign was a fair depiction. Was he really that disconnected from reality to think that the bottom 47% genuinely just wanted handouts? Did he really not care about the poor?
Turns out Romney was exactly who we thought--a rich asshat who genuinely believes that non-white poor people are moochers. (Romney Blames Loss On Obama’s ‘Big Gifts’ To Voters | TPM2012)
What an ass.
Turns out Romney was exactly who we thought--a rich asshat who genuinely believes that non-white poor people are moochers. (Romney Blames Loss On Obama’s ‘Big Gifts’ To Voters | TPM2012)
What an ass.
November 7, 2012
Obama wins second term
This election cycle has worn on me. Perhaps 2008 was harder, I don't know, but watching Paul Ryan preparing to gut the safety net to finance the wealthy class frightened me. Then there were all the indicators that suggested that Obama would lose, from the economy to the Romney ability to simply lie his way out of any situation.
Yesterday, I prepared for a loss, and so was pretty excited when I saw Obama victories in Pennsylvania.
Watching the two men speak last night, I was reminded of why I like Obama. Romney said all the things he was supposed to, but I have to say he struck me as a person without a core. I am not making too much of that concession speech--I think it is hard to speak well in that situation. But he struck me as someone who just wanted to be President--whatever the voters wanted him to be. This story struck that chord, with someone who knew what the right thing was, but could not act on it because the base and voters would not reward him for that. So he chose the wrong way.
Obama, for all his flaws (and there are many) has always struck me as a genuinely compassionate person. But watching him last night I wondered how it felt differently for him than the last time. This time he knows full well the weight of the job, and had to return to it this morning. Like me, I suspect he felt relief.
Who knows what this four years will bring. I am glad that healthcare is protected for now, and pretty soon, we will see these provisions take place. Still stunning that Obama could be hated and vilified for wanting to make sure people could hold on to healthcare coverage. Something very wrong with that.
In other news, we saw the saw shocking erosion into the War on Drugs in Colorado and Washington state. I am unsure about those changes, but really wonder if part of this is just not a reflection that the war has not worked. My observations at the music festival a few weeks back confirms that. But in a much bigger deal, marriage equality (cue the trolls) passed by a popular vote in several states. As my friend Greg Horton noted on FB, that culture war is over. The only people who don't realize it are those vested in keeping the anger and hatred stoked at the Family Research Council and other like groups.
I believe that the Republican party leadership sees that, and understands that some of their major planks will only survive in states like mine. In the rest of the country, those stances will earn them a minority status. Part of me hopes they continue with the racist madness, but the other part of me hopes that an adult Grownup Republican party returns with a viable and responsible approach to policy.
This blogger stated my hopes for this four years.
Yesterday, I prepared for a loss, and so was pretty excited when I saw Obama victories in Pennsylvania.
Watching the two men speak last night, I was reminded of why I like Obama. Romney said all the things he was supposed to, but I have to say he struck me as a person without a core. I am not making too much of that concession speech--I think it is hard to speak well in that situation. But he struck me as someone who just wanted to be President--whatever the voters wanted him to be. This story struck that chord, with someone who knew what the right thing was, but could not act on it because the base and voters would not reward him for that. So he chose the wrong way.
Obama, for all his flaws (and there are many) has always struck me as a genuinely compassionate person. But watching him last night I wondered how it felt differently for him than the last time. This time he knows full well the weight of the job, and had to return to it this morning. Like me, I suspect he felt relief.
Who knows what this four years will bring. I am glad that healthcare is protected for now, and pretty soon, we will see these provisions take place. Still stunning that Obama could be hated and vilified for wanting to make sure people could hold on to healthcare coverage. Something very wrong with that.
In other news, we saw the saw shocking erosion into the War on Drugs in Colorado and Washington state. I am unsure about those changes, but really wonder if part of this is just not a reflection that the war has not worked. My observations at the music festival a few weeks back confirms that. But in a much bigger deal, marriage equality (cue the trolls) passed by a popular vote in several states. As my friend Greg Horton noted on FB, that culture war is over. The only people who don't realize it are those vested in keeping the anger and hatred stoked at the Family Research Council and other like groups.
I believe that the Republican party leadership sees that, and understands that some of their major planks will only survive in states like mine. In the rest of the country, those stances will earn them a minority status. Part of me hopes they continue with the racist madness, but the other part of me hopes that an adult Grownup Republican party returns with a viable and responsible approach to policy.
This blogger stated my hopes for this four years.
We chose health insurance for those who cannot afford it. We chose a softer approach to those seeking a better life within our borders. We chose – at least I hope we did – to begin healing our suffering planet. We chose the candidate who promised to protect the people who didn’t have a seat at the table of power, whose voices struggle to rise above the lobbyists, special interests and money that have flooded our political system.For now, I will take solace in the fact that the most cynical campaign of my adult experience lost, and with that the billions spent by the Koch brothers and their ilk. The battle isn't over, but today feels better than that Wednesday 8 years ago. Lots to be grateful for today.
Almost as important as what we chose is what we rejected.
We rejected a singular focus on cutting help for the poor to boost the incomes of the wealthy.
November 5, 2012
Republicans and morality
I have a lot of Republican family and friends. They are all, to a person, some of the most honest people I know. I can't imagine them cheating on their taxes or lying to get what they want any more than I can imagine that of my liberal friends.
Yet, my conservative family and friends look the other way when their party attempts to stop people from voting (often based on race). Worse, they will vote for a person who lies more than he tells the truth.
All because he isn't Obama.
I will never understand that contradiction of moral people and an unhinged and immoral party.
November 3, 2012
The problem with the Pro-life movement is that it might not be as pro-life as they think
And no, I am not talking about other areas where they don't defend human life. And in this instance, I am not even talking about pro-lifer's resistance to healthcare and nutrition for infants and young mothers.
All of those are legitimate issues, but now I am struck by the pro-life's disinterest in actually reducing abortions. In my own discussions with some conservatives, I have yet to hear a response to questions about reducing abortions. Their approach is predicated on banning abortions, in all but a few rare instances--most of which can be summarized as "when I think it is ok, not when some pregnant woman thinks so."
This link is an interesting take on some of this, but the other was this mind-blowing study that suggested that Obamacare's access to contraceptives might reduce abortion rates by as much as 75%. If true, and I have no idea as to the study's bona fides, then, as this author notes, Obama becomes a "pro-life hero."
Who knows, but I will say that I have yet to get a conservative to answer this question: "what if banning abortions didn't reduce them, but legalized abortion with good healthcare did?" Not one response.
And I have a hypothesis, at least for some. Many feminists and pro-choicers have argued that this comes from a Puritan disapproval of any sex outside their approved setting. Others have suggested that, at heart, this constitutes a misogyny of the far right that has always been there, but rarely openly expressed as it was during the "Sandra Fluke as slut" incident.
And all of those have some validity, I think. But I also wonder if this is not based at some level in the idea of the deification of motherhood. It isn't that they don't want women to have sex (some of them know, after all, that some of these women getting abortions are married with kids.) But the resistance to reducing abortions, I think, comes from the fact that their goal is to shame any woman who might question having children. How dare a woman turn that down?
If you acknowledge that some abortions are reasonable, and decide to reduce those instances, you still acknowledge that some women don't want to be mothers, or don't want to be mothers in all instances. But if you ignore the reduction strategies and instead push to ban all abortions, you not only shame those who have had them, but also any woman who might consider ending a pregnancy.
All of those are legitimate issues, but now I am struck by the pro-life's disinterest in actually reducing abortions. In my own discussions with some conservatives, I have yet to hear a response to questions about reducing abortions. Their approach is predicated on banning abortions, in all but a few rare instances--most of which can be summarized as "when I think it is ok, not when some pregnant woman thinks so."
This link is an interesting take on some of this, but the other was this mind-blowing study that suggested that Obamacare's access to contraceptives might reduce abortion rates by as much as 75%. If true, and I have no idea as to the study's bona fides, then, as this author notes, Obama becomes a "pro-life hero."
Who knows, but I will say that I have yet to get a conservative to answer this question: "what if banning abortions didn't reduce them, but legalized abortion with good healthcare did?" Not one response.
And I have a hypothesis, at least for some. Many feminists and pro-choicers have argued that this comes from a Puritan disapproval of any sex outside their approved setting. Others have suggested that, at heart, this constitutes a misogyny of the far right that has always been there, but rarely openly expressed as it was during the "Sandra Fluke as slut" incident.
And all of those have some validity, I think. But I also wonder if this is not based at some level in the idea of the deification of motherhood. It isn't that they don't want women to have sex (some of them know, after all, that some of these women getting abortions are married with kids.) But the resistance to reducing abortions, I think, comes from the fact that their goal is to shame any woman who might question having children. How dare a woman turn that down?
If you acknowledge that some abortions are reasonable, and decide to reduce those instances, you still acknowledge that some women don't want to be mothers, or don't want to be mothers in all instances. But if you ignore the reduction strategies and instead push to ban all abortions, you not only shame those who have had them, but also any woman who might consider ending a pregnancy.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)