March 31, 2007

Some funny cartoons






and one of my favorites:

Soldiers as Political props?

Some retired generals send a message to the President starting with Paul Eaton who said:
I'm convinced that he would honor them more if he would refrain from using soldiers as props in political theater
A retired Maj. General from the Army National Guard added:
"I think to use it as a means to discuss the Iraqi supplemental is an insult to the soldiers and what they did. Because it's political exploitation as far as I feel. I think he ought to address the issues concerning their treatment, Walter Reed, etc, etc, etc.

But to take this captive audience that has no choice and use them as I mentioned to exploit and push this, his disdain of the Iraqi supplemental vote in the House and the Senate is completely without foundation. And I think he should know that and that it really doesn't sit well with the rest of us in the military."

Religion roundtable

Or politics, I can't keep them straight.

First item is the fruit of Pat Robertson's labor, placing some 150 Regent-trained lawyers in this Bush administration.
"At Regent, Goodling was drilled in the importance of unflinching loyalty to the Republican program. Once in the Justice Department, she proved an able cog in the Bush administration's political machine, meeting with Republican activists in 2006 to help plot the firing of New Mexico's prestigious US Attorney David Iglesias, a fellow Republican who 'chafed' against administration initiatives.

But as scrutiny of her actions intensifies, the evangelical Goodling resorts to the 5th Amendment -- man's law -- to avoid breaking the biblical commandment against lying. Only the goodly and godly Pat Robertson could have prepared her to make such a decision."

Certainly proof that people like Robertson and Falwell can have an impact--but also more than a suggestion that their thumper-factories are bad for us all.

*****

Andrew Sullivan points us to a couple of stories about public religion. This first is an issue I have thought about before. Why is it that while Jesus sharply rebukes public prayers that call attention to self, that religious conservatives love to pray as loud in public as they can? I remember someone interviewing Falwell and asking him that question. The Jabba seemed to have misunderstood the question because he both agreed with the sense that Jesus chastized self-righteous public prayer AND then said when he and his family ate out, he prayed "as loud as he could" to make sure the other patrons heard him.

Sigh.

The second one is rather intriguing and one I did not know about. I am curious what the theologically trained among us can add to this conversation. One of Sully's readers suggests that the "under God" in the Pledge violates another of Jesus' commandments against swearing oaths.
""Again you have heard that it was said to those of old, 'You shall not swear falsely, but shall perform to the Lord what you have sworn.' But I say to you, Do not take an oath at all, either by heaven, for it is the throne of God, or by the earth, for it is his footstool, or by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King. And do not take an oath by your head, for you cannot make one hair white or black. Let what you say be simply 'Yes' or 'No'; anything more than this comes from evil.""

I don't think I have heard that verse before. This reader clearly saw the Pledge as problematic.
Even if we make room for the necessary "civil" oaths used in courtrooms and other legal matters, it's plain Jesus was recommending that his followers dispense with any voluntary, self-initiated oath-taking. So why the constant agitation over the Pledge? Answer: It's not really Jesus that matters.
Interesting.

March 29, 2007

Don't make me defend THIS God

I debated about this post, but decided to go ahead. Please don't misunderstand me, I am not attacking God. I am suggesting that innerancy and literalism means that people end up having to go through intellectual and theological hoops. I am also having a wonderful conversation with Tony about this very issue.

On the side, btw, I think my friends would agree that religious conservatives would be wise to dump the tools they put on the television (Jabba Falwell, James Dobson, Pat Robertson, Richard Land, John Hagee) and have Tony represent them on the national stage. It might turn out badly for the GOP, but religious conservatives everywhere would be grateful.

But back to my topic... About this OT God. Don't get me wrong. I believe. I choose to believe, and it isn't always easy. And I can even make sense of some of the odder parts of the OT, including this story from 1 Samuel:
Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy [a] everything that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.' '"
If you don't know the story, the Israelites and Amalekites evidently hated each other tremendously, and there are numerous conflicts between the two of them. At this point in the story, God tells the Israelites to wipe them out. All of them. Out.

Growing up, I don't think I read this story or heard it from the pulpit. As an adult, I heard one sermon on the radio, but it focussed on the second part of the story--where the Israelites actually don't kill everyone and get in trouble. God told them to wipe them all out and they greedily saved some of the rich Amalekites and valuable cattle and sheep. The sermon's lesson was always obey God. I once wrote Hank Hannegraf (after all, he is the Bible Answer Man) and he explained it as the Amalekites "had it coming." God had given them numerous chances to repent, he noted, and when the UN refused to enforce the Amalekite no-fly zone, God had no choice but to invade....

Ok, maybe not, but it might as well have been. The "they had it coming" defense certainly makes sense, and when placed in a cultural sense of ancient tribal society, makes perfect sense. It certainly makes sense that in these battles between the two groups, a lot of atrocities were committed--mistakes were made, as it were. It also makes sense that the Israelites, who were recording this particular history, would place themselves in the best light possible. Suggesting that God told them to do this makes sense too.

But please don't ask me to believe that the God of peace, the God of justice, and the God of creation, committed genocide. Don't make me defend infanticide and say that "God's ways are higher than our ways." What is the lesson of killing the women (including, we must assume, pregnant women) and infants? The lesson I take away from that (if forced to read it as literal truth) is that God is a two-faced God--on one side the compassion and love for the humanity he created--on the other side a capricious and angry God who destroys entire peoples. How do people opposed to abortion based on the sanctity of life still believe that the God who created that life and instilled that sanctity was so willing to erase infants and unborn?

And if we look further at the story, we find more inconsistencies. God, we assume, could have done the killing himself, but in this story--amidst the same ancient texts that gives us the vaunted 10 commandments that conservatives tell us will save our sorry moral state if posted on schoolhouse and courthouse walls--God commands these flawed human beings to kill for him. "Thou shall not kill" unless God changes his mind?

I choose to believe. Please don't ask me to believe that God did this. I can accept this story as metaphor and even as an example of how we can and do kill each other. Don't ask me to believe that God so loved the Israelites that he was willing to slaughter their enemies.

Lovely

Feministing: "Last night at Bates College, Phyllis Schlafly gave a lecture titled, 'Conservatism vs. Feminism: The Great Debate' where at one point she contended that a woman can't get raped by her husband: 'By getting married, the woman has consented to sex, and I don't think you can call it rape.'"

March 28, 2007

NPR loves the Ted Leo

And let me reiterate that I would not know about this guy without Ubub. Thanks, dude. You have turned me onto a lot of good music.

NPR : Musician Ted Leo, on Protests and Living on Tour

Just war part deux

Thinking more of the Just Intention qualification. Not only do we have the Abu Ghraib and torture, but we also have the intense fear campaign to justify everything from the Patriot Act to illegal wiretapping. Oh, and lets not forget the Walter Reed scandal, the attempt to cut veterans benefits, and the refusal to send enough troops when generals actually wanted them. I am finding little in the way of good or just intentions here.

Now for the last few:
Last Resort
1. How many times was Hussein given a chance to comply to the UN Resolutions without compliance? 17 - enough said. He was given chance after chance and then intelligence suggested he was upping the ante in seeking weapons of mass destruction. He refused to allow inspectors to confirm or deny this intelligence. And again all the while he was systematically killing his own people.
d.r. was pretty dismissive of some of us for not hewing to the facts, but I don't think there is evidence that Saddam was "systematically killing his own people"--or at least killing them beyond the normal Saddam ruling policies. I have conceded and everyone agrees--the guy was a total dictator and brutal to his own people. But that list is fairly long in the world and this alone is hardly the requirement. As for Last Resort, I find this one of the weakest of the Just War qualifications. Sanctions were working. The inspections were working--despite all the games that Saddam played at every level. Containment was working. This was not our last resort--and refusing to comply with UN resolutions--the very same UN that the Bush administration and conservatives everywhere don't actually respect, by the way--hardly seem like a "last resort."
Probability of Success
1. Did the Americans think that they could remove Hussein from power? Of course, and they did. And now he has been tried, convicted and executed in a great act of justice.
2. Was there evidence that Iraq would move toward a democratic state? Yes, and they have made huge strides in that arena, having held elections, with more to come.
No one doubted that Hussein could be removed from power. This is, and never was the total objective. I suspect that if you got George H.W. Bush to be honest, he would tell you that he would have warned his son that there was not a high probability of success. He certainly was concerned about that in the first Gulf War where his pragmatists and experts warned him that removing Saddam would create a vacuum. Many, many people said that this was a venture fraught with peril, but the President and his people ignored that instead suggested that we would be greeted as liberators. Just as Woodrow Wilson thought his troops landing at Vera Cruz would be greeted.

And to be fair, there is an argument to be made that had this President not sent in someone like Rumsfeld to do this, we might have had a chance. Had we restored power--AND SECURITY--there is a chance that we could have transfered the existing Iraq government into a working democracy--or democracy-ish. Instead, Bush deBathified the government and dismissed the military--sending thousands of people jobless, armed, and angry at the Americans. And lets not forget the Bush policy of filling the reconstruction posts with Bush loyalists--including asking them their stance on Roe v. Wade rather than their qualifications for service.
Proportionality
1. Did the possible good outweigh the bad? Of course they did. This might be the most controversial of the Just War requirements, but again, the Kurds are not extinct, Sadaam is no longer violating the UN resolutions in a hope to resurrect his weapons program and is no longer attacking nations or threatening to do so, and Iraq is now on its way to democracy, if they would just embrace it. Much better than persecuted people in a country that is seeking to persecute others.
d.r. is reaching the most here. While the Kurds were certainly persecuted and ethnically cleansed under Saddam, but they were in no immanent danger of extinction. I have addressed the UN and want to reiterate the irony of conservatives invoking the UN Resolutions--given that many of them would prefer we not even have a UN. And finally, I really detest the line "Iraq is now on its way to democracy, if they would just embrace it." I hate this "blame the Iraqi" approach. It is as if the police went into the wrong house, leveled it, and killed many of the family members. The family had been run by an abusive father, but was functioning. The police come in, kill the father, level the house, and expect the family to function. When they don't, the police chastize the remaining family members.

We broke this country. We don't get to blame them for that.

Just war theory

While I am waiting, I think the parameters for a just war claim are interesting. One of d.r.'s complaints was that I didn't address the issue in depth. Let me remedy that. Here are the first couple, along with d.r.'s response:
Just Cause
1. Did Hussein violate the terms of the cease-fire? YES! - In fact, he violated 17 UN Security Council Resolutions. That was enough justification to remove him, even without weapons of mass destruction (which by the way were discovered - they just were not of the amount the intelligence data said they were, nor were they as up-to-date as suggested).
2. Was Hussein a war criminal, having been convicted of killing hundreds of thousands of his own people? YES - the Kurds cowered in fear of this guy and begged for help. They were the first to embrace the Americans and have by far benefited the most from the invasion of Iraq. If Sadaam was still in power it is possible these guys wouldn't exist now.

Just cause is a biggee here, and one that we as a country are still discussing. And part of that is due to the haziness of the reasons we went in. When we invaded, Bush said it was because Saddam presented a direct and immanent threat to our very security. That was Condi's "mushroom cloud" argument. After we went in and found no wmd (sorry, old and decaying ones are hardly proof of an immanent threat) the justification from the White House switched to "promoting democracy" and because Saddam had "wmd capability." Just cause in this case seems fuzzy. Paul Wolfowitz (one of the war's architects) not only said that Iraq lacked ethnic rivalries, but admitted that the WMD was simply invoked to scare people into supporting the invasion. Sigh.

d.r.'s point two about Saddam's war criminal status is true, but not sure that elevates us to the Just Cause level. Was he a horrible murdering dictator? Absolutely. Had he killed many of his own people in the past? Yes. Was that ethnic cleansing ongoing? No. Not to say that Iraq was warm and fuzzy under Saddam, because we know quite well about his rape rooms and psychotic sons. But that can describe many regimes around the world. If we are about taking out war criminals, we have a long list and better start drafting people.
Just Intention
1. Does America want to rule Iraq? No - we are trying to establish a representative republic in that country.
2. Is American seeking to destroy the Iraqi civilization? No - American troops and commanders have gone out of their way (sometimes with harm to themselves and the mission) to keep civilians alive and away from harm.

Hmm. Just intention is just as fuzzy as just cause. I am sure that most Americans don't want to rule Iraq, but are we that clear about Bush and Cheney? Some neo-cons clearly want to use Iraq as a permanent base to exert American hegemony into the region. Some clearly want to control that source of oil. Are those just intentions? I don't think so.
Point two is where I think d.r. is off the beam. No doubt that many (in fact, most) American military professionals are that--professional--and want to fight this war correctly. But we have ample evidence that people from the top down have decided that we can throw out old rules and fight the "terrorists" on their own terms. Abu Ghraib was not an aberation. The administration itself fought to keep torture as an option and when they could not defeat a bill outlawing torture, Bush added a signing statement giving him the right to torture anyway. Add to that the suspension of habeas review, the attempt to name people as "enemy combatants" and several other tactics used by this administration and I think our intentions are far from clearly just.
Proper Authority and Public Declaration.
1. Did the President have the authority to go to war? YES - and Congress even voted for it in an overwhelming way.
2. Did the government make a proper declaration? YES - the people were told and Congress was informed more than 48 hours before military action, as well as having know the intention weeks before (and voting for it - see above).
Again, this is right to a point. Certainly congress voted to give Bush authorization. Was that based on good information? I don't think so. Everything we know about the intelligence process suggests that Cheney and others within the administration wanted to invade and cherry picked the intelligence to justify that invasion. d.r. accused me of calling Bush a liar, and I certainly have in the past. But I really wonder why Bush still has credibility. He has certainly lied about many things, from being briefed on the danger to New Orleans levys to Karl Rove's involvement in the Valerie Plame outing.

More later.

March 27, 2007

Just War? Or no?

I ran into a defender of this war over at Big Daddy Weave where, I will concede, I lost my cool. Today has been one of those down days where my mood seems to get darker as the clouds roll in. That, and as I told d.r., finding someone who so fully defends Bush in his implementation and decision to take us to war set off the beast.

But as I told him, I am opening the comments to this debate. Knowing what we know now, and even taking a look at what we knew then, can we call this a just war? d.r. says yes. I say no way. His initial comment lays out the terms for the "just war" defense. What say you?

March 26, 2007

IN OVER HIS HEAD

Just saw this interview of Gonzales on MSNBC. Oh, my God, the man is either really, really stupid, or very, very unethical. Or both. And for all of my complaints about the mainstream media, Pete Williams actually asks some questions, and in one case asks the question twice--clearly hinting that the AG had not answered the question:
"Williams: Given that, then how can you be certain that none of these U.S. attorneys were put on that list for improper reasons?

Gonzales: What I can say is this: I know the reasons why I asked you — these United States attorneys to leave. And it — it was not for improper reasons. It was not to interfere with the public corruption case. It was not for partisan reasons.

I also — we also know that there's nothing in the documents that indicates that they were asked to leave for improper reasons. But all — but lastly, just to be sure, I have asked for an internal — review by the Office of Professional Responsibility, working with the Office of Inspector General. And, of course, the Congress is going to be doing its own review because I want to know as well if, in fact, there were improper reasons, we — we should know about it. And there will be accountability.

Williams: To put this question another way — if you didn't review their performance during this process, then how can you be certain that they were fired for performance reasons?

Gonzales: I — I've given — I've given the answer to the question, Pete. I know — I know the reasons why I made the decision. "
Amazing. Gonzales swears that he was not involved in the reasons for the firings, but he knows that the firings were not political.

Gonzales still says that performance is the issue--even though the job reviews suggest the opposite.

Worst President ever. Oh, and btw, Gonzales is trying to hang his deputy on this. And then there is this from freaking Bob Novak of all people
Republicans in Congress do not trust their president to protect them. That alone is sufficient reason to withhold statements of support for Gonzales, because such a gesture could be quickly followed by his resignation under pressure. Rep. Adam Putnam (Fla.), the highly regarded young chairman of the House Republican Conference, praised Donald Rumsfeld in November only to see him sacked shortly thereafter.

But not many Republican lawmakers would speak up for Gonzales even if they were sure Bush would stick with him. He is the least popular Cabinet member on Capitol Hill, even more disliked than Rumsfeld was. The word most often used by Republicans to describe the management of the Justice Department under Gonzales is "incompetent."

--snip--

The I-word (incompetence) is also used by Republicans in describing the Bush administration generally. Several of them I talked to cited a trifecta of incompetence: the Walter Reed hospital scandal, the FBI's misuse of the USA Patriot Act and the U.S. attorneys firing fiasco. "We always have claimed that we were the party of better management," one House leader told me. "How can we claim that anymore?"
Is this where I say "I told you so?"

Sullivan states the obvious

That we have lost the moral high ground. We can no longer chide or berate countries for torture. What an amazing development. In 6 years we have fallen this far. To be fair, we could not stop others from torturing, but now we can't even castigate them with a straight face.
The Daily Dish: Captured Brits: "They are being "interrogated," apparently. The news reports put that word in quotation marks. I wonder if it emerges that they are being subject to George W. Bush's preferred euphemism "coercive interrogations." And if that turns out to be the case, and we have to pray it isn't, then what will the United States and its ally Great Britain say in complaint? After all, Iran is only doing to Western soldiers in captivity what the U.S. has been doing to "enemy combatants" since the war began. Then there's a question of what kind of trial they might face. One in which their defense gets a chance to see all the evidence against them? Oh, wait ... we don't do that either.

The first strategic crisis created by the Bush-Cheney torture regime is now occurring. It won't be the last. And if these British sailors are found to have been mistreated and their "trials" tainted, who in the international community is now going to come to Britain's and America's defense?"

March 25, 2007

More religion roundup

Or should that be "religion?" First item is that talking bobble head himself, Pat Robertson:
"On a recent CBN show, Robertson warned that if Americans keep electing Muslim Americans they will 'take over the government' and turn the country into a theocracy (surely nothing Mr. Robertson has ever contemplated). His solution? Churches should engage in civil disobedience--flagrantly violate IRS regulations and work to get Christians elected. Atrocities documented (including a transcript of his remarks) below."


*****

Item two: Andrew Sullivan points to an odd point of comparison between Islamist and Christian Right policies--keeping the ladies under wraps.
"Ladies, this is where you can get confused. Many women would think guys are ‘all about’ women who flaunt their bodies. I am here to attempt to speak for us Christian men fighting the fight for purity. Women like this disgust and frustrate me. They take advantage of something that God intended to be beautiful. They lure men away from that which they truly love. They make men like me fight and struggle, and cause many to fall. THESE WOMEN SHOULD NOT BE ADORED OR FOLLOWED! Christian sisters, please do not think that this attention is anything more than a result of short-sighted shallow men who are sexually frustrated and unwilling to follow God’s plan for sex. To me, women who flaunt their bodies make me turn my head, repulsed, and pray that God would guard my heart, eyes, and mind, and that somehow He would show them His infinite love, and that they don’t need to act in this way to be loved."
As Sully notes, it is all the fault of women. To be sure, I don't disagree that many young women seem to have learned bad lessons about this--that being cute or sexy is their way to get attention. But blaming their sexuality for male thoughts is ridiculous. This reminds me of an argument I had with a friend of mine. I read a story in the Dallas paper about this Christian group called "Point of Grace" (I think). The interview with the very attractive women revealed that their mission in life (besides singing rather vapid Christian music) was to stop young girls from dressing badly. I admired their dedication and willingness to ignore things like poverty and discrimination. Sigh.

*****

Another story from Sullivan, though I have seen it elsewhere. While more political than religious, it has implications--serious ones--for the religious right and their apparent political power. A recent Pew report suggests that Bush and Rove are doing more to undermine Republican policies than anything that the Dems could dream of.
"Religious intensity is falling; acceptance of gay people is rising. The younger generation is the most secular of any. Support for the military has never been stronger - people don't blame the troops for the war. The country is divided down the middle on torture, but still in favor of preemptive war in some circumstances. Sorry, Dinesh, but women's equality and freedom are values now overwhelmingly popular among all groups, including Republicans, and strongest among the young. Since Bush has been president, there has been a sharp decline in the number of Americans favoring "old fashioned values about family and marriage." In the last ten years, opposition to gay marriage has dropped ten points and support has risen ten points. There has also been a striking twelve point increase in support for affirmative action over the past decade - all of it among whites."
Those trends cannot be good for our GOP brethren, unless they are willing to go back to the GOP of old--one not run by idiots and liars. I suggested that Bush was the worst thing for evangelicals, and it appears the worst thing also for true conservatives.

Perhaps the next GOP candidate will be able to read, speak in complete sentences, and think beyond the dumb (use less drugs).

More on Christian "historical" revisionism

H/T my friend Mary for this story on the effort to place Christian nation "history" into Public school curricula. I think what disappoints me the most is just how disengenuous, secretive, and intellectually dishonest these supposed Christians are.
The NCBCPS Bible course curriculum is a heavily guarded secret but appears to push Christian historical revisionist lies. The Texas Freedom Network (TFN) has been at the forefront of exposing the Christian sectarian bias of the controversial curriculum and, as Southern Methodist University Professor Mark Chancey, who managed to obtain a copy, wrote in a TFN special report, "[ It ] reflects a political agenda... it seems to Christianize America and Americanize the Bible.". The curriculum Chancey writes, recommends Wallbuilders, "an organization devoted to the opposition of church-state separation" and a Wallbuilders video that "argues that the Founding Fathers never intended for church and state to be separated and that America has descended into social chaos since devotional Bible reading and prayer were removed from public schools." That allegation of "social chaos" is not well supported by facts : American national rates of murder, violent crime, teen pregnancy, and divorce have dropped dramatically since the early 1990's

Over the past two decades the creation of revisionist historical works claiming America's founders intended the US as a "Christian Nation" has turned into a booming cottage industry. Meanwhile, esteemed and tenured American historians at the nation's finest Universities have almost completely neglected to address the spread of a fabricated, mythologized Christian right historical narrative on America's alleged origins. That's a shame, because over the past several years a well funded, politically connected, organized effort has succeeded at inserting its course curriculum featuring that fake history into possibly hundreds of American public schools from Texas to New Jersey.

March 24, 2007

FBI abuse of Patriot Act

Interesting. This is what we always feared about the Patriot Act. This anonymous person received an NSL letter, was barred from talking about it, even after the FBI decided it didn't need the information.
My National Security Letter Gag Order - washingtonpost.com: "Three years ago, I received a national security letter (NSL) in my capacity as the president of a small Internet access and consulting business. The letter ordered me to provide sensitive information about one of my clients. There was no indication that a judge had reviewed or approved the letter, and it turned out that none had. The letter came with a gag provision that prohibited me from telling anyone, including my client, that the FBI was seeking this information. Based on the context of the demand -- a context that the FBI still won't let me discuss publicly -- I suspected that the FBI was abusing its power and that the letter sought information to which the FBI was not entitled."

This is kind of funny too

Bible Belt Blogger posts about a Utah coffee shop selling a t-shirt with the image of the angel Moroni blowing a trumpet, with coffee poured into the open end. :)

The Mormon church, shockingly as it may be, lacks a sense of humor. Huh. They assert that the image is a trademark and is pushing to make the coffee shop cease and desist. The coffee shop says it is a parody. Bible Belt Blogger wonders if parodies are exempt from trademark laws. I wonder how a church can trademark a religious figure. Is Jesus trademarked? Steve, as our resident lawyer, perhaps you can help us out.

Because lying is fine with this President

Bush reaffirms support for Gonzales despite the fact that the most recent email dump shows that the AG lied to all of us about his involvement in the Attorney purge.
"WASHINGTON - President Bush is standing firmly behind his embattled attorney general despite Justice Department documents that show Alberto Gonzales was more involved in the decisions to fire U.S. attorneys than he previously indicated.

Gonzales said last week he was not involved in any discussions about the impending dismissals of federal prosecutors. On Friday night, however, the department disclosed Gonzales’ participation in a Nov. 27 meeting where such plans were discussed."
For those expecting the President to emulate his favorite political philosopher, we will continue to wait. WWJD? Lie his ass off, evidently, because Bush is more Custer (Little Big Man style) than the Truman he likes to compare himself to. How dare anyone doubt his decisions to appoint an unqualified political hack as AG? How dare anyone question his use of the Justice Department as his own little fiefdom to go after political opponents.

Gonzales has to go, and if his boss had any integrity at all, he would resign too.

March 23, 2007

Republicans are anti-military

Let's just admit that and move on.
Crooks and Liars � Cost-Efficiency In Discharging Vets: "A six-month investigation has uncovered multiple cases in which soldiers wounded in Iraq are suspiciously diagnosed as having a personality disorder, then prevented from collecting benefits. The conditions of their discharge have infuriated many in the military community, including the injured soldiers and their families, veterans' rights groups, even military officials required to process these dismissals.

They say the military is purposely misdiagnosing soldiers like Town and that it's doing so for one reason: to cheat them out of a lifetime of disability and medical benefits, thereby saving billions in expenses."

I feel hip today

Maybe just for today. Last week, right before leaving for vacation, I heard this great review of Neon Bible, the new album from The Arcade Fire. I bought the album on its release date and so felt like I was on top of things when I heard the album reviewed on NPR. Then today, I heard this review of Ted Leo's new album 'Living with the Living' which I just purchased this week. During the review, they named the three other big indie releases of this year--Neon Bible, Ted Leo, and The Shins. I have all three and feel damn near up-to-date.

BTW, they are all good albums.

Speaking of good music, I like Brandi Carlile, though I thought I would never promote a woman named Brandi with an "i". But that said, she can sing! Her new album is coming out April third and is evidently produced by T-Bone Burnett. Burnett, evidently, encouraged Brandi to record sparsely produced songs live (which I assume means in one take rather than recording the vocal track separate) to give it a more authentic voice. And if the first single is any hint, it works. You can hear it here. (Aside, I read a few review of this single on Itunes and had to laugh when one said that American Idol's Simon would call it "dreadful." Just one more reason to dislike American Idol.)

History and faith

Before I left for vacation, I found this article about conservative Christians and history. Clarkson's argument is that the religious right distorts history and does so on purpose to justify their own political movement. The historical revisionism is rather stark, I must say, as they note about Jamestown:
"John Blanchard claims that the Jamestown landing signifies that, 'We were started as a Christian nation and I feel it's God's purpose we stay a Christian nation.' Indeed, to read The Assembly 2007 web site, one would think that the King had sent missionaries to Virginia. Far from it. The London Company behind the venture pooled investors interested in making money. For years, it floundered badly. Eventually, the company gave up the commercial charter and control reverted to the Crown. The gauzy view of Christians claiming the land for Christ and King is clarified by history."
And this revisionist view goes well beyond the founders and often is just revealed by people who clearly don't understand any historical context. I found this from Chuck Baldwin, who besides being a conservative is also evidently a preacher. Baldwin is convinced that feminism is ruining America:
Feminism - Feminism Destroying America: "In just over three decades, the feminist movement has completely uprooted and rewritten the norm for American family life. No longer are women seen as nurturers and helpmeets. The push for 'equality' has done much more than move America's women from the kitchen to the boardroom; it has moved them from under the arm and next to the side of their husbands to, in many cases, a place of independence from, and lordship over, them."

Sigh. No understanding, or even curiosity about the past. Everyone assumes that 19th century middle class women all doted on their children and did domestic work. No sense that women have been battling for some level of autonomy for a long, long time. And really, what you see is simply an angry white male who doesn't understand that things have changed.

But that isn't all. From his main site, you can find a wonderful little sermon entitled Truth about the Confederate Battle Flag:
You see the Confederate flag has never stood as a racist symbol. If you want racism, you go to the Stars and Stripes. In the South, although there was separation, the blacks respected the whites and the whites respected the blacks. And I will tell you this, there was no trouble in the South back then nor in the 1960's until the North came down and started stirring up trouble. So the Confederate flag is not a racist flag. Secondly tonight, the Confederate flag is not a flag of slavery. It does not represent slavery. Are you listening to me tonight? There was not one slave ever brought into this country under the Confederate flag. Every slave that was brought into this country was brought in by Northern ships under the Stars and Stripes. There was not even a slave brought into this country on a Southern vessel! The slaves were brought into this country on Northern vessels under the Stars and Stripes.
Slavery was the North's fault. And racism in the South didn't exist until Northerners came in and told them what to do. He is correct on one point--there is no doubt that Northerners were complicit in slavery and for most of the 19th century relatively indifferent to slavery and then to Southern racism.

I am afraid all of this is part and parcel of the religious right's revisionist history. Feminism is evil, Jamestown was godly, and the South wasn't racist. No wonder these people love Ann Coulter (loves Joe McCarthy) and Michelle Malkin (defender of Japanese internment).

Sigh.

Rural Americans dying more in Iraq?

Steve S. pointed me to this post that suggests that Rural Americans are bearing a much higher burden in this ill-gotten war.
What does this mean? Just over 3,000 Americans have died in Iraq. If the U.S. population is 300 million, then that's just 0.001% of it. Add into this the fact that the American dead come disproportionately from the most forgotten, least attended to parts of our country, from places that often have lost their job bases; consider that many of them were under or unemployed as well as undereducated, that they generally come from struggling, low-income, low-skills areas. Given that we have an all-volunteer military (so that not even the threat of a draft touches other young Americans), you could certainly say that the President's war in Iraq -- and its harm -- has been disproportionately felt. If you live in a rural area, you are simply far more likely to know a casualty of the war than in most major metropolitan areas of the country.

No wonder it's been easy for so many Americans to ignore such a catastrophic war until relatively recently. This might, in a sense, be considered part of a long-term White House strategy, finally faltering, of essentially fighting two significant wars abroad while demobilizing the population at home. When, for instance, soon after the 9/11 attacks the President urged Americans to go to Disney World or, in December 2006, to go "shopping more" to help the economy, he meant it. We were to go on with our normal lives, untouched by his war.
Also interesting to me, in that Bush polled pretty high in those areas of America--and may still. Rural america is one of those areas where the Republican bait and switch works incredibly well--don't look at the economy or the war, focus on the aborting gays and flag burners.

In other news, btw, Steve and I are discussing gun control in the comments. I am sure we could use some other voices if anyone wants to jump in.