April 12, 2005

Scary, scary stuff

This from Carlos, and Rolling Stone. Read it if you dare, but I am including a few key graphs below (with my own brand of commentary, of course. I apologize in advance for the length and the obscenities, but Roy Moore and Tom Delay bring that out in me. Oh, who am I kidding? Ok, not just those guys, they don't help the early mood. I have watched D. James Kennedy on television, btw, and think that of the televangelists, he always annoyed me the most. Pompous ass usually came to mind when I watched him from his gigantic throne pulpit. I think it was his arrogance about history (big David Barton fan) that got me the most. But read on and see if you really think they have the right ideas.

"Most people hear them talk about a 'Christian nation' and think, 'Well, that sounds like a good, moral thing,' says the Rev. Mel White, who ghostwrote Jerry Falwell's autobiography before breaking with the evangelical movement. "What they don't know -- what even most conservative Christians who voted for Bush don't know -- is that 'Christian nation' means something else entirely to these Dominionist leaders. This movement is no more about following the example of Christ than Bush's Clean Water Act is about clean water."

The godfather of the Dominionists is D. James Kennedy, the most influential evangelical you've never heard of. A former Arthur Murray dance instructor, he launched his Florida ministry in 1959, when most evangelicals still followed Billy Graham's gospel of nonpartisan soul-saving. Kennedy built Coral Ridge Ministries into a $37-million-a-year empire, with a TV-and-radio audience of 3 million, by preaching that it was time to save America -- not soul by soul but election by election. After helping found the Moral Majority in 1979, Kennedy became a five-star general in the Christian army. Bush sought his blessing before running for president -- and continues to consult top Dominionists on matters of federal policy.


"Our job is to reclaim America for Christ, whatever the cost," Kennedy says. "As the vice regents of God, we are to exercise godly dominion and influence over our neighborhoods, our schools, our government, our literature and arts, our sports arenas, our entertainment media, our news media, our scientific endeavors -- in short, over every aspect and institution of human society."


Does the bold quote mean that they will kill people to get there? Ruin reputations? Trample over the rights of people who don't agree? What does that mean? Are they on a "crusade" against infidels like me? Even though I am a Christian? Does that term mean the same thing to them? Or since I don't believe a literal Bible am I not really a Christian?

Problem is that they then turn the Bible into a book of science and history, at the same time they undermine the actual study of science and history. I can certainly speak to the issue of history, and the David Barton/D. James Kennedy school is ahistorical and anti-scholarship. That means they start with the conclusion in mind and simply cherry pick the evidence they want (kind of like a Bush administration finding support for war in Iraq!). It isn't scholarship and it isn't history. It is propaganda.

At Reclaiming America, most of the conference is taken up by grassroots training sessions that supply ministers, retirees and devout churchgoers with "The Facts of Stem-Cell Research" or "Practical Steps to Impact Your Community with America's Historical Judeo-Christian Heritage." "We're going to turn you into an army of one," Gary Cass, executive director of Reclaiming America, promises activists at one workshop held in Evangalism Explosion Hall. The Dominionists also attend speeches by supporters like Rep. Katherine Harris of Florida, who urges them to "win back America for God." In their spare time, conference-goers buy books about a God-devised health program called the Maker's Diet or meet with a financial adviser who offers a "biblically sound investment plan."


Funny aside here. This strikes me as consumer driven as the rest of America and the American church. "Join the dominionist agenda, and make more money than you can dream of--you know, just like Jesus said."

To implement their sweeping agenda, the Dominionists are working to remake the federal courts in God's image. In their view, the Founding Fathers never intended to erect a barrier between politics and religion. "The First Amendment does not say there should be a separation of church and state," declares Alan Sears, president and CEO of the Alliance Defense Fund, a team of 750 attorneys trained by the Dominionists to fight abortion and gay marriage. Sears argues that the constitutional guarantee against state-sponsored religion is actually designed to "shield" the church from federal interference -- allowing Christians to take their rightful place at the head of the government. "We have a right, indeed an obligation, to govern," says David Limbaugh, brother of Rush and author of Persecution: How Liberals Are Waging War Against Christianity. Nothing gets the Dominionists to their feet faster than ringing condemnations of judicial tyranny. "Activist judges have systematically deconstructed the Constitution," roars Rick Scarborough, author of Mixing Church and State. "A God-free society is their goal!"


I don't actually know any liberals who want to remove God from our society--hell, many of the liberals I know are Christian--but if God is like these people, I am open to the idea. :)

Activist judges, of course, are precisely what the Dominionists want. Their model is Roy Moore, the former Alabama chief justice who installed a 5,300-pound granite memorial to the Ten Commandments, complete with an open Bible carved in its top, in the state judicial building. At Reclaiming America, Roy's Rock sits out front, fresh off a tour of twenty-one states, perched on the flag-festooned flatbed of a diesel truck, a potent symbol of the "faith-based" justice the Dominionists are bent on imposing. Activists at the conference pose for photographs beside the rock and have circulated a petition urging President Bush to appoint Moore -- who once penned an opinion calling for the state to execute "practicing homosexuals" -- to the U.S. Supreme Court.


You all have read my thoughts on Moore. In another life, this guy was killing heretics or putting people on trains. The same people who pilloried Clinton (rightfully so) for lying about his sexual misdeeds now seem to have completely forgotten the phrase "rule of law." That only applies to liberals, I guess.

--snip--

To pack the courts with fundamentalists like Moore, Dominionist leaders are planning a massive media blitz. They're also pressuring Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist -- an ally who's courting support for his presidential bid -- to halt the long-standing use of filibusters to hold up judicial nominations. An anti-filibuster petition circulating at the conference blasts Democrats for their "outrageous stonewalling of appointments" -- even though Congress has approved more nominees of Bush than of any president since Jimmy Carter.


This actually makes me think these guys are beatable. They really don't understand politics. If you change the rules, you change them for the other guy too. I don't recall any such calls from these people when Senate Republicans were stonewalling on Clinton nominees. Well, guess what? At some point, this worm will turn and the rule changes you pushed for will allow a liberal (and it will happen sometime) to appoint people like me to the court. Does that scare you?

--snip--[took out some Richard Land blathering about John Lennon.]

The Dominionists are also stepping up efforts to turn public schools into forums for evangelism. In a landmark case, the Alliance Defense Fund is suing a California school district that threatened to dismiss a born-again teacher who was evangelizing fifth-graders. In the conference's opening ceremony, the Dominionists recite an oath they dream of hearing in every classroom: "I pledge allegiance to the Christian flag, and to the Savior for whose kingdom it stands. One Savior, crucified, risen and coming again, with life and liberty for all who believe."


This just pisses me off. Talk about not understanding American history. If this ever happens, I will be immigrating to someplace with brains. This is about as Christ-like as a lynch mob.

Cass urges conference-goers to stack school boards with Dominionists. "The most humble Christian is more qualified for office than the best-educated pagan," says Cass, an anti-abortion activist who led a takeover of his school district's board in San Diego. "We built quite a little grass-roots machine out there. Now it's my burden to multiply that success all across America."


Are you fucking kidding me? I guess that explains their support for Bush. His proclaimed faith overpowers any concerns about his intelligence. I think it was Martin Luther King Jr., who suggested that he would rather have a smart athiest in office than a dumb Christian. Of course, these people think King was a commie, so quoting that is probably a fool's errand.

Cass points to the Rev. Gary Beeler, a Baptist minister from Tennessee who got permission for thousands of students to skip class and attend weeklong events that he calls "old-time revivals, with preaching and singing and soul-saving and the whole nine yards." Now, with support from Kennedy, Beeler is selling his house and buying a mobile home to spread his crusade nationwide. "It's not exactly what I planned to do with my retirement," he says. "But it's what God told me to do."


Wow, and with jerks like this, you wonder why I shudder every time someone says "God told me to....."

Cass also presents another small-town activist, Kevin McCoy, with a Salt and Light Award for leading a successful campaign to shut down an anti-bullying program in West Virginia schools. McCoy, a soft-spoken, prematurely gray postal worker, fought to end the program because it taught tolerance for gay people -- and thus, in his view, constituted a "thinly disguised effort to promote the homosexual agenda." "What America needs," Cass tells the faithful, "is more Kevin McCoys."


Right. Whatever you do, support the bullies. Christ seemed to reach out to the people who were bullied and abused by those in power. That is the problem with the overwhelming image I get from these people who flock to the D. James Kennedy stuff--no Christ. No love for people. No mercy. They are on a crusade to destroy non-Christians or liberal Christians like me, and the language they use suggests that violence could be an option. Whatever happened about reaching out to the poor and the sick? To those who are persecuted? This theology sucks.

--snip--blah blah

The one-two punch of militant activists and big money has helped make the Dominionists a force in Washington, where a growing number of congressmen owe their elections to the machine. Kennedy has also created the Center for Christian Statesmanship, which trains elected officials to "more effectively share their faith in the public arena." Speaking to the group,
House Majority Whip Tom DeLay -- a winner of Kennedy's Distinguished Christian Statesman Award -- called Bush's faith-based initiatives "a great opportunity to bring God back into the public institutions of our country."


See? Being a complete amoral asshole is somehow equivalent to being a Christian Statesman? Pass. I prefer the Christianity of Jimmy Carter, thank you very much.

--snip--[jerk congressman who wants to make it legal for churches to be politically overt and still be tax exempt. I still say, take care of what you pray for, jerk ass]

"You cannot have a strong nation that does not follow God," Jones preaches, working up to a climactic, passionate plea for a biblical republic. "God, please -- God, please -- God, please -- save America!"


Hey! On that last part we agree. I hope God will save America too, but from people like D. James Kennedy.

April 11, 2005

More on sumbitches

Leighton left a comment on the previous post and since Blogger buries comments, I thought I would respond. Plus, his comment ties into some stuff I was pondering the last half of the day. Anyway, he said:
"I don't have a good answer for why this is. maybe it's the widespread terror of dissent and disagreement, maybe it's that every native-born American Christian is conditioned to act as an autonomous PR mouthpiece for the public reputation of the Church, maybe it's that saying the right words really has become more important than understanding and abiding by what those words mean; but I wonder whether complaining about a lack of accountability is really the best angle to take. I have a feeling it might just make people try to make you more accountable."


Interesting insight. I was talking with a friend on campus who is from another faith, and who has some of the same concerns about his church organization that I have about my protestant evangelical one. One of the things that keeps coming up is the nature of institutions. Baptists are raised to see the Catholic church pretty critically, and a big part of that is the huge institution that it has become. But it isn't the "Catholic" part that is the problem, it is the institution, and it seems to me that evangelicals have the very same problem. It is harder to see, because they don't have headquarters that count as a country, but the problems are still there.

And it isn't just the buildings and framework of an institution that are at work here--especially since evangelicals are split between a bunch of denominations and non-denoms. But evangelicals have a history of being on the outside of power. Some didn't want to be in power or participate in politics anyway, and others were simply marginalized because their beliefs were pretty far outside the mainstream of America--and evangelicals often liked that. But now, with an avowed evangelical (though only lip-service) President and numerous powerful representatives in congress, Evangelicals are far from the periphery--they are at the center of power. It is their beliefs on evolution and abortion and school prayer that get first notice now in Washington.

One of the rules of politics is that it is much easier to be the underdog and outsider (look at how Bush continues to portray himself this way--ridiculous as it is) than to be the ruling party. When you are on the outside, you can throw all sorts of stupid shit on the stage and act like you are serious about it. When you get in power, those things start to cause problems. When you are an institution or in power, you lose the fervor of the revolutionary, and become the "man" who has to protect his turf. You stop trying to undermine the system and start defending it. It is the quintessential dilemma of politics, because at that point you find yourself in bed with a whole host of characters that are pretty unseemly. But since you are in power now, you can't very well be too much of a purist--because that will marginalize yourself.

That might explain at least part of what is going on. It still bugs me. Everytime I see Tom Delay on television, or see a conservative evangelical defend him. I know that there are a lot of quality conservatives and quality evangelicals out there--some of them are politicians to boot. Delay isn't one of them, and neither is Bush. Conservative Evangels should reconsider their approach here, because as it stands, they are more interested in power than they are in the very principles that brought them to power.

What do do about faith? 'Sumbitches' and politics

catholic_girl left a great comment that summed up my feelings today. " I get so depressed and angry when I see what these people are doing to Christianity. What do I do? Ignore it? Not an option. Back to the drawing board."

I was reading about Tom Delay this morning. Remember him? He has lately been accused of taking trips and money from foreign lobbyists (something other Repubs defended saying: "everyone does it"--has become the classic defense of conservative everywhere--"democrats do it too" or "the other side is even worse.") and most recently allegations that PACs under Delay's control payed his wife and daughter half a million dollar salaries. I remember when conservatives hated the government and hated how "special interests" profited from government. Evidently it is ok when they do it.

But enough snarking about Repubs. Well, kind of. Delay really gets under my skin. And I am not naive about politics. I have been studying it for sometime and understand that it is not pretty sometime. The old saying about strange bedfellows is so very true. We all find ourselves supporting people that we don't really want as neighbors or friends. I supported Clinton. As the saying goes, he is a "sumbitch, but he is OUR sumbitch." We have all sorts of unlikeable people on the left--Ted Kennedy (btw, think about how much Kennedy still pays for his youth, while all of GWB's has been washed away and then remind me about Christian charity and forgiveness, eh?) Hilary Clinton (still am unsure why she is so hated--except she is strong and smart), Michael Moore (he bugs me too), and many many others. All sumbitches and all ours. But I know they are sumbitches and I have no illusions about their faith or morality. They are politicians, and I support what they do for me and the country, period.

Back to Tom Delay. As you can see, I have no problem with voting for a sumbitch. So, I can deal with my conservative friends voting for him. But Delay presents himself as a good conservative Christian. He has said that his Christian faith is very important to him and that informs his views on evolution, school prayer, abortion, etc.

Yet he is a complete dick. I mean prehaps the worst kind of human you can find. He treats his enemies with nothing approaching Christian charity--after all he is known as the "hammer." He makes a big deal about his church attendance in Sugarland and wears his affilation on his sleeve. Yet, he is a total dick. A horrible excuse for a human being. A real sumbitch.

The problem I have is that good Christian people are not calling him to task. This is exactly what I was talking about, well, this whole last year or so. When you make overt Christianity a political commodity, you are asking for this. You are demanding to be lied to, to be conned. You are asking for sumbitches to pledge their undying devotion to Jesus for your vote!

This is not good for our democracy. It isn't good when you make excuses for a scumbag like Delay, or you elect a Bush for vague statements about his faith. But worse, as I noted around the election, you do irreparable harm to the faith. I no longer respect so many who quote the bible and talk about moral values and "right and wrong." Why should I? If Tom Delay can compare himself to Christ and you don't blink? Or if George W. Bush can mock a condemned woman or play the race card in South Carolina and you say he is "a good Christian man?" Your credibility on the big issues of the day is shot.

Our republic is harmed, for sure. But the modern Church is harmed even more. Time for the grownups to stand and be accounted.

April 10, 2005

You know those Grownup Republicans? Well, none here:

Thanks to Shaun at Upper Left for this link. Evidently the fringe of the Radical Right met in Washington to bemoan the activist judges. Read the Washington Post story and tell me that these people really believe in a loving God. Phyllis Schafly is bad enough, but Michael Farris, the guy who is the most active defender of homeschooling, has suggested that judges be impeached in huge numbers, and that congress--that's right, the congress of people like Tom Delay and Hastert--should be able to vacate judicial positions. Nothing like the "rule of law." The article also highlights a guy who hints that Delay and Cornyn are right, that somehow the people who are so badly offended by the judicial decisions should take their disagreements to the street. Kill the judges. What's a democracy for, anyway, if you don't get your way?

I keep saying that I am waiting for the grownup repubs to show up. Chris Shays has spoken out, as has Danforth, but we have yet to see if the others will show up.

I am also waiting for the grownup Christians to denounce the hatred exhibited by Schlafly and Farris. I am waiting for the people who wear their faith on their sleeve to show some humility and accountability. I would like to see any evidence that they actually believe in a loving God, the one the NT talks about with the gentle Shepard. Instead, I see hatred and ignorance masquerading as faith.

Any wonder I would rather pass on this?

April 9, 2005

Arthur Schlessinger Jr. on politics and faith

This is actually from last fall, but I just read it. This is a real historian, one who has been in the primary documents. David Barton should take notes. He won't.

Jesus Politics: The White House Wasn't Always God's House: "A fanatic, as Finley Peter Dunne's fictitious Mr. Dooley said, does what he thinks the Lord would do if he only knew the facts in the case. The most dangerous people in the world today are those who persuade themselves that they are executing the will of the Almighty.

Lincoln summed it all up in his second inaugural address. Both warring halves of the nation, he said, had read the same Bible and prayed to the same God. Each invoked God's aid against the other.

As Lincoln said, ' … let us judge not, that we be not judged…. The Almighty has his own purposes.'"

April 8, 2005

President Jesus: Pope version

President Jesus has refrained from giving press conferences lately, but decided to meet the press on the occasion of the Pope's passing.

President Jesus: "Thanks for coming everyone. Hey, where is that gay prostitute I used to call on all the time? He asked easy questions. I miss him. Anyway, today, I would like you to call me President Jesus the Pope, out of reverence for the pope, you know, that John Paul Ringo guy. I will take your questions."

Non gay prostitute reporter: "Mr. President, what do you have to say about the Pope's passing?"

President Jesus: "As I have said many times, I love the Pope. He and I both shared a great devotion to what I call, the "culture of life." Funny story really. I was talking to Dick about our torture policy--by which I mean that we are against torture--and Dick and I talked about how much the Pope agreed with us. He was a truly great man."

Other reporter: "Mr. President, what about your differences with the pontiff?"

President Jesus: "Who? What? Is that a part of the liberal media? Oh, the Pope. We didn't disagree on much. We both shared that culture of life thing I mentioned earlier. We both like life. We talked about it many times when he called me to oppose the war in Iraq or to try to get me to stop executing people. We both say that life is important. We both wanted to keep the evil husband from killing poor Terry Schiavo. I loved her life and the press time that we got from it. Sniff."

Other reporter: "Mr. President, if we can change topics, can you address the social security crisis and your plan for it?"

President Jesus: "It is a crisis and I don't have a plan for it. I simply want the country to know that the government cannot be trusted to pay what it promised. The US government is terrible with money and does not operate with any kind of, what I would call, "integritivity." Do not trust your government."

Same reporter: "Mr. President? Aren't you the government? Aren't we all the government?"

President Jesus: "Heh heh. Where did you get that idea? You probably went to an Ivy league school. No, the government is a bunch of greedy and inefficient bureacrats whose sole purpose in life is to rob you of your hard earned money and waste it. Hell, they actually burn your money. Did you know that? Why would you trust those evil bastards with your hard earned tax money? What have they ever done for you? "

Same reporter now sighing and considering relocating to Canada: "Mr. President, the government has given tax breaks and government contracts to people like your family. The government has built roads, schools, clinics and hospitals. The government has financed cheaper gas and helped people start businesses. The government has subsidized research into disease prevention and cures. The government has assisted the poor and disabled and helped the country's farmers. Social Security has been one of the most popular government programs since its inception in the 30s because it has created a shared American identity."

President Jesus: "What now? Whosit? I think we know where communism went after it left my friend Pooty Poot in Russia."

Reporter now considering suicide in press room: "Mr. President, what do you say to those Americans who have concerns about your "proposed" social security changes?"

President Jesus: "I would say to my fellow Americans: better start saving because the government gravy train is being rerouted to Westchester county! Heh heh. (shoulders shaking at his own humor) If you voted for me, I say you are smart, and will obviously save enough money to keep from eating dog food. If you voted against me, I couldn't care less about you."

Reporter tightening noose around own neck: "Don't you actually represent all Americans--not just those who voted for you?

President Jesus: "No. I do not. If Dick Cheney had his way (and it is under consideration) we would just ship all democrats to Gitmo so that we would have more, what I like to call "unificatorium" and less "Anti-Americanitis. Now, why did that guy just hang himself in the press room?"

Friday advice: Stop listening to David Barton

Thanks to Bruce and Carlos for this
link
. I have written about Mr. Barton in the past and I wince everytime I see him on TV or hear about him spreading his "history." As this points out, those who decry "revisionist" history (though revisionist is also good history) should be mad at Barton too. He is the one who is simply picking and choosing what he wants to emphasize. He is the one who lacks any historical professionalism or scholarly integrity. Be mad at him.

"I first became acquainted with Mr. Barton in the early 1970's when I was a staff member of the Christian Life Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention.  For the past 30 years, Barton has been evangelizing his extremist beliefs that the separation of church and state is a myth and that the United States was founded as and should be governed as a Christian nation; this is bad history and dangerous theology.  By having Mr. Barton as a host of a religious heritage tour, you send a volatile message to all Americans that Washington has once again overstepped its bounds and is endorsing revisionist history along with advancing a right-wing agenda. Given the present mood of the country and the questionable role that religion has played in Washington recently, these are treacherous waters to be treading."

April 6, 2005

Republican leadership--Columbian style

Thanks to LG for the link. Like I have said multiple times, I am waiting for the grownup Republicans to appear and retake their party. Instead, I am watching as thugs and posers masquerade as conservatives. The grownup Republicans--you know, the ones who actually believe in conservative ideas--appear to be missing in action--as missing in action as their leader was in Vietnam, and as missing in action as his putative Christian beliefs.

But hey! What's a little domestic terrorism among friends. Once Cornyn and Delay have cleared the way for idiots and zealots to take violently what they can't legally, that will be it, right? No other thugs and liars will seize on the opportunity, right? We won't find ourselves ruled by mob law and emotional bullshit, will we? After all, the courts should really just act like the majority rule. Maybe the comparision isn't Columbia, but more the Muslim world where religious extremists rule and judges either come from their bigoted schools or cower in fear.

Anyway, read this and think about writing your representatives and perhaps the President. We can argue all day about the founding, but we sure as hell didn't come from people like Cornyn and Delay. Just imagine that the President is still Clinton and the words will come magically to you: "Rule of Law." This time, it's not just about oral sex. It's about our democracy.

The New York Times > Opinion > Editorial: The Judges Made Them Do It: "Listeners could only cringe at the events behind Mr. Cornyn's fulminating: an Atlanta judge was murdered in his courtroom by a career criminal who wanted only to shoot his way out of a trial, and a Chicago judge's mother and husband were executed by a deranged man who was furious that she had dismissed a wild lawsuit. It was sickening that an elected official would publicly offer these sociopaths as examples of any democratic value, let alone as holders of legitimate concerns about the judiciary.

The need to shield judges from outside threats - including those from elected officials like Senator Cornyn - is a priceless principle of our democracy. Senator Cornyn offered a smarmy proclamation of 'great distress' at courthouse thuggery. Then he rationalized it with broadside accusations that judges 'make raw political or ideological decisions.' He thumbed his nose at the separation of powers, suggesting that the Supreme Court be 'an enforcer of political decisions made by elected representatives of the people.' Avoiding that nightmare is precisely why the founders made federal judgeships lifetime jobs and created a nomination process that requires presidents to seek bipartisan support.

Echoes of the political hijacking of the Terri Schiavo case hung in the air as Mr. Cornyn spoke, just days after the House majority leader, Tom DeLay, vengefully vowed that 'the time will come' to make the judges who resisted the Congressional Republicans' gruesome deathbed intrusion 'answer for their behavior.' Trying to intimidate judges used to be a crime, not a bombastic cudgel for cynical politicians."

April 5, 2005

Red Lake, public memory, and our scripted lives

Indian Country Today (Thanks to Cold in Laramie for the link) is talking about the media coverage of the Red Lake tragedy. As we have discussed here, America has responded in different ways to this particular school shooting. Columbine was a "massacre" but Red Lake is a "shooting." Why?

Some say that we are inured to the tragedy because it is certainly not the first school shooting. But clearly had this happened in suburban Dallas, the coverage would have been different. Some speculate that the closed reservation and lack of 24 hour news mindless looping of events led to that. I can certainly understand that, but the initial reaction was even different and muted. Our great compassionate conservative Christian President couldn't be bothered to tear himself away from Terry Shiavo to even comment on the tragedy. I think race has something to do with the reaction.

I have been thinking about how I react to certain things. I fear that at times I still look for cues as to how to respond--what does a good liberal say in times like this? I don't like that response, but suspect that I am not alone there.

I was thinking about that and thought that we all probably (to greater and lesser degrees depending on the person) have a script--a world view that explains how we see that experience outside our lives. When an event happens--Terry Shiavo, the Pope, Iraq, Tom Delay--we read the event through that script. It plugs in pretty naturally in a way that most of us don't even consider.

I think for white America, Red Lake was outside the script. Native Americans have existed on the fringes of our experience. They exist as images and icons--mascots and movie screens. White America looks at the Native American mascot controversy and thinks, "how trivial is that?" Many NA's look at that same controversy and think, "here we are again--existing only as plastic beads and feathers, not real people." Indians remember that in California, for example, the native population dropped from 150,000 to 30,000 in 12 years! In a little over a decade, 120,000 California Indians were either mass murdered, died of disease or abuse--hunted down, starved. California miners hunted Indians for fucking bounty! The miners had to return with body parts to redeem for their pay. Small children were either enslaved or murdered.

Those stories are often not part of our script for American history. How do we fit that into our great progressive or divine history? How do we plug that into an upward movement for freedom and equality? How do we put that into the great past where Americans prayed and worshiped God en masse?

We don't. We just look past them. Leave them out of the script so we don't have to reconcile them with our broader ideological beliefs. So, all across Indian country, people are thinking that Red Lake is no difference. For White America, it doesn't compute. 10 dead on a reservation just doesn't fit in the script. It doesn't fit well into a anti-gun control or pro-gun control rant; nor (though some have tried) into a vapid "taking prayer out of schools has caused all our problems" script. It is as if our sense of Indians as "West of Everything" is still very much a part of our understanding.

Maybe it would behoove all of us to get off the script a little more and see the world through fresh eyes--understanding that our simplistic framing doesn't always work.

Conservative red meat

This story is making the rounds in the blog world. Evidently, Texas Senator Cornyn speculated that the recent courthouse shootings or violence against judges was a populist anger at activist judges. As many are noting, this is tantamount to justifying domestic terrorism.

Unfortunately, the right wing, and especially the conservative Christian crowd seems very vulnerable to certain conservative mantras. One is the myth of the liberal media--which allows people like Rush Limbaugh and James Dobson adopt the underdog role while they are actually more closely linked to the centers of power than their liberal advesaries. Conservative talk radio and think tanks have effectively controlled the dialogue on so many things (like taxes), but still they play the "minority under attack" role. That is annoying.

The other dominant mantra is the "activist judges" one that you hear on every talk show. Judges are somehow intruding on the democratic process and ruining our society, or at least that is what I hear. That is the only thing that can explain something as stupid and fucking irresponsible as what Cornyn said. Think about it. This is what happens in Columbia. People who don't like the judiciary shoot the judges. That isn't America, or at least it shouldn't be.

This speaks to the mindless approach so many people bring to the discussion of democracy. As if America was supposed to be some kind of pure democracy where majority rules, period. Is that really what you want, Red America? Judges are there to protect ourselves from our impulses for democratic tyranny. Remember that democratic (he who has the most votes wins) gave us slavery, segregation, anti-miscegenation laws, separate water fountains, anti-Chinese immigration. And while the courts have often been slow to correct those abominations, they have at times spoken against the mob. Those who side with the mob should at least consider that they are in a mob.

So, the next time you get a fund raising letter saying that activist judges killed Terry Shiavo, think about it. Think about whether you want Tom Delay using your personal tragedy to further his political career. Think about how emotional some responses are. Think about what democracy means when you are in the minority. Think.

April 4, 2005

Death penalty and the Bible

As reported many places, (and thanks to Vaughn for the link) the Colorado Supreme Court ruled that this jury incorrectly turned to the Bible for their justification of sentencing this guy to death.

CNN.com - Death sentence by jury that discussed Bible thrown out - Mar 29, 2005: "Harlan was sentenced to death in 1995, but defense lawyers learned that five jurors had looked up such Bible verses as 'eye for eye, tooth for tooth,' copied them and discussed them while deliberating behind closed doors."


What really bugs me about this is something I have argued in the past--that people are selectively drawing on the OT when they want an angry God who likes to smite. But they ignore the NT stance on forgiveness and tolerance. As Salaam noted in my comments one time, in the NT, Jesus spoke out for women who had committed adultery--a crime that merited the death penalty under OT law. So, a jury reaching into the bible with no other context is simply looking for a justification to kill this man. Bad theology. Bad law. Good decision by the court.

Really nice blog entry

Marisa over at Sensory Overload is a great writer who often really engages my attention. This one is fabulous about her new job and explaining it to her Dad in what she calls a "twangy-Spanglish-cluttered way of talking." Anyway, if you don't read her stuff, give it a look.

Back

Back and glad to be back. It was a good trip. As I wrote earlier, I learned a lot about myself. I may write more about that later.

Went to a powwow on Saturday. I like them and was glad I got the opportunity. I love the drum singers. I love watching the group work and try to figure out who is leading. I even like the fact that I seem to be the only one in the room that doesn't pick up the cue that the song is ending.

Going to powwows makes me so very hyper conscious of community ritual. I watch the kids out there on the floor or the friends talking and mingling between the singers and dancers and think of my own experiences. Did I do that with county fairs? Church picnics? The weekly football games in our small town?

I don't know. For some reason those don't feel the same to me, but then again, I wasn't watching them with that in mind. I just was there.

Anyway. Good to be back.

April 2, 2005

Laramie Ghosts

I blogged early this month on the ghosts that haunt me.

Today I spent some time in the archives and found family names on the pages--pictures and memories. Ghosts that jumped off the page, flashed past the buildings and landmarks, and flitted across the faces.

This trip has been a revealing one for me. I think Sherman Alexie's talk was really good. His call for all of us to stop taking ourselves, our self-proclaimed wisdom, senses of normal and abnormal, etc., so fucking serious was a good thing to hear.

It has been interesting in other ways too. I gave two talks, and that is an interesting experience. So very easy to assume things about myself and the audience when I am in front with their eyes (some, anyway) fixed on me. I can see how people lose perspective, myself included.

NPR had an interview with a guy who has written a lot about how modern people are constantly acting in ways that they perceive they should. We so internalize media messages, or other messages, and I think his point was that we are rarely authentically ourselves, and may not even know what that is. We are walking, talking, etc. in mannerisms that we have picked up from other places. Sort of a by-product of the method acting school.

I have been very conscious of that in my interactions with church. I noticed early on the language and posture and pose that people struck in church settings. Voice patterns change, mannerisms are affected, etc. Alexie's talk really reinforced that, and I was struck at my own participation in that. When I was in front of those 30 people one night, or those 50 people the next day, I affected my own mannerisms--projected my own idea of having something to say that they needed to hear. I try not to have two many of these personalities. I am conscious (as much as I can be) of some of that and try not to affect more than I need to. I try to act the same around different groups of people. But I am conscious of that play-acting that NPR discussed.

But back to the ghosts. When I saw those photos and names of family members, I experienced something both unexpected and cool. I felt an emotional connection that surprised me--took me off guard, and seemed to move outside that often contrived way we respond. It was genuine and authentic, and I am glad for it.

Maybe those are the ghosts that reach from the past and make us aware of our own insignificance and value all at the same time.

I like ghosts.....



Great lines from Sherman Alexie

"Liberal males only objectify women in their peripheral vision."

"All of us are racist, sexist, homophobic. That is our natural reaction. What matters is the next reaction."

He had a pretty good bit on courtesy. People who put their seats back on airplanes don't care about other people's personal space. He also pointed out to all the cell phone users that they really don't need to shout to be heard.

April 1, 2005

ICTHUS: Tom Delay Compares himself to Christ

thanks to Vaughn for this link: Tom Delay has very little self-awareness.

ICTHUS: Tom Delay Compares himself to Christ: "DeLay is particularly joyful today because it is Sunday and the Cadillac is headed toward the First Baptist Church of Sugar Land, where he will pray to God, as he does every day. He and Christine will warmly greet many church friends. He will call out 'Amen' repeatedly when Pastor Scott Rambo delivers a bloody, fervent sermon on the agonies of Jesus on the cross. DeLay will sing vigorously and pray quietly and then when the spirit moves him will kneel down at the altar, eyes closed in silent prayer, as he has so often in a life sometimes troubled by self-doubt and by the pain of alcoholism and dysfunction in his family.
--
As we leave First Baptist, I ask DeLay about the many citizens who would be quite uncomfortable with the idea that he would mold the government in the belief that his religion - fundamentalist Christianity - had the only answers to society's problems.

DeLay looks me squarely in the eye and shakes his head sadly. 'When faced with the truth, the truth hurts. It is human nature not to face that . . . People hate the messenger. That's why they killed Christ."

More Sherman

Alexie was really good tonight. I am writing this after the talk, but won't be able to post it until sometime tomorrow. But I thought I needed to get some of this down before I sleep. And I am exhausted. Two presentations in two days has taken more out of me than I expected.

Back to Alexie. A really interesting guy. I didn't realize he had a background in standup comedy, but his performance is really good--really honed and sharp. Unlike a straight stand-up, his was more hybrid of comedy routine and serious discussion on the issues of the day. If you have read his stuff, this will make more sense.

This talk was all about the Matthew Shepard murder--and the symposium associated with it is dedicated to social justice. Alexie did a great job of addressing that, but an even better job of challenging perceptions on everything from sexuality, to political bias, to fundamentalism. He challenged all of us in the audience to confront our own fundamentalism--be it vegan or conservative christian--and recognize that we become rigid out of fear.

I liked that. He made fun of white liberal anti-war types (and Streak was nudged by colleagues). He made fun of conservative christians who defend Mel Gibson's film, but really ignore that the real radicalism of Christ was the resurrection and forgiveness. He challenged all of us on race and sexism.

His conclusion was pretty cool. A lot of what he had to say was about the superficiality of what a lot of our obsessions are. We focus on the sexual act, but ignore the issues of the heart. He challenged us to think deeply about questions, and distrust conclusions and especially easy conclusions--be they from liberal professors or fundamentalists preachers who use Leviticus to base their "truths" on.

He ended with his ritual--his ceremony or daily prayer. Every morning he gets up and says two things to himself: both were self-examination. One was about his battle with alcoholism, that is successful, and the second was to remind himself that "everything he said that day was bullshit." As he noted, he has been better at not drinking that at not taking himself too seriously.

Everything I said today was bullshit.....

March 31, 2005

Sherman Alexie--live blogging

Well, not really. But we are front row to hear him speak. He signed a book for me an hour ago and now we are sitting in the auditorium getting ready. I have missed hearing him speak before, so this is nice.

The additional fact that the auditorium has wireless is cool. Cold In Laramie let me use his logon for this post.

So, for those of you outside Wyoming, go read "The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven," or "Reservations Blues" and think of Streak and Cold in Laramie.

Oh, and it is still really cold here.

And Windy.

Wyoming continued

Still here.

Still Windy.

And a funny thing happened yesterday. It snowed. It was hilariously freezing.

Wyoming.

March 30, 2005

Purpose driven profit?

From Bad Catholic a great post on receiving a mailing that mentioned the Atlanta hostage situation and Warren's book, and then plugged the purchase of the same book. I agree with catholic_girl on this one. Crass, crass, crass.

March 28, 2005

Streak goes to Wyoming

Road trip! Yeah, I am off to Wonderful Wyoming where the wind makes Oklahoma look like a patio fan. Where it snows in August, and July, and June.

Anyway, off to speak at a symposium. Taking the Streak's Blog to public sphere, as it were. Don't worry, I will keep the obscenities to a minimum. No more than I need, but no less.

I hope to blog from there, but who knows. Electricity just got there last year, so internet is shaky. Only have Playstation 2, an easy game with the host, and then the post game mocking.

Then it will snow.

March 27, 2005

Republicans....bah

Ok, I need to buy one of these because I keep watching that damn Fox News.

Watching is really a misnomer. I flip past and sometimes watch to see just how bad they are. When Brit Hume was interviewing Bill Richardson and Newt Gingrich, I watched for a bit--kind of like watching a 2 on 1 basketaball play.

Sure enough, Brit acted just as I thought. When the topic of Shiavo came up, Hume asked Richardson about it. Richardson said that he thought that true conservatives would be bothered by the congress and President intruding on this family affair. Hume pointed out (correctly) that many of the family members disagreed with him. Richardson misspoke then saying that if he were in that position, he would want to keep her alive, but would not turn to the congress, president and the courts.

That last part was the mistake and Newt pounced--saying that liberals wanted convicted murderers on death row to have appeals, but not innocent people in hospital beds. Balls. Hume pointed out that the state's right's argument had been used to defend segregation. Right. Of course, Hume never trotted that out when Bush believed in state's rights. You remember that--before he used the Supreme Court to override the Florida courts? To win the Presidency? (note, I really don't care about that particular case, but it does violate the President's own words. Of course, most of his policies do that, but who is counting? Certainly not his supporters).

But see what Newt did? He pulled a little slight of hand--focusing on an appeals process to say that liberals like murderers more than Terry Shiavo. That is a rhetorical falsehood. First, no one has said that the courts should not be involved in this situation, though everyone notes that it would be easier if the documentation was in place to make the courts less necessary. But if you were listening to Newt, you would think that the Shiavo family supporters have had no legal access. This case has been litigated in and out. Appealed and then appealed. Some thought the family took that too far, but I didn't hear anyone trying to limit that access. They used the courts--they just didn't get the result they wanted.

What conservatives should be--and most are--mad about is the congress and President intruding on this. And there, Richardson was just outplayed by the Newt. Conservatives used to believe that the government should stay out of things like this. Some still do. But don't tell Newt and Fox news. They really operate from one "principle"--whatever keeps us in power is our principle.

Can we dispense with any notion of Republican responsibility or principle?

MSNBC - House OKs $37 million for Wal-Mart H.Q. road : "BENTONVILLE, Ark. - The U.S. House has approved a federal highway bill that includes $37 million for widening and extending the Bentonville street that provides the main access to the headquarters of Wal-Mart Stores Inc."


That's right. We are cutting services for the poor, the disabled poor and veterans who fought for this country. Meanwhile the congress can provide $37 million for the richest and biggest corporation in the country. Nice. What conservative principle is this?

Just remember this the next time Republicans lecture Democrats on the role of government.

March 26, 2005

Differences

I was watching PBS last night briefly and saw Tucker Carlson. He bugs me. I want to like him, but I just can't. I know he is better than the Sean Hannity's and Bill O'Reilly's, but he is still a dick. And this interview really showed me why.

He was interviewing an MD who was talking about the sex offender who killed that young girl in Florida. Clearly a tragic case with a guy who had been caught before and released. Carlson was talking about how we needed to just lock up all the sex offenders and keep them locked up. The doctor kept trying to explain why that was a bad idea. He kept pointing out the wide variety of sex offenders from the sexual predator (clearly dangerous) to the inappropriate (flasher, perhaps). Mary Kay Letourneau is a sex offender, but we don't really fear her killing anyone, do we? Carlson kept wanting to lump them all together. That doesn't work, and isn't really American, is it?

The other part that really bugged me was when Tucker asked the Doc about what creates a pedophile. The doctor was great and tried to explain the complexities of it. He pointed out that no one chooses this--no one wants to be sexually attracted to pre-pubescent kids. That said, he was not excusing them, but noting that they were not doing this willfully. Many of them are abused themselves as kids--again not an excuse, but certainly important to note. The doctor said that when something like this happens in Florida, there is a lot of blame to go around--first and foremost the offender, but in this case, the legal system had just tried to incarcerate this guy into not doing this. No counseling, no help--just jail. The doctor said that our society as a whole had failed here.

Tucker would hear none of that, and it dawned on me that might be one of the differences between many liberals and many conservatives. Tucker wanted one cause, one cure, and one responsibility. He wanted it clear cut. I watched that and thought the doctor made a great point. There are multiple causations to most things. I can say that we as a society fail young men when we don't do a lot of things. If we leave them in poverty, with no education or way out, make guns readily available--we should not be surprised when they commit crimes. Is that an excuse for the individual criminal? No. They are responsible as individuals for the choice they made, but we as a society are also responsible for not doing more. I don't see a problem with that. No need to absolve the kid for doing the crime, but can also concede that with better opportunity and education, he might not have done it.

That might explain how conservative American responded to 9-11 v. liberals. Liberals like myself looked at that event and thought that there were a lot of reasons and history behind that event. Arming the rebels in Afghanistan made a lot of sense in the early 80s, but it came back to bite us. Our dealings with muslim moderates in the 1950s in Iran led us to support the Shaw of Iran. Our policy of valuing oil over human rights and playing cold war politics with third world lives had come back to haunt us.

That said, there was no excuse for what those hijackers did. That was an act of evil, I don't deny. Why can't we talk about both? Raising the first one tends to lead conservatives to accuse me of blaming America. Why? Why are the people who generally hate government and assume it is inefficient and dangerous so sure that our foreign policy has been perfect? Why is my suggestion that we had encouraged a good bit of hatred throughout the world seen as an apology for Atta and his fellow hijackers?

There are multiple things at work. Just as that child abuser is responsible for his actions, those hijackers are to blame for the dead on 9-11. But we play a role in both. It isn't about making excuses for evil, or blaming the US, but noting things that we can do to improve. We can take steps (not under this administration, perhaps) to try to reach out to developing countries and try to ensure those people that we don't bomb them capriciously. We can try to be more consistent in our dealings with leaders and avoid (when we can) supporting dictators and secret police simply because we both have a common enemy.

In the child abuse case, we can try to be more proactive. When we know of cases that send up flags, we should do what we can with therapy and counseling. In other words, we should do what we can to help people who are clearly broken. If they don't avail themselves of that help, or still choose to abuse, then we have the obligation to protect the public from such people.

I, for one, am tired of conservative bashing liberals as bleeding hearts who coddle people. I don't coddle. But I also think that life is more complicated than many conservatives seem to want to believe. And complicated situations--terrorism, child abuse, crime, poverty--take complex and nuanced approaches.

I don't think that makes me an American hater, nor an apologist for abusers.

The right is dangerously wrong

Commenter Bill Wilson posted this link on his blog whereKos points out that the political grandstanding of people like Delay and Bush, added with the completely irresponsible coverage on the "news" (think referring to Michael Shiavo as a Nazi, or as Greg just posted, Fox using John Edward (psychic) to tell us what Terry Shiavo is feeling) has dangerous implications. The FBI just arrested a man who was going to kill Michael Shiavo, and there have been numerous death threats against him and the judge that ruled agains the wacko right.

Is this really a "culture of life?" Have you all lost your minds? Seriously. Have we really come to the point when the church going public is going to look on as their elected officials and Fox News essentially push for anarchy? If one other person dies in this case, it will be the responsibility of the asswipes on television and Pat Robertson who have stoked this into a frenzy.

I am thinking about this a lot because I am giving a talk next week on stereotypes where I argue the simple idea that when you have dehumanized the other into an "evil" person, you have very little recourse but to kill them. We see it throughout our history, but are seeing it endorsed now from the highest levels.

Think about this. This could be any of our families in this mess. We could be looking at a loved one in a coma and grappling with this horrible situation. Imagine turning on the tv and seeing Tom Delay declare that your loved one was sent by God to help him! Or flipping on the news and seeing assholes like Robert Novak flippantly decide that you are an immoral and possibly evil person because of your stance. Your family tragedy exposed for all to see and politicians from the Right taking to podiums and microphones everywhere to talk about your tragedy. This isn't right. Not by any stretch.

March 25, 2005

Read this

Thanks to Streak's other friend. The Real Live Preacher is usually good. This one is better than most.

"My oldest daughter doesn’t believe in God anymore, so she says. She told me this recently at Starbucks."

Read this.

Bush rewards wealth, not service

Sojo nails it. I am sorry. How do conservative supporters defend this budget? As this article suggests, no President has cut taxes (especially for the rich) during a war. Think about it. We are giving the wealthiest Americans tax cuts while cutting veteran's benefits and services for the poor. How do you people look yourself in the mirror? How do you fill out your taxes and not wince? I thought you were all pro-military--big on the patriotism of the military? But no, just like Bush, you are more concerned with cutting taxes than taking care of either the poor or the military. These people put their lives on the line for your country and your misguided foreign policy, and your President rewards them with less services. I don't get it.

This column is dead on. We are lacking shame as a nation, and I am sorry to say it, but Republicans have lost every vestige of it. Supporting this budget and tax policies are indefensible, and I think you know it. That is why you focus on abortion and gays. You know that if we talk about the morality of this budget, you will lower your head.

Maybe it is time to actually act on your faith. Call your senator and congressperson. Tell them that you are a Republican voter and you want to see those tax cuts reversed. Tell them that you support this president and this war and you think that a true conservative would not ask the poor and working class to pay for it.

anyway, read below on the shame of a nation...

"Charlie Richardson, co-founder of Military Families Speak Out, is opposed to the war and advocates bringing home the troops. 'It’s disgusting that they are asking families like mine to make enormous sacrifices while they give tax cuts to billionaires,' said Richardson. 'We’re having bake sales to buy Kevlar bulletproof vests to keep our kids alive in a war that never should have begun. Whatever happened to shared sacrifice?'

People on opposite sides of the Iraq war are shocked by the stunning inequality of sacrifice during this military engagement. Never in the history of U.S. warfare has Congress pushed tax cuts, let alone permanent tax cuts for the very wealthy. Historically, the opposite has been true: Wealth has been 'conscripted,' in the form of progressive income and estate taxes, to at least symbolize that everyone is contributing in some way.

THE U.S. HISTORY of progressive taxation is wound together with mobilizations for war. The first federal tax on wealth was levied in 1797, as our country was faced with the escalating costs of responding to French attacks on American shipping.

During World War II, President Franklin D. Roosevelt understood that national domestic unity against Hitler depended on a sense of shared sacrifice by both Rockefeller and Rosie the Riveter. Top income rates were boosted, and the estate tax was increased so that fortunes exceeding $50 million would be taxed at the 70-percent rate. FDR spoke out boldly against war profiteering, saying, 'I don’t want to see a single war millionaire created in the United States as a result of this world disaster.'

.....
Congress is now debating a budget that masks the costs of the war, continues massive tax cuts for the rich, and attempts to reduce the deficit with massive budget cuts. 'The cuts in veterans’ services are bad enough,' observed Richardson. 'But they are also cutting higher education spending, which forces poor and middle income kids graduating from high school to look to the military as one of the few options for an affordable education or job with health insurance.'

The current tolerance for this inequality of sacrifice is a moral indictment of America’s ruling and wealthy elites. How can families in the richest 1 percent accept millions of dollars in tax cuts at a time when other families are doing fundraisers to buy bulletproof vests for their children in the line of fire? How can wealthy families advocate for the abolition of the inheritance tax when other people’s children, in Iraq and the United States, are wounded and maimed for life?

With all this talk of budget gaps, the biggest deficit among our nation’s political leaders appears to be in shame."

NEWS.com.au | Bush breaks shooting silence (26-03-2005)

NEWS.com.au | Bush breaks shooting silence (26-03-2005): "Mr Bush's silence drew fire from some American Indians, including Clyde Bellecourt, a Chippewa Indian who is the founder and national director of the American Indian Movement in Red Lake.

'It's kind of late,' he said of Mr Bush's call to Mr Jourdain. 'He should have been the first one to reach out to the Red Lake Indian community.'

Mr Bellecourt cited Mr Bush's decision to rush back to the White House from his Texas ranch last weekend to sign unprecedented emergency legislation allowing Mrs Schiavo's case to be reviewed in federal courts.

"He does not have any problems flying in to restore the feeding tube to Terri Schiavo. I'm sure if this happened in some school in Texas and a bunch of white kids were shot down, he would have been there too," Mr Bellecourt said."


I am afraid that last quote is dead on. Had this happened in Austin or Dallas, Bush would have been on TV immediately. Give us all a break, Mr. President. You are perfectly willing to pose over Terry Shiavo. Face it. Indian kids don't fit into your agenda. Now, had they been millionaires you could promise my tax money to while you cut veterans benefits....

I really thought it was the last one

The Rude Pundit (and be warned, he really is rude) made a fabulous point that I thought needed to be raised. Despite all this concern about life coming from President Bush, and the rush to fly from Crawford to sign the "look at me, I care about life" bill, Rude Pundit points out that Bush has said nothing about what happened at Red Lake. Nothing. Not a word.

On Thursday, Bush issued an Easter message, wherein he talked about the resurrection of Christ and said, "[W]e thank God for His blessings and ask for His wisdom and guidance. We also keep in our thoughts and prayers the men and women of our Armed Forces -- especially those far from home, separated from family and friends by the call of duty." He remembered the soldiers. He always remembers the soldiers. They are ever present.

In each of these statements and events, Bush did not ask for anyone to remember the Indians of Red Lake, Minnesota. Bush did not ask for us to pray for them. Bush did not send his regrets. Bush made no appearance to mourn. Bush is silent. He has planned to go to Europe, but has no plans to helicopter into the reservation.


What message does that send?

I hate to say it, but it sends an age-old message to Native Americans. It also says that Bush's great culture of life is very, very limited--to people who might vote for him.

But, as Cold in Laramie just pointed out, there is more than just Bush to be frustrated here. Why, he asks, was the Columbine event a "massacre" while the Red Lake is referred to as a "shooting?" Why talk about these in different terms? Are Indian kids somehow expected to die violently? Is this a throwback to the 19th century when Indians died in "battles" but whites were "slaughtered" in "massacres?"

I hate to say this too, but it speaks to how we culturally frame these issues. Urban youth experience a shocking level of violence in their lives, but American only freaks when it happens in a suburban school. Now it has happened on an Indian reservation. White America has no idea what to do with that. Can we blame it simply on weak gun control? What about teaching evolution in schools? Not allowing prayer? Those were all ridiculous explanations for Columbine. Do most Americans see Indians in the context of a John Wayne movie? Can we still not see Indians as people?

I think Rude Pundit gets many things wrong, even in this piece, but this contrast of the outrage over Terry Shiavo v. Red Lake is instructive, and not in a positive way. I am not suggesting that Republicans turn Red Lake into another circus, but their avoidance of this really echoes.

Power, Principle, and Faith

I kind of hope that this is my last post on the Shiavo case. Like so many people out there, I am tired of how this deeply personal family tragedy has been so manipulated and used by so many people.

But Streak's other friend and I were musing about the principle issues at stake. We are not the first to note that the party that used to be most concerned about keeping government out of personal lives is now supporting some of the most intrusive actions the government can do. Jeb Bush wants to take Terry Shiavo into state custody. Numerous people, including our philosopher President, have said that if you are going to err, should err on the side of life. Funny how those same people seem to not feel the same way when a person's guilt or innocence is in doubt--and many want those people to have very limited appeals. Just kill them.

But why are these "principles" clearly so not-principled?

I really don't know. But those people who call themselves conservative used to criticize people like me for my liberal beliefs. Since I didn't base them on some absolute truth, they said that my beliefs were not well-founded in principle.

Well, let me say that if you can blather on in 2000 about the government not telling people what to do, but then muster all the power you have to over-ride state courts and intrude on the most personal and tragic event, you have no principle underlying your policy. And that is exactly what Bush has done.

I kind of expect that from him. Despite his spin of being principled, he has shown himself to not be. But I am most surprised by conservatives I know--people who talked a lot under Clinton about "principle" and the "rule of law"--who are now excusing government intrusion and and expanding state, to say nothing of justifying debt practices, a hostile foreign policy and the growth of a theocratic state.

If I were a conservative who disliked Clinton but now loves Bush, I would do a little inventory and see if I could find my principle. Might be worth dusting off and seeing if any of it matches this current administration.

Just a thought.

OBU fires employee for criticizing a church

Oklahoma Baptist University

March 24, 2005

Easter Confessions

Holy week is upon us and Easter is this Sunday. And I have no clue what to do with that.

I have been thinking about Easter a lot lately. It is a difficult time for me, for some reason. It is not my favorite holiday. That hasn't been helped with the Mel Gibson stuff, or here locally with churches giving away a Harley or advertising their Easter pageant. Streak's other friend and I winced last night at an ad on television that was clearly marketing a special Easter sale. It is all for sale, and under capitalism, this date on the religious calendar is as good a reason to sell useless shit as any other. That bothers me, but it does not surprise.

Maybe growing up Baptist, I never really understood the church calendar. I didn't know what advent was (except for the advent calendar) and it took me years to understand that Mardi Gras was any way connected to religion. I remember asking a girl out to lunch in high school. She told me she had given up lunch for lent. I thought she was making it up, but didn't even really understand what she was talking about. In retrospect, she was trying to be nice to me (she was a nice girl, and had a really nice boyfriend who could have crushed me like a bug--I am not sure what I was thinking.....).

We attended a pretty special SBC church in Houston at South Main. I am not sure it is still the church it used to be after the pastor left, but it was really a great place. They had an active aids ministry (in the 80s, no less), participated in helping the poor, worked closely with cancer patients at MD Anderson, and refused to both leave the inner city or build giant health clubs. (It was also around ground zero of the counter revolution against the fundy takeover, but I didn't know that until just recently.) Anyway, I remember the first time I saw them dress in vestments (?) and we celebrated advent. I liked that.

I remember going to sunrise services as a child--shivering as the fire took hold and waiting for the sun to come up. I know many enjoyed those. I understood (and understand) the symbolism, but am just not sure it ever took. I remember the confusion about easter eggs. I don't remember it being a bad experience by any stretch, just not one that I really enjoyed.

As an adult, Easter has continued to kind of puzzle me. Maybe it goes back to my spring depression. Springtime has plagued me for a variety of reasons. For years the changes in weather and plant life made me miserable during this period. I remember when I was still in school, the new year always filled me with fear about what I would accomplish this year. One Easter eve, our cat died. That was painful. Still is.

So, it is with a bit of trepidation that I approach Good Friday and Easter Sunday. I am glad for those of you who find great meaning in this week. I respect that.

Anyway.....

More on the Religious Right and their devil's bargain with politics

NY Times columnist Frank Rich is hardly a popular figure in the Religious Right, I am sure. He has been hyper critical of the following of the Left Behind books, and was one of the first to clearly articulate that Mel Gibson was playing people with his blood-fest crucifixion flick. I agreed with that take and saw much of the duplicity in Gibson as well--all confirmed by the director's involvement and licensing of ghoulish souvenirs from the film.

Well, this column makes more connections that some of us have worried about. (Thanks to Bad Catholic for the link, btw.) He starts by pointing out that many of the Ten Commandments statues around the country were put there by Cecille B. DeMille to promote his movie. That's right, these weren't put there to worship God, but to worship Hollywood.

But, as Rich notes, that is nothing compared to what we have today. "The religio-hucksterism surrounding the Schiavo case makes DeMille's Hollywood crusades look like amateur night." Politicians from all over the map are lining up to profit from this family's tragedy. Bill Frist, heart surgeon, senator, and presidential hopeful, said that watching video tapes of Shiavo allowed him to second guess doctors who actually examined the woman. Nice. Tom Delay has been even worse. When he isn't doing his best Barry Bond's imitation, he is jumping all over the Shiavo case. "DeLay, last seen on "60 Minutes" a few weeks ago deflecting Lesley Stahl's questions about his proximity to allegedly criminal fund-raising by saying he would talk only about children stranded by the tsunami. Those kids were quickly forgotten as he hitched his own political rehabilitation to a brain-damaged patient's feeding tube. Adopting a prayerful tone, the former exterminator from Sugar Land, Tex., took it upon himself to instruct "millions of people praying around the world this Palm Sunday weekend" to "not be afraid."

And this from our compassionate commander in chief:

The president was not about to be outpreached by these saps. The same Mr. Bush who couldn't be bothered to interrupt his vacation during the darkening summer of 2001, not even when he received a briefing titled "Bin Laden Determined to Strike in U.S.," flew from his Crawford ranch to Washington to sign Congress's Schiavo bill into law. The bill could have been flown to him in Texas, but his ceremonial arrival and departure by helicopter on the White House lawn allowed him to showboat as if he had just landed on the deck of an aircraft carrier. Within hours he turned Ms. Schiavo into a slick applause line at a Social Security rally. "It is wise to always err on the side of life," he said, wisdom that apparently had not occurred to him in 1999, when he mocked the failed pleas for clemency of Karla Faye Tucker, the born-again Texas death-row inmate, in a magazine interview with Tucker Carlson." (emphasis mine)


The rest of the column is worth reading. Rich connects all this to the growing concern public school teachers have about mentioning evolution; the IMAX theaters not showing films on the Galapagos islands because real evidence might offend religious fundamentalists who cling to a 6,000 year old earth. Science is being traded for faith in what is a fool's bargain. There is no need to exchange one for the other, but lacking both is a detriment to us all.

As Rich notes, the polls show that only 20 percent of Americans really believe what these Republican politicians pretend to believe. Most Americans don't want their government overriding state courts time and time again, and certainly not to force a politically charged outcome on an intensely painful private tragedy. That won't stop them from doing it. As the West Wing said last night on tv, people who demand expressions of faith also demand to be lied to and manipulated. I don't understand why they want that outcome, but they seem to line up to have someone like Delay--a person they would not want as a friend, colleague, church member, or neighbor--pander to their most inner beliefs. In the end, politics is undermined, but faith is sold.

March 23, 2005

The West Wing

Sometimes TV gets it right. Tonight's was great. Alan Alda plays the Republican nominee, though in TV land the Republican nominee is smart, moderate and reasoned. Shock, huh?

Well, this particular Republican candidate is someone who has tried to engage his faith, but he has serious doubts--doubts that his wife's death didn't help. But he is a good man. He is honorable and kind and decent. But he doesn't go to church. I can relate to that.

Well, one of his primary opponents was a Reverend who bashed Alda's charcter over abortion and invited him to his church where, as he told the press, he would pray to change the Senator's mind on abortion.

The Senator is, as I noted, pretty iffy about church (another thing I related to) and doesn't want to go. But his political advisors tell him that is a sure fire win. Just go, make a showing and you shore up all the Conservative Christians who support the Reverend.

Finally, after agonizing over this decision, the Senator finally responds to the question:

"I respect his church too much to use it for my own political purposes. And the truth is, it would only be an act of political phonies.
I want to warn everyone in the press, and all the voters out there. If you demand expressions of religious faith from politicians, you are just begging to be lied to. They won't all lie to you, but a lot of them will. And it will be the easiest lie they ever had to tell to get your votes."

I understand this is television. But it is nice to see someone else suggest that the religious right is selling out their votes for very little gain. By supporting Bush so blindly, they have invited deceit and further selling out. They have invited every dumb ass politician to get on television and quote from the bible and talk about his "deep and personal relationship with Jesus" while politically persuing profits and destruction.

People of faith, you are serious about it. Don't sell it. Don't sell your heartfelt belief for a pretense of power. Don't do it.

People I would like to have coffee/beer/dinner with

This is a dream list, of course, and won't happen. But these people intrigue me. Don't mistake them as heroes of mine, just people who I find interesting.

1) Jon Stewart. Someone compared me to him once, which I took as a high compliment. His quick wit and clear intelligence would make him a fascinating dinner companion.

2) Bill Clinton. Yeah, I know, I know. I wouldn't ask him for marriage advice, for sure, but I think he is an intelligent guy who would make for a bright and challenging dinner/coffee. He knows more about a lot of things than most, and I think he would be engaging and thoughtful. (Much more than I can say about the current president who does not interest me in the least. I cannot imagine finding something to talk about with him. I think Clinton is the only politician on my list.

3) Paul Newman. Perhaps my favorite actor of all time. Clearly an intelligent guy who has done a lot in his life. And I know for a fact he likes beer!

4) A few other actors that I will lump in here. John Cusack and Susan Sarandon. Cusack is one of my favorites and I have had a crush on Sarandon (Streak's other friend is aware, trust me) since Bull Durham.

5) Steve Earle. Easily my favorite singer/songwriter/activist. A tortured soul who was drugged out in the 80s, but has cleaned up and produced some amazing work. If I could con him and Emmylou Harris to invite me to dinner and a jam session, I would be ok with that.

6) U2. All four of them. With lyrics like this, who wouldn't want to meet them?
Don't believe the devil
I don't believe his book
But the truth is not the same
Without the lies he made up


7) Bishop Tutu and Sister Helen Prejean. People who have seen what they have seen and still have faith, not only in God, but in humanity. That has to be a good discussion.

I will add more as I think of them.

Tom Delay and Barry Bonds

Separated at birth?

Jesus Politics: Elmer Gantry, Martin Buber and the Christian Right: "And what, exactly, is going on in the United States? 'Attacks against the conservative movement, against me and against many others,' DeLay told his flock. So God has now thrown in with DeLay in his efforts to pack the House ethics committee with his allies so that he no longer need be the subject of the scrutiny and censure of his peers."

MercuryNews.com | 03/23/2005 | Barry Bonds' breaking point: "``You wanted me to jump off the bridge, I finally have jumped. You wanted to bring me down, you've finally brought me and my family down,'' Bonds told reporters at the Giants' spring training facility in Scottsdale, Ariz. ``So now go pick a different person. I'm done. Do the best I can, that's about it"


Neither is responsible for anything. Neither has caused any of his problems. Both are the victims of others (liberals, media, racists).

Both are wrong and both are huge jerks.

Only Nixon could go to China

I am still mad about this. I have read a little more about these "vnr" or "video news releases" and it makes me very nervous. The GAO, btw, said these were propaganda and the agencies should not do it. Bush said his Justice department said they were fine and angencies should ignore the one agency that kind of audits the federal government. No mere mortal dare criticize the Bushies.

These videos are made with taxpayer money, and were aired on many stations without disclosing their origins as public relations pieces. So, the State Department can release a video that shows Iraqis thanking Bush and the USA, and poor and stupid news agencies can replay that as if it is real reporting. A cynic could say that there is little difference between these government made reports and what Fox turns out on a regular basis, but that is the cynical view.

I have thought about this for a while. I remember Spock's line in one of the Star Trek movies where he is pushing Kirk to make peace with the Klingon or somebody. Kirk's longstanding repuatation as a Klingon-hater gave him credibility. Just as Nixon's longstanding anti-communist stance allowed him to make some steps with "red" China that Johnson or Kennedy could never do.

That is the positive side of this kind of bias. The negative appears to be the fact that a "conservative" is also the only one who can truly undermine your civil liberties because no one expects him to. Under Clinton, these kinds of videos would be called propaganda too, but from Frist, and Lott, and Hastert and Delay. "Slick Willy" was noted for spin, and for being liberal, so he was accused of undermining free speech and civil liberties on every turn--even when he was prosecuting nuts in compounds. But Bush can insist on loyatly oaths to enter his "town meetings," pay off commentators, allow a gay prostitute shill to ask him questions (under a fake name), and now release propaganda videos. My conservative friends say nothing. I am puzzled.

We have historically made fun of regimes that lacked a free press. I remember the jokes about Soviet "news;" the fact that Pravda meant "truth" and the government completely controlled the news. Conservatives were loudest in that criticism. Now they watch and justify and make excuses.

You also see how gradually and how innocently this can begin. Every institution does it. Watch a college football game and see the little video clips that tout each individual institution's credentials. No one really thinks that they are unbiased. They are propaganda. Like when the 700 club has a "story" on Regent "University." All are owned by Big Head Pat, and so no one is really surprised that all the stories are glowing, right? Same when ABC covers Disney?

Make no mistake about it--if they try to sell this as a news story with "this is Kelly Wilson reporting," they are trying to deceive. This is propaganda. And if this were as pervasive under Clinton, many of you would be sneering. But you are so used to defending Bush that you have lost the ability to see it.

A conservative is taking away your freedoms and you are patting him on the back. Somewhere you will need to take a look at what conservative political philosophy actually is. You know, small government, not intruding on state court cases, a belief in the free market and free press. None of these are supported by Bush. And you are all helping him.

March 22, 2005

Streak's Blog goes International!

We received a nice comment this morning here at Streak's Blog from Silvia, who is reading us from Italy. This is very cool, and I hope that you will give us an Italian perspective on our petty issues. That is, if you want, Sylvia. You are more than welcome here! It does make me regret my limited language skills though, and make me more impressed with our international peoples who can move from language to language!

Benvenuto!

Indians and Christians, Hah!

Those who have read Sherman Alexie (and if you haven't, shame!) will probably chuckle at that title. After all, Christians have not played well with Native Peoples, you could say.

But my post is really not about that. I am reading

Shepard Krech's "The Ecological Indian." Interesting and mildly controversial book. At its core is something that made me think about the America as Christian nation argument.

Krech takes on the entire idea of the Ecological Indian, or the idea that Native Peoples are more "in-tune" with nature. Many Americans believe that prior to white contact, Indians somehow interacted with Nature but did not disturb it. As Richard White (and modestly let me say that I said this too) noted, to somehow assume that Indians made no impact on nature is to come dangerously close to a racist assumption. If Indians make no impact on nature, they are portrayed as being closer to animals than human.

And, in fact, Krech and others have noted that Native Americans often acted in ways that were destructive to their natural environment--through deforestation, over hunting, etc.

Why is this important? Since the 1960s, Americans have used Native Americans as a symbol of environmentalism, most famously with Iron Eyes Cody's "Crying Indian" campaign where a noble Indian cries as he observes a polluted stream. The problem is that this campaign and idea have never really been about Indians as people. It has always functioned as an oppositional force--pointing out the problems with White Polluters rather than elevating Native peoples.

Here is the connection and warning to those wanting to create a Christian nation out of our complicated past. Appealing to that idea of the Praying Founding Fathers is in effect doing the same thing as the Crying Indian. This campaign is clearly not about the past--else they would never elevate Ben Franklin in any way, nor would they ignore the proliferation of witchcraft and superstitions that also permeated Colonial America. It is about the perception that we are Godless and immoral.

And it isn't that somehow Christians are the only ones saying that. Most people buy the nostalgic past where people were more moral, less gay, and somehow more honorable in the past. Historians know better (and so should most Americans), but the idea persists. But it is in that context that this "Christian Nation" mania should be viewed (as well as Roy Moore's 10 Commandment worship). It isn't about the past, but is merely a tool to demonize the present.

This projection is complicated. On one hand, it is (much like the white use of the crying Indian) self-loathing. Christian Conservatives must feel as if they failed the nation by allowing it to turn into Gomorrah so quickly. On the other hand, it is self-affirming for them to look at Hollywood or Washington and shake their heads at how lost those poor people are. "If only they were as Godly as me," some might think, "our nation would be back in God's favor."

Such approaches are risky. For one, they contribute to the general cynicism of our youth by telling them that their generation is so bad and that the past was so idyllic. Neither is true, so stop saying that. Second, it risks what Cold in Laramie identified as marginalizing and trivializing the experiences of non-Whites in American history. Those believing that America was so much superior in the 19th century when everyone prayed (they didn't) are essentially telling Native Americans, African Americans, women, immigrant children, Asians, Hispanics and the poor that the world was a better place when all of these groups "knew their place" or were hunted down or enslaved or exploited.

These projections of modern angst have their costs, and people need to think about that. If you use Native Peoples to promote an environmental ethic, you ultimately undermine whole cultures as real people. If you insist on a Providential history, you tell those who were abused and misused in the past that God wanted that to happen.

Terry Shiavo, the Religious Right, and why this annoys me

There are many reasons why this Shiavo incident annoys me. One is the hypocrisy of people like Bush and Delay who talk about a "culture of life" but pursue profits over people on a daily basis. If they were really concerned about life, wouldn't they be busting their asses to get healthcare extended to those 50 million Americans who are uninsured?

The other is simply the way the Religious Right has responded to this president. They, in my opinion, have shown themselves to be incredibly politically slutty. They will roll over and support Bush for the silliest damn things. "Oh, my god, those Gay people might be happy--organize a demonstration," or "We will have the ten commandments to worship or die trying." Nothing on poverty, nothing on meaningful healthcare reform, nothing on addressing the environment that we all live in. Nothing.

The Terry Shiavo case is clearly another one of these emotional heartstrings that people like Bush like to pull. Think of this, Bush didn't return from vacation (most vacationing President in history, btw) when 250,000 people died in a tsunami, but he returns to sign this politically grandstanding bill for this one woman. Don't some of you start thinking that maybe this guy is playing you? Don't you start to feel a little silly? Don't you ever find his blustering bravado "bring it on" a little jarring with his constant use of biblical images in his speeches? Or do you really think that Jesus is a War God?

I don't always agree with the The Anti-Manicheist, but he nails it here:
"There is no doubt that the left in US politics needs better leadership and stronger unifying principles. But the real cause of the decline of the US's democracy has been how the religious right has been giving its votes for cheap to the economic conservatives that run the republican party."
KRT Wire | 03/21/2005 | Law Bush signed as Texas governor prompts cries of hypocrisy: "In 1999, then-Gov. Bush signed the Advance Directives Act, which lets a patient's surrogate make life-ending decisions on his or her behalf. The measure also allows Texas hospitals to disconnect patients from life-sustaining systems if a physician, in consultation with a hospital bioethics committee, concludes that the patient's condition is hopeless.

Bioethicists familiar with the Texas law said Monday that if the Schiavo case had occurred in Texas, her husband would be the legal decision-maker and, because he and her doctors agreed that she had no hope of recovery, her feeding tube would be disconnected.

'The Texas law signed in 1999 allowed next of kin to decide what the patient wanted, if competent,' said John Robertson, a University of Texas bioethicist.

While Congress and the White House were considering legislation recently in the Schiavo case, Bush's Texas law faced its first high-profile test. With the permission of a judge, a Houston hospital disconnected a critically ill infant from his breathing tube last week against his mother's wishes after doctors determined that continuing life support would be futile."


Let's just let this sink in. When he was governor, Bush signed legislation that allows the doctors to take people off life support, and this law was used against the Mother's wishes. No spouse to blame here. If you read what the White House said in response, they said that ""The legislation he signed (early Monday) is consistent with his views," McClellan said. "The (1999) legislation he signed into law actually provided new protections for patients ... prior to the passage of the '99 legislation that he signed, there were no protections."

Hear that? Down is up. Right is wrong, and George Bush is a seriously committed Christian. Oh, and one of the factors used in the Texas case is if there is money for the treatment. When it is gone, and there is no hope for recovery.... Unless, of course, you can make political miles.

So, to sum up: the Republicans and their conservative christian handlers believe in life:

a) especially when it is politically helpful
b) unless that person is dying from a treatable disease and just needs health insurance
c) or unless on death row with dubious evidence

Other Republican policies will make the Terry Shiavo case moot in the future because they will cap medical malpractice cases and make it harder for families who endure a horrible medical catastrophy to declare bankruptcy. But in this case, they are all over this poor woman.

Oh, and remember when Republicans didn't want the state in your individual life? Those days are done.

And to be very clear. Bush will never be held accountable by anyone, and certainly not the Conservative Christians who believe somehow that God wants him in office to bomb other countries and act hypocritically about people like Terry Shiavo. Shame on all of you. Shame on everyone. And for God's sake, will one of you Christian conservatives call Bush on anything? Because you have embarrassed yourself to a point of no return. Shame.

March 21, 2005

Thanks to Life and Deatherage

This cartoon highlights all that is wrong with the Terry Schiavo case. I have not blogged about it because I don't really know what to say. I don't have a lot of the details and it just feels like a tragedy with a lot of hyenas using this young woman for their own political punching bag. All around. The Republicans strike me as unbelievable on this, but they aren't the only ones.

This cartoon, if you haven't clicked over there yet, highlights one of the huge hypocrisies from the right. The recent bankruptcy bill would make it very hard for families like the Shiavo's to recover, as would the President's vaunted "tort reform" which would take away the funding for someone like Terry Shiavo's coverage up till now. And then read what Bush evidently signed into law as governor of Texas and tell me, (if true) how that relates to his supposed "culture of life?"

on truth

Natalie has an interesting post on truth and conversation. She is reading David Dark's new book and he makes some really good points about this important topic.

“He talks about his father being a good role model for him in terms of seeking truth. Humility seems to be a big theme. Just because we as Christians have the Bible to refer to as truth, it doesn’t mean we should wield it as a weapon. Dark’s father, when someone would back something up with the phrase, “It’s biblical,” he would especially scrutinize it, because “the Bible belonged to everyone and no one,” and “anyone who presumed to own its copyright was criminally insane” (ix). Dark says, “To view truthfulness not as a boasting point we have over others but as a standard that judges all our talk, is to recognize oneself as a partaker of common humanity humbly bound to the common good of attempted truthfulness” (xi).


This resonates with me as I have had more than one conversation where the Bible has been invoked to rebut whatever I was saying, often with the phrase, "your disagreement is not with me, but with God." That has always rankled me--there is an air of disengenousness about it or a deflection. I think that issue of humility is a huge one, one made the more important when people claim to be speaking for God. Anyway, thanks to Natalie for starting this particular conversation.

March 20, 2005

From Carlos

American Christian History Institute - Principle Approach - Christian History - Home Schooling: "That there would be no America if there were no Christianity;
Why Christians are so important to God in respect to 'His Story' and government of men and nations;
How responsible they are for the quality and conduct of American education, government and economics; and
How to restore America's historic Biblical method of reasoning to the home, church and school, the three constituents of Constitutional Liberty"


This stuff is everywhere over at Carlos's blog. David Barton is speaking at D. James Kennedy's domminionist conference--you know, the one where they want to take over the country and rule it as a Christian nation?

Meanwhile, Barton and his minions are everywhere. See, Christian conservatives don't like my profession. Evidently, historians have not awarded conservative Christians enough standing in our nation's history. Or something. Hell, I can't figure it out.

I guess that most Conservative Christians share this idea of "his-story" which means that we are all just little pawns in God's big play. America, after all, as you see above, would not exist without Christians. My Native American friends will love that. They love talk that God focusses all his attention on white christians and ignores their little forays into genocide, ethnic cleansing and slavery. they love it when their own history is reduced to scenery on the larger stage, and their suffering is ignored or simply dismissed as "sin."

Ultimately what bothers me is the methodalogical approach of all of these people. As the website here shows, they start with their conclusion: America a Christian nation and Christians at the heart of all good stuff--and then start working backward. Had I done that for my dissertation, I would have flunked.

The same issues come up in the discussions on evolution. Conservatives everywhere are saying things like "that is just a theory" which is also what I hear about my interpretations of the past. It is as if conservative christians have been touched with a relativist bug--or at least that they keep hearing it.

My friend Greg pointed me to this debate between three historians, and this is something that followers of David Barton should read. One of them is a Mormon. His writings outside mormonism have been widely respected, but as the article notes, he is also a huge apologist for the Mormon religion. One of the other historians challenges how he can do both. To my conservative christians, this is your challenge. When you throw out the historical method for a Barton, you are doing the same thing, and what is more, you have no challenge for the other faiths who do the same thing.

Let me suggest that science and history function very similarly. We all ask questions and do research. The quality of our research and the quality of our questions dictates the quality of our work. A Scientific "theory" is much like a historical explanation. They are the best explanation for the facts and details that we have. That doesn't mean capital "T" truth, but it also does't mean a half-assed opinion. It means that if new evidence comes along, that conclusion will need revising. Revision, after all, is a good thing. It isn't what most people think it is.

Ultimately, neither science or history operate the way conservative Christians want them too (that is, unless science is curing something, or history actually speaks well of Christians). But that is no reason to simply ignore both professions. Those that do are encouraging the very anti-intellectualism that has plagued religion.

Why can republicans use propaganda?

Listen to this npr story about the bush administration making video press releases that sound just like "real TV news reports."

Recap time:

1) This white house sees the press as just another interest and has excluded the real media from honest coverage (admittedly with their complicity).

2) Same white house that controls everything allowed gay prostitute access to the press room and to ask questions of this particular president who never "just calls on" someone by random. Oh, and this shill reporter asked the kind of leading questions that even this president could answer.

3) This same white house paid so-called journalists to go on talk shows and write columns supporting their programs. But the journalists didn't tell anyone they were little whores. White House says it is perfectly fine.

Now we have this same White House churning out fake video news reports and claiming that they aren't propaganda because they are true. Excuse me? I suspect that the Nazi press officer claimed their propaganda was true too.

Once again, I look at my conservative friends with the "what the fuck" look on my face. If you really believed what you say you believe, you would be on the phone with your congressperson and writing a letter to Bush. But you don't really believe that stuff do you? You like having someone who speaks the fake "faith language" in power more than you like your principles. So you won't call him on this, or the dangerous "abstinence only" stuff, or any of his lies, or his pollution policies, or any of it. You like power more than principle, which may be the very definition of selling out.

March 19, 2005

This is exactly what I argued

This is what bothers me about the religious right. They operate from the theoretical (sounds ironic, in a way) and refuse to acknowledge mitigating facts. The death penalty is supported because they think it should be moral to execute someone who they know is guilty, but ignore the problems with race, dna evidence and class bias.

Likewise, this story about abstinence only education. Of course abstinence will ensure no unwanted pregnancies or stds, but that isn't the reality. The study shows that 88 percent of teens who take the pledge have sex before marriage, as opposed to 99 percent of those who don't take the pledge. That is only a 10 percent gain, but the bad news is that those 88 percent that are sexually active don't have the education in precautions or contraceptives. So, this program actually endangers kids.


Yahoo! News - Study: Abstinence Pledgers May Risk STDs
: "NEW HAVEN, Conn. - Teens who pledge to remain virgins until marriage are more likely to take chances with other kinds of sex that increase the risk of sexually transmitted diseases, a study of 12,000 adolescents suggests."


satanic worship

Nope, not my latest thing. Just an interesting post by the incomparable slactivist on the seemingly unending belief among the religious right that thousands, if not tens of thousands of children are being abducted and sacrificed or abused by satan worshipers. As he notes, no evidence exists to support those claims, but it has turned into a cottage industry for some.

"As with most urban legends, it's difficult to determine precise origins for many of these stories. But it certainly appears that some devout, Christian writers sat down and devised elaborate rituals involving group sex, dismemberment and the rape of infants. That these writers ran this material by the devout Christian editors at these publishing houses. And that these publishing houses packaged these claims, bound them attractively, and shipped them out to the local Mustard Seeds, Wellsprings and other devout Christian bookstores across the country."


Fred suggests that this has to do with evangelical anxiety:
"This anxiety arises in part from the never-quite-wholly conscious recognition that we Christians don't seem to be all that different from everybody else. We know we're supposed to be "a peculiar people," yet we seem to spend our time, our money and our lives pretty much the same way that everybody else around us does. We have the same things, we do the same things, we want the same things as those unsanctified others."


One of the commenters quoted Anne Lamott: ""You can safely assume that you’ve created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do."

These are traps that can ensnare all of us.

March 17, 2005

Evangelical leaders say something close to good

Evangelical leaders call for broader approach to public policy; Land, Dobson lend support - (BP): "In addition to opposing abortion, euthanasia and same-sex “marriage,” the document urges care for the poor, the disabled, the persecuted, the elderly, minorities and refugees both in the United States and overseas. It calls for churches to “model good race relations.”

The statement encourages governments to use their militaries only under “just-war” criteria and after pursuing peace nonviolently. “Just-war” theory is a classical Christian approach to the use of force that requires certain standards, such as a just cause and its utilization as a last resort."


Except for the statement on gay marriage, I am pretty close to this statement. Here is the next big question. How do these statements, including the phrase "to use their militaries only under "just-war"
criteria and after pursuing peace nonviolently stand in the same room with the Bush administration? How do people who sign on to this sheet pledging to help the poor and the environment vote for people like GWB and Tom Delay?