March 17, 2005

Thursday rant

I already ranted about opening ANWR, though that does still piss me off. I would be far more sympathetic if we had first taken some steps to increase efficiency. Put it this way, as long as we are rolling out Hummers, there is absolutely no justification for this.

Ok, on with the rant. I have pointed out that those who believe the bible to be innerrent tend to be quite selective in that process. Here is a great example (thanks to Carlos at Jesus Politics).

Jesus Politics: I Can't Listen to Christian Lawyers: "A key sponsor of the bill, Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa), actively opposes abortion and same-sex marriage on biblical grounds yet believes the Good Book's clear definition and condemnation of usury is irrelevant. The Old Testament, revered by Jews, Muslims and Christians alike, mandates debt forgiveness after seven years, as was pointed out earlier this month by an organization of Christian lawyers in a letter to Grassley.
----
'I can't listen to Christian lawyers,' said the senator, 'because I would be imposing the Bible on a diverse population.'"


Nice. Really speaks to the issue of how sin has become only sex. Money? Pursuit of money? Go for it! Get as much as you can, and if you can get it from the poor and stupid, then all the better. Verily.
.........

Next subject: our President and what he is teaching the children.

No connection between competence and advancement. President Bush said yesterday that he has chosen Deputy Defense Secretary Paul D. Wolfowitz, a key architect of the Iraq war, as the U.S. nominee to head the World Bank."


Let's go over this once again. Say you have a guy who hates the UN and jokes about the UN building losing 10 floors (not really funny anymore)? Well, of course, you make him ambassador to the UN. What about a lawyer who says that the US doesn't have to adhere to the Geneva Conventions and suggests that the President can authorize torture if he wants? Of course, you make him Attorney General so he can go after the porn industry. How about someone who oversaw intelligence failure after intelligence failure? You make her Secretary of State.

Now we have one of the most aggressive Neo-cons who said that we could invade Iraq on the cheap, that Iraq would pay for their own reconstruction, and who admitted that the WMD wasn't really the reason for the invasion, just the one that could scare the American people into supporting the war? You make him the head of the World Bank. He has no economic background, and has alienated much of the rest of the world.

This president (despite all the claims for his religious faith) has savaged any critics. He has made sure that those who don't follow him completely leave Washington with their reputation gone (just ask Ambassador Wilson, Richard Clarke, or Paul O'Neill). But, if you kiss his ass and tell him how smart he is, and that he is really an instrument of God, you will get promoted even if you suck at your job. Of course, they haven't sucked at their job when that job was defined as protecting the King's ass. Gonzales made sure that Governor Christian Bush could sign off on executing (and possibly mocking) the condemned on Texas's death row.

Some day, we are going to read about how truly simple our President is. I think the future will reveal the Oedipal nightmare of the Bush family, and will reveal how this child of privilege has associated with ideologues who fit his idea of "pulling themselves up by their bootstraps." Molly Ivins said this of his father, but it is more true of Shrub: "He was born on third base and thought he hit a triple." Someday, those of you who backed this man will have to apologize someday for what you have done to the poor, the environment, and to gays and women.

March 16, 2005

Tom Delay--paragon of Christian virtue

I remember reading the extensive Washington Post article on "the Hammer" and the extensive discussions on his faith and church in Sugarland, Texas. He talked about his faith a lot. This is the same guy who used his power to force a redistricting in Texas between the normal period.

DeLay Defends Trip and Vote, Attacks Critics (washingtonpost.com): "Speaking at a weekly session with reporters, DeLay alternated between attacks on the news media and attacks on Democrats. 'With all the partisan politics of personal destruction that the Democrats have announced and have carried through on, I have yet to be found breaking any House rules,' he said. 'It is very unfortunate that the Democrats have no agenda. All they can do is try to tear down the House and burn it down in order to gain power.'"


This is a guy who has used his power to make it easier to pollute and harm the environment. This is a guy who has treated people so ruthlessly that he is called the Hammer. You know, just like Jesus was.

This is exactly what I am talking about. Conservative Christians have sold the store. You sold teh idea and the marketing of your faith. Now any asshole can claim a "serious personal relationship with Christ" all the while they act like Ghengis Khan. Hope you got what you wanted. Because some day this come back to haunt you.

Well, Conservatives, here is what you voted for


Yahoo! News - Senate Votes to Open Alaska Wildlife Refuge to Drilling
: "With the price of crude oil reaching an all-time high, the U.S. Senate narrowly voted today to open a wildlife refuge in Alaska to oil drilling, an approval long sought by President Bush as part of his energy policy."


Let's add this to the list of other things you voted for. 1) budget that favors the rich and hurts the poor, the veterans, and the disabled. 2) air pollution laws that essentially do nothing to reduce global warming or mercury poisoning.

Now this. Been waiting for it. Hard to muster the outrage for this administration that shows such disdain for the environment.

Glad you supported him?

March 15, 2005

Seriously, what the hell does this mean?

While we are on the subject of the Jerusalem Prayer Team, I went to the offical site and foud this.

Jerusalem Prayer Team: "The goal of The Jerusalem Prayer Team is to enlist 1 million people in America to pray daily and 100,000 houses of worship praying weekly for the peace of Jerusalem."


Two questions: 1) what does this have to do with gay people? Are gay people bombing Jerusalem or undermining peace in the Middle East? No. No. No. 2) what does this say about prayer? Is it really just a giant petition that you have to get enough people to sign? Is that the only way God acts? Does that explain why so many people struggle in poverty....that they don't have enough contacts to convince God that they should be helped? What kind of theology is that?

And finally (and I won't count it in the 'two questions" part) how does this view of prayer and God work with Jesus and leaving the 99 Sheep to go find the one lost? Does that mean that there were a million sheep out there praying for the lost sheep? No. No. No. This theology bites. If God only listens to these huge petitions, prayer means nothing more than a popularity or marketing thing. I grew up raising sheep. That one sheep always meant a lot to me. I am not following this "herd mentality" theology.

I think I just threw up a little in my mouth

MAX BLUMENTHAL: " have spent the last couple of days in Ohio where I spoke to over 2,800 people at Fairfield Christian Church outside Columbus. Today I joined Ohio Secretary of State Ken Blackwell and former Ohio Congressman Bob McEwen as we spoke to about 70 key members of the clergy. We reflected back upon America's godly heritage and the key role that pastors played in this nation. The meeting, which was hosted by Pastor Rod Parsley at World Harvest Church, was organized by Pastor Russell Johnson of Lancaster.

Many of these pastors were instrumental in working with the president of Ohio's Citizens for Community Values, Phil Burress, in passing Ohio's marriage amendment over tremendous obstacles foes of marriage placed in their way. This was the first of a series of meetings designed to enlist hundreds of members of the clergy as 'Patriot Pastors' to further organize the Church in Ohio for social engagement. What I see happening across the country with pastors is unprecedented - pastors and their flocks are not going back to life as usual after the election. Christians are committed to the battle not only for the heart and souls of people but for the heart and soul of this nation."


Very seriously. If Rod Parsley is behind ANYTHING, I am headed the other way. Have any of you watched this twerp on tv? Besides really making John Hagee look really, really fat, he makes the rest of the charismatic twerps look positively good. He makes you long for the days of Jimmy Swaggert. He makes you want to sign up for a Benny Hinn "healing" whatever or possibly call your dentist for a pre-emptive root canal. He is everything that is bad about American Christianity.

Purpose driven suspect

So what are we to make of this?

For Captive, Book Offers New Purpose : "Ashley Smith, who was held captive for 7 1/2 hours by the man accused of killing an Atlanta judge and three others, told interviewers Monday that a passage from Warren's book seemed to help persuade her captor to set her free."

'This is, I would say, one of the more dramatic, if not the most dramatic [testimonials] I'm aware of,' said Vicki Cessna, spokeswoman for Christian publisher Zondervan in Grand Rapids, Mich. 'Obviously the book has had far-reaching, life-changing influences for millions of people. We're just honored that this in any way helped facilitate a positive outcome for Ashley.'


This bothers me. I should be clear, I have not read Warren's book and really don't intend to. Part of it is my distrust of most of this popular Christian stuff, that, in my mind, tends to simplify the complex and ignore broader contexts that really need to be explored.

The other part of me says that if this type of book, or the Prayer of Jabez stuff (with its companion marketing crap) helps someone, then that is fine. I still believe the church would be better off reading deeper theological writings, but I suspect that even stuff like Thomas Kinkade (that makes me wince) is helpful to some.

The publisher's response, however, speaks to that other part of me that really distrusts the magical side of Christianity. You know, the stories about the pocket bible that stops a bullet, or the family bible that survives a fire, or whatever. (I have also heard of a 69 cent bic pen deflecting a bullet too, but you don't see people praying to the pen.) In a different time, the fact that people would treat a book by some pastor with the same magical qualities would have disturbed conservative Evangelicals, but not today. Just as the Passion's success proves that Mel was telling the truth about the Crucifixion, the fact that a murderer was intrigued by Warren's book is supposed to display God's hand.

The simplistic explanations sell, but they ultimately don't convince. I remember James Dobson telling people that Ted Bundy became a serial killer because of porn. And he knew that because Bundy told him. A man who had practiced deceit to lure young women to their death was his evidence. Imagine the scene Dobson could create now if he can only find that this killer read porn as a kid and then was stopped from killing one more person by Rick Warren.

Well, to each his own, I guess. But I will pass on the Rick Warren. And the Tim LaHaye, and the Jerusalem Prayer Team.

We do what we can

Greg has alerted me to the Jerusalem Prayer Team and their hope to make Evangelical Christianity look incredibly silly worldwide.

Feminism

A friend was discussing Christian fiction the other day and reminded me of the Frank Peretti books. I read the first two years ago, though for the life of me I can't recall why I read two. Reading the first was enough.

The discussion was about how Christian fiction tends to demonize feminism. The antagonist is often a feminist, who is sometimes gay, always pro-abortion, and possibly into witchcraft. It all sounds like a Pat Robertson joke, I know.

The Peretti books certainly did that--as well as demonizing anything non-Christian or non-conservative. But the conservative attack on feminism really bothers me. I am frankly a little tired of it. It galls me everytime I see someone like Michelle Malkin or Ann Coulter (fascist bitch that she is) belittle feminism, I wonder if they even see the irony. If their conservative backers had their way, Malkin and Coulter would never be the jet-setting public speakers and authors that they are today.

When I teach, I often ask my class if anyone self-identifies as a feminist. Sometimes I am one of the few to raise my hand. Many of the women often say that they might agree with some feminist ideas, but are not "feminazis." Thanks, Rush, for adding that thoughtful term to our vocabulary. When I ask how many support equal pay for equal work, or the idea that women can pursue whatever degree or occupation they want, and everyone agrees. But they don't identify them with feminist ideas.

I am sure part of that is the fault of certain well-known feminists, but most of it has come from what the backlash. So, we get national figures like Phyllis Schaffly and Beverley LaHaye lecturing women on why they should be in the home. Without feminism, they would be ignored. And those college student women are there because feminism argued that women could attend more than a teaching college or study nursing. Nothing in the world wrong with those professions--in fact they are great and needed--but neither are they uniquely feminine.

Thanks to feminism, people rarely comment that their doctor is a woman, or that their attorney is female. There is no need to make a big deal about the woman professor or CPA. We don't even blink at those, and thank God for that. Yet, somehow feminism continues to be disparaged.

The conservative christian community is not doing anyone a service by bashing feminism. No, there is nothing wrong with staying home with kids. I hate to tell them this, but I know feminists who have done that, just as I know feminists who oppose abortion. In fact, I have yet to meet a feminist who was "anti-family," because all of them had families and were concerned about the same issues that self-proclaimed non-feminist women are. They don't want their kids to be sexualized too early, they worry about crime and drugs. They want their kids to have a good education and a supportive environment where they learn the skills and values necessary to be productive citizens. Where is the "nazi" part of that word?

So, unless you want women to only have the choice of marriage and kids, to not have professional aspirations or options, to not speak out on the issues of the day, to not have any authority or voice--you need to stop bashing feminism. Now.

Christianity, Bush, and Morality

Brandon writes his Senator.

a badchristian blog... - dear ms. stabenow: "My desire to see social justice done, though, supersedes my desire to not have to spend the time required to draft a letter to my Senator. I am deeply and gravely concerned with the proposed budget for the next fiscal year.

The current President talks about moral values, and frankly, that sickens me as he's recently proposed a budget that cuts benefits to the poor, pours even more money into the military, and offers tax cuts to the wealthiest of Americans--of these facts you are indubitably aware. Honestly, Ms. Stabenow, as a Christian I am deeply dismayed at the President's manipulation of the tenets of my faith in order to win re-election. Now these questionable morals are being used to foist a neo-conservative agenda onto the American people.

Ms. Stabenow, I am not alone. Many other deeply devout people have a concern for the poor. Democrats have a responsibility to their constituents to re-embrace and re-communicate their values in the context of faith to people of faith. Many individuals, like myself, yearn for you to reach out to us. We deeply desire that our faithful convictions--more progressive in nature--receive resonation on the national level.

Re-communicating things of faith, though, Ms. Stabenow, does not mean a watering down of who you are. More progressive Christians do not desire that all politicians 'convert to Christianity,' 'Christianize' their rhetoric, or espouse some proper degree of religiosity in order to quell their constituency. We simply want you to be honest about who you are and where you come from. We simply want you to talk about progressive values in a context that expresses their congruence with issues of faith--whether that faith is Christian or not.

People everywhere, regardless of their religious heritage, have grave concerns over this proposed budget. It is woefully incongruent with the historic tenets of Christianity or most other world religions. Please speak out on my behalf, and on the behalf of countless other faithful Americans."


[emphasis mine]

March 14, 2005

Thanks

The mighty Zalm (who has a very attractive template for his blog, btw) pointed out that I had not closed a blockquote tag. You know how much I like the blockquote tags!

So, now I have learned a valuable lesson. It is a poor blogger who blames his blogging tools. Or, something....

Fancier soundtrack

What I am listening to now.

Blogger problems

It seems that my template problems only occur in Safari. They display fine in IE, so you Windows users are probably wonder what the hell I am doing. Oh well. I am still playing with this. Right now, in Safari, the profile stuff and archive information display fine--just all the way at the bottom of the page.

New Look

I was having problems with the old template and decided it was time for a change. Not sure this is working completely right, but we shall see.

Yeah, this scares me!

buddenblog: Teaching US History, Right Wing Christian Style: "'....Providential history is true history.  Many modern educators deny the Providential view of history and would have us believe that their promotion of one of several 'secular' views of history is simply the recounting of brute facts.  They fail to tell their students that their own humanistic presuppositions and religious doctrines determine their choice of people, places, principles and events.  They fail to communicate that neutrality is not possible in the teaching of history, for the historians word-view will dictate his perspective.  Even as there are not many interpretations of Scripture (2Pet.1:20,21), neither are there of history ... there is really only one correct view; that which is the Author's [i.e. God´s] interpretation and perspective.  God is the Author of Scripture and History. "


Only one view of history? And I am wondering how this Providential view of history explains attempted Indian genocide, slavery, child labor, Japanese Internment?

This is more David Barton style of history and demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of how history is practiced. I guess if you don't like the conclusions, you just change the approach. But the real tragedy is that the historical conclusion are not the threat to people of faith that they seem to think. Their approach, however, is a huge threat to the rest of us.

If only I could find an example of politicans using the Christian Right as a tool? Oh, wait....


Yahoo! News - Casino Bid Prompted High-Stakes Lobbying
: "He looked to Reed, the former Christian Coalition leader who operated several consulting companies. Reed has acknowledged receiving as much as $4 million from Abramoff and his associate, Scanlon, to organize grass-roots anti-gambling campaigns in Louisiana and Texas. The money came from casino-rich Indian tribes, including the Coushattas, but Reed said that although he knew of Abramoff's connection to the tribes, he did not know until media accounts surfaced last summer that his fees came from gambling proceeds.

Reed then turned to Dobson to marshal his vast network of evangelicals, Abramoff's e-mails show.

Abramoff wrote to Scanlon in a Feb. 20, 2002, e-mail that Dobson would make radio ads against gambling. Reed 'may finally have scored for us! Dobson goes up on the radio on this next week!' He suggested giving Reed $60,000 for the ads to run in Louisiana and Texas. 'We'll then play it in the WH [White House] and Interior,' he told Scanlon."

Christianity, commodification, and Wal-Mart

Yesterday, Streak's other friend and I had lunch with friends at a great Asian place in Oklahoma City. After a great lunch, we drove over to Oklahoma City's own Full Circle Bookstore which is one of those rare locally owned bookstores. We rarely pass up a chance to visit.

I have written here many times about the danger of conservative evangelicals selling out their faith. As much as I dislike the current president and his policies, much of my concern is for those conservatives who are true believers and for the conservative church as a whole. Once you sell out, it is hard to retrieve that reputation.

The danger for the church in so blindly following Bush or referring to him (as someone did on another blog) as our "Bible-believing Christian President," is that you then risk your entire religious reputation on this politician. When he acts badly, you look bad--especially when you don't speak out. And since you have stated things like "God wants Bush for these times" you can't criticize him very well, since that would be criticizing God.

The dangers are many. One of them is that you have made your faith a marketing and political tool--just another one in a vast market place. That means that people who don't really believe what you believe are willing to do whatever to convince you otherwise to sell you their candidate, movie, or, hell, face cream. What is to stop a politician from repeating the "faith talk" to get your vote and then enacting policies that undermine both your faith and your lives. (One could argue that Bush has already done that, but I will leave that for another day.) In any case, it makes you incredibly vulnerable to hucksters and fakers and con-artists.

I really wasn't thinking about that at the bookstore yesterday. But while sitting in front of their fireplace, I read parts of a new book on the class-action suit against Wal-Mart. Women are routinely paid less than men, overlooked for promotions, and told to make way for less-qualified men because they are family men. Workers have been locked in stores after clocking out and forced to work with no pay (that called slavery, btw). The company has used its giant power to bully companies, has cozied up to China and any other place that has no worker safety or employment protection laws, and has generally bullied small-town America as well. To be fair, I have never been a fan of the store--I hate the experience of shopping there and resent their predatory tactics.

What does this have to do with turning Christianity into a commodity? Reading the book, it is clear that the company has sold itself as a "family friendly" company, and many of the workers believe that Sam Walton was not only a good Christian man, he was a devoted family man. Many of these women workers applied for jobs there because of that perception and hoped to participate in a pro-family business. Evidently Walton was not much of a family man--his widow said that he was not around the family that much, which kind of makes sense since he was busy building this monstrosity. His faith was pretty tepid as well--he was a nominal church goer (kind of like the President :) ) and didn't tithe as they company myths report. Clearly many of his business tactics are anti-family--at least for those working families that are trying to pay rent and groceries on what they make at Wal-Mart.

But the broader point is that Christianity is being packaged and sold--just like the latest fad in clothing. You guys have succeeded in making Corporate America and Madison Avenue and Washington political offices aware of your buying power and voting power. As a result, they are doing to Christianity what they have done to ethnic identification. Just as they have tried to sell Native American identity to sell cars, or appropriated urban black youth culture to sell to suburban whites, they are now packaging what you claim is your deepest value--a faith in the transforming power of Jesus Christ--to make money and get votes. "Shop at Wal-Mart because we are Christian like you." "Vote for me, I am just like you." Meanwhile both exploit workers and undermine the very faith that you represent. Can you really see Jesus opening a Wal-Mart over the protests of local businessmen, locking workers inside, mocking women workers?

You guys might really reconsider whether your faith is for sale.

March 12, 2005

On life

Others have ongoing discussions about abortion that are more thoughtful than mine. I know it is one of those areas where finding common ground is hard to do. So much of the rhetoric is so extreme. I posted a comment on sharing the committment to life that so many evangelicals have--and a commenter criticized me for not being firm enough on abortion. She said that it was simple and clear--there was never a time when killing fetus was allowable. Fine. But she also defended our wars and bombing efforts as if our "smart" weaponry could avoid killing pregnant women.

Ok, but there are some things that we can really agree on. Or at least I think we can. I read today that 4 million infants die in the first month of life. Those are avoidable deaths, or mostly avoidable. Basic health care and nutrition would drop that number quickly. But we seem to be reducing that kind of care instead of increasing. Most Americans overestimate our foreign aid--believing that we spend somewhere around 15% of our budget on foreign aid when the real number is 1%.

More numbers?

"Lack of health insurance coverage causes 18,000 unnecessary American deaths a year. (That's six times the number of people killed on 9/11.) (NYT, Jan. 12, 2005.)

'U.S. childhood poverty now ranks 22nd, or second to last, among the developed nations. Only Mexico scores lower' (The European Dream, p.81). Been to Mexico lately? Does it look 'developed' to you? Yet it's the only 'developed' country to score lower in childhood poverty.

Twelve million American families--more than 10 percent of all U.S. households--'continue to struggle, and not always successfully, to feed themselves.' Families that 'had members who actually went hungry at some point last year' numbered 3.9 million (NYT, Nov. 22, 2004).

The United States is 41st in the world in infant mortality. Cuba scores higher (NYT, Jan. 12, 2005)."
(emphasis mine)

Consider that, we are 41st in the world in infant mortality. Where are the movements, the parades, the "pray-ins," the vigils outside congress? They don't exist. And maybe liberal Christians need to take the lead here. Bush's policies won't help that number. Not in the least.

Couple of cartoons on the Passion



Or this one:

March 11, 2005

Dammit

Now this?

Comment problem

Been some problems with posting comments lately. I appreciate the effort from many of you and hope that they will fix it soon. Keep the faith and keep trying.

Demons, Ghosts and Elephants--Oh My

"In the Line of Fire" was on TV over the weekend and Clint asks the assassin the great question: "At night, when the demons come, what do you see?"

Those demons come at night--in that period between sleep and wakefulness--and poke at our fears and insecurities. You are worthless, you are a fraud. You are not smart or good or thoughtful. You are a bad friend, bad relative, bad husband, bad wife.

In the light of day, those same demons show up. Inner voices--snakes of doubt.

What of the mighty elephant? He sits in our living room while we take great effort to ignore him. I thought there was more sitting space in this room. It feels half the size. We walk around him--refusing to face him wishing he would leave, wishing he didn't constantly expose our basic fears.

Demons and elephants need confrontation. Demons to be told to shut the hell up. You aren't right and you aren't even that scary. Elephants just need recognition. The issue they represent is often not nearly as big as the effort used to avoid and ignore him. We need to say to him: Stampy, you are not a bad elephant, but you will ultimately kill us all if we don't take you outside. Now, here is a peanut.

Ghosts? Maybe we need to spend more time contemplating living with ghosts, or the ghosts that haunt me, or when a ghost is born. No, this isn't a 6th Sense kind of thing. It is just those people and pets and relationships that are in the room with us all the time. They have good things to tell us.

Exactly

Black Sheep Christian has a good link from publictheologian (their site was down when I clicked, so read it on BSC). Anyway, more discussion about the problems for Conservative Christians who say, quite honestly and earnestly that they care about the poor. Yet, they consistently vote for policies that hurt the poor. At some point, they need to explain that contradiction.

"'So while I don't think that conservatives hate the poor, I also don't think that they are doing what they can to make things better for the poor. Motives, in the end, are notoriously slippery to judge. But conservatives saying that they are concerned about the poor seems quite strange when the policies that the same people are supporting are throwing more people into poverty. To me the simple question is this: If they care so much, then why are they using their political power to make the rich even richer and matters worse for the poor? How many million more people will have to fall below the poverty line before Christian conservatives who care about the poor will be willing to change their policies and raise taxes, for example? Would one million people do it? Two? Five? Is there any point at which the Republican orthodoxy of lower taxes and less government would be jettisoned by Christians in the Republican Party? Or how many million more Americans will have to lose their health insurance before Christian conservatives would be willing to share their health care dollars so that their neighbor could have some coverage too? I think that party orthodoxy has to give way to genuinely serving the poor in the face of the mounting evidence that what Bush is doing is not working. The plight of the poor has to be central to the ethics of Christians of every stripe if the scripture is to be taken seriously, but while I hear an acknowledgement of this, I don't see one coming from my conservative brothers and sisters.'"

March 10, 2005

Hee's bacck!

Just when you think you have survived the last year, Mel Gibson is
is back with the 'The Passion Recut'
. Yay. Wow, I was really bummed that Mel's psychotic vision had passed from the scene and am so GLAD that it is back!

Well, not really. I can't even watch Chicken Run since Mel's last bit. Mad Max really played a lot of a people. I wrote a lot about this last year, and it still stands up here. The implications of Mel's duplicity are here.

Reading over my stuff, I still feel good about it. Mel played us all. He appealed to ethnocentrism, fear of Hollywood, conservative Christian self-righteousness, and even fears of violence in film. He sold you the bill of goods that "liberals" and "jews" didnt' want you to see a Catholic film that, in a different time and place, you would have resisted and protested along the lines of "The Last Temptation of Christ." But played and manipulated, you flocked to this film and scorned those who didn't like it.

For the record, many of you really felt a strong connection to the film. I don't have a problem with that. But don't you dare dismiss those who have legitimate concerns about this film and about the way it has been marketed and promoted to make millions and millions of dollars. It can still be a deep experience, but it is also a crass expression.

March 9, 2005

What the hell do you all stand for?

Yeah, that's right. It is time for a rant. Couple of stories today caught my eye and made me angry about the Repubs and their conservative Christian handlers (or is that the other way around?). First, on NPR, a story about the office that is supposed to protect whistleblowers in our government. You know. Those people who are brave enough to step forward and say that there is waste or ineffeciancy or corruption? Well, the office that oversees that is run by, shock, a Bush appointee who has clamped down on whistleblowing. That's right, the agency tasked with protecting whistleblowers is being charged with punishing whistleblowers. Oh, and this same Bush appointee scrubbed their website of any reference to sexual orientation. Come on! You guys may think that gays are going to hell, but do you really support them being discriminated against openly? Might want to reread that Bible thing.

Before I move on to the next story, let's recap. Republicans and Conservative Christians stand for the following:

1) helping the rich
2) screwing the environment (the more mercury in women's bodies, the better!)
3) screwing the poor (see number one) with harsher bankruptcy policies, no minimum wage increase, more uninsured Americans--yeah, that is right there in the Bible where Jesus lashed out at the poor people for not working hard enough and complimented the rich. Wait, that isn't in the Bible at all!
4) hampering government cleanup efforts

Ok, now on to rant part 2.1. Listening to local radio here in OK, there is a movement afoot to put a moritorium on the death penalty until we can review it. Oklahoma is number 2 in executions (behind Compassionate Conservative Christian George W. Bush's Texas) and some people recognize that we MIGHT be executing THE INNOCENT!

Oklahoma is a big Christian state, right? Churches on every fucking corner. Can't drive anywhere without seeing more and more churches? Yet, do we see God's people standing up to say that we should, at the very least, investigate this death penalty machine? Nope. Way to go. Conservative Christians are once again convincing me that they don't give a shit about the poor, criminals or the environment.

And here is an irony I can't quite escape. Conservatives in general, and this is mimicked in the Christian community as far as I hear, HATE government and think it is inefficient and corrupt. Yet when this inefficient and corrupt government KILLS people, they think it is perfect. Please to explain this?

My only explanation is to say that Conservative Christians and Conservatives like killing people more than they hate government. Of course, when that same government kills people in Waco or Ruby Ridge it is wrong, so it must be that they care very little for the poor and the non-white who so often end up in our Capital Punishment system. Just as Jesus mocked the poor and colored of his day, and berated them to act more like the rich. Jesus was famously fond of the death penalty and said that those behind it were well-intentioned and moral people.

Wait a minute.....that isn't what he said at all? When did Jerry Falwell and James Dobson rewrite the Bible?

March 8, 2005

Living With Ghosts

Streak's other friend and I had a "driveway" moment this morning. Well, perhaps more accurately, a parking lot moment at Starbucks. NPR interviewed Arlo Guthrie and his daughter, Sarah Lee and her husband on the occasion of her first album release. It was a charming interview about someone growing up with a famous father and famous grandfather who didn't even know much about her grandfather's music until she was an adult.

The exchange between father and daughter was really nice--the mutual concern came through. Arlo was on a phone in one place, and the other two somewhere else. At the end of the interview, they played just a bit of "This Land is your land," with Arlo playing the guitar and the others singing over the phones. They really sounded great. At the end of that phrase, Arlo said, "I think I heard Woody in there too."

I think I heard him too.

Jesus Politics: Roy Moore: 'We Have No Morality Without an Acknowledgment of God'

Kevin has a great comment on Carlos's blog. Evidently Roy Moore is saying that unless we put up his graven images monuments, we can't be moral. Melissa (I don't know her) left a comment, "Faith and Hope is what this country is missing. Too bad this country can't acknowledge God as well as place their faith in him too." I am all for faith and hope and even faith in God, but why are the people saying this the ones who are demonizing the poor and celebrating war? Why are they embracing wealth and watching their president cut funding for disabled poor and veterans?

Anyway, Kevin says it better than me.

Jesus Politics: Roy Moore: 'We Have No Morality Without an Acknowledgment of God' : "The problem is that this lip service is empty and hollow. It doesn’t mean anything to me when George W. acknowledges God with one hand while starving poor people with the other. It doesn’t mean anything to me when the government says in God We Trust yet uses half of its discretionary budget for building up the military. It doesn’t mean anything to me when George W. says he prays and reads the Bible, yet lies through his teeth about reasons for wars, Social Security and just about everything else. Being a Christian doesn’t mean you get to do whatever you want. It means you obey Jesus and follow his teachings, or at least make an effort to do so. It doesn’t mean you get to be a Pharisee. It means you have to actually do something to help the hurting people around you."

Catching up on some other blogs

Natalie has written some really good posts, so if you don't read her blog, you should. This post on women reminded me of much of my journey. Despite a lot of discussions in SBC circles about women not preaching or about me supposed to assume some "spiritual headship" in my family, those never made sense. In college I was surrounded by strong and bright women who taught me a great deal. This old view of masculinity sounded false. Reading about women's history in grad school cemented that frustration. Reading Nat's post, titled "What happened?" reminded me of that.

panta ta ethne: What happened?: "So, in 1914 members of the SBC were talking about things like racial justice, world peace, improving working conditions, and public health. And even before 1914 until, well, last September, SBC women were calling for gender equality. Interestingly enough, it seems that SBC leaders who want to subordinate women can’t even appeal to their own tradition. I’ve only heard a little about a “fundamentalist takeover” in the SBC—is that what happened? Where have the conversations and concerns about world peace and social justice gone? (Oh, and before I get accused again of making the SBC into a “whipping boy,” let me say that I know from experience that not all SBC churches warrant this criticism. But there’s a whole lot that do, and the SBC has national and international influence, which makes raising this question pretty important, no?)"


It is even worse than that. Many evangelicals (if I remember my Nathan Hatch) were toying with racial and gender equality during the second awakening. But now we have people like Dobson telling women that they are supposed to submit, and that is direct from God (you can trust Dr. Dobson on that!). Sorry. I don't buy it.

Way to go Nat. It is people like you who can break down some of these barriers.

Annoyed this morning

So, while this is not a shock, the Senate repubs defeated an effort to raise the minimum wage while pushing for ways to strengthen creditors and make it harder to declare bankruptcy. Make no mistake about it, I don't like people running up big credit card debt and then declaring bankruptcy, but the credit card companies encourage just that by targeting the young and poor. Why does the Senate reward them?

As for the rest of the world--the working poor, once again the Republicans led by the Religious Right are making their world more difficult. Always defending the people with money, they refuse to raise the minimum wage to a livable level. These are the working poor--the people with a couple of jobs who are trying to raise their families.

But Streak, I thought the Christian Conservatives cared about the family? Wouldn't that be nice. But it turns out that they prefer focusing on the 10 Commandment idol worship statues than the working poor. Or my gay neighbors. Anything but addressing the working poor and the fact that there are 50 million uninsured Americans or that nearly half of bankruptcies occur because of medical costs. So much easier to read Tim Lahaye and believe that if we just had school prayer everything would be fine.


Yahoo! News - Senate Defeats Minimum Wage Increase
"These include an option for employees to work up to 80 hours over two weeks without qualifying for overtime pay; a provision restricting the ability of states to raise the minimum wage for restaurant employees; and waiving wage and overtime rules for workers in some small businesses now covered."


I love how that is phrased--an option for employees to work up to 80 hours over two weeks without qualifying for overtime. As if employees really want that. I am sure they are being held back from the hours because their employers are too cheap to pay overtime, but that doesn't mean that they want to work more hours for less pay.

I think it is fair to say that Repubs have won on the language thing, but their policies are counter to their stated ideals. They make things easier for the rich and harder for the working poor.

March 7, 2005

From Bad Catholic, a great quote on the ten commandments

Bad Catholic: To help us know what to do: "Christan Stapleton, 13, of Newland, N.C., carried a homemade, cardboard Ten Commandments tablet. She came to the Supreme Court with her church and family members.

'We do need them in our school,' she said, 'to help us know what to do, what God wants us to do as we go through our day.'"


Yeah, this is crap. If this 13 year old girl needs the 10 commandments to guide her day, then she is in trouble. And let's be clear here. It isn't this particular 13 year old that the Religious Right and Roy Moore are thinking of. Just as in school prayer, the issue isn't the kids who want to pray, it is those who don't. The attempt here is to coerce the heathens from down the street. A little honesty would be nice.

March 6, 2005

Movie review

Last night, we watched

Silver City (2004)


I am a bit of a John Sayles fan. I think Lonestar maybe one of my favorite movies, and his Sunshine State is also quite impressive. Nuanced films that address the complexity of life and often refuse to demonize people.

There is no doubt that Sayles is not a fan of George Bush and this film is really much like Steve Earle's "The Revolution Starts Now" in that it was created with the explicit goal of attacking the president. Earle's album was not his best work, but it really stands on its own with several memorable tunes, and a few that are over the top, including his "Condi, Condi, Condi" and the angry "F the FCC."

But back to Sayles. He addresses a lot of themes about the complexity of the political landscape in this film. Chris Cooper plays a really good version of Bush--fumbling over his sentences in a way that is really hard to do, and showing some intellecutal limitations when dealing with the complexities of Colorado politics.

Sayles definately presents a conspiratorial world, where corporate giants own politicians and are the driving force behind Cooper's character. Those corporate hogs manipulate and intimidate the press, always trying to manage the public and manipulate them into following certain ideas (reduced regulation, lower taxes, etc.) all the while seeking to open more and more of the West to developers. Cooper's character is aptly named "Dickie Pillager" and the family in fact acts out their name.

All of that is interesting and provocative. I think that many Christian Conservatives end up supporting politics that are really counter to their core values. And I fear that the encroachment on free speech is starting in earnest. 20 something states have proposed laws to restrict college professors from discussing politics in their classes. The first ammendment implications are quite horrifying and I really don't think that my conservative friends really support that, but they are following someone who uses "moral values" to distract them from oil company profits. People who like to talk about the founding fathers are looking the other way while Bush excludes dissenting voices, hires journalists to stump for him, and actually allows a gay prostitute to act as a shill in the White House press room.

That part of the film is interesting, but Sayles never really pulls it together. And unlike the other two films I mentioned, this film is too explicitly political. His other stuff is gently subversive; this one hits you with a sledge hammer. His film, Steve Earle, Green Day's "American Idiot" and Micheal Moore all speak to the intense anti-Bush feeling that so many conservatives dismiss as sour grapes. But there are real reasons that people resent this administration. Unfortunately, this film won't convince them.

Ten commandments

The 10cs are at the court again. For so many Christians, this is a bellwether of how America approaches spirituality or something. If we ban the 10 Commandments from court rooms or schools, our society is rejecting God. It reminds me of the rather magical approach to the Bible and prayer. As if this statue or framed list is all God needs to reassure him. That God isn't very deep and is easily manipulated. This reminds me of idol worship--the kinds the Bible warns people about.

From the McCarty's blog a Vonnegut quote (actually Kristen got this from Zalm's blog:
"For some reason, the most vocal Christians among us never mention the Beatitudes. But, often with tears in their eyes, they demand that the Ten Commandments be posted in public buildings. And of course that’s Moses, not Jesus. I haven’t heard one of them demand that the Sermon on the Mount, the Beatitudes, be posted anywhere."


That is a great point. Wouldn't that sound different if Christians were clamoring to have those posted? The problems with the 10 Commandments as public policy are numerous. JoeG left a nice comment on this over at Jesus politics and I thought I would post it here. Much of the ten commandments--if enacted into law--would be unconstitutional. You can't force an American to worship God. You can't limit free speech, even if taking the Lord's name in vain really means swearing.

Jesus Politics: The New American Christian Taliban: "Can we do a quick analysis of the Ten Commandments here? Here's the text from Exodus. I want one of the literal interpretationists (Chameleon, Libby, etc.) to give a response to some of this, to show how these commandments really and truly formed the basis of U.S. law, and how this led us to become a Christian nation. Shall we?

1. 'I am the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. Thou shalt have no other gods before me. Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; And shewing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments.'

- OK, any laws on the books about having a single god or mandating a monotheistic religion? That one would criminalize Buddhists, Hindus, Wiccans, atheists, all in one shot. As well as their children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren. Second, the whole 'graven image' thing flies in the face of the arguments to display the Ten Commandments monuments in the first place. It can also be interpreted to say that having a crucifix is a sin. Hmmm...

2. Thou shalt not take the name of the LORD thy God in vain; for the LORD will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain.

- Anything out there that outlaws using God's name? How many people would be in trouble for saying 'Oh my god!' or something like it?

3. 'Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labour, and do all thy work: But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates: For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it.'

- No laws about six-day work weeks. 'Blue laws' closing businesses on Sundays are disappearing. Everyone go to church on Sunday? Any legal punishment if you don't?

4. 'Honour thy father and thy mother: that thy days may be long upon the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee.'

- Emancipation laws allow kids to 'divorce' their parents. Do you still have to honor them if they are physically, sexually, or emotionally abusive?

5.'Thou shalt not kill.'
- OK, finally one that's on the books. But this one is basic to almost every religion. It's also one that is routinely broken throughout the bible.

6. 'Thou shalt not commit adultery.'
- Grounds for divorce, but not necessarily illegal.

7. 'Thou shalt not steal.'
- Second one on the books.

8. 'Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour.'
- All lying is not illegal. Definitely when under oath, or in cases like criminal impersonation, etc.

9 and 10. 'Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's house, thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's wife, nor his manservant, nor his maidservant, nor his ox, nor his ass, nor any thing that is thy neighbour's. '

- No laws about this either. I can covet all I want. If I don't act on it, I'm not committing any crime. If I do act on it, it's covered by the adultery and theft stuff already.

OK, so three out of 10 commandments are actually covered by U.S. law. How the hell, then, is there any argument that the Bible and the commandments are the basis of our legal system??? I know this may have been a long-winded, somewhat ridiculous exercise, but it lays everything out on the table that goes toward the arguments in favor of the Ten Commandments displays."

March 5, 2005

Music Plug--Kathleen Edwards

After a rant, I like to do something positive. Well, kind of. Anyway, this last Tuesday--right before I headed out of town--I bought the new Kathleen Edwards album, "Back to Me."


I really liked her first album, Failer, so was anxious to hear this one. She has a real smoky voice and I like the writing.

Albums always take time--at least good ones--to mature in my mind. So, I can't guarantee that this is a great album. But I like it very much so far and have listened to it quite a bit.

Back

Traveling kind of sucks, I must say. By the end of this particular trip, I had lost much of my charity and compassion for people. I felt like telling giddy college kids to "shut the hell up," and the couple across the aisle to save their post-Cancun stories for somewhere where I didn't have to hear it. I didn't say those things, of course, but thought them. And sometimes stared at the offenders.

Anyway, a couple of thoughts. I was in Minnesota for a few days and it is a vastly different state than Oklahoma. Not just talking the cold here, but the entire dialogue.

They have a Repub governor who is trying to cut taxes desperately. After all, Republicans have identified taxes as part of the axis of evil along with gays, Iran, fuel efficient cars, and anyone not willing to wear their faith on their sleeve. Yet, Minnesota is widely known for an excellent school system. Contrast that with Oklahoma, which has much lower taxes, and a much lower education system. How is it that my good conservative friends don't see that connection? Education is an investment (not to overly use economic terms here) in the future. It has intangible and, yes, even economic benefits down the road in lower crime, higher productivity, etc. Yet we are unwilling to pay for such services. I am really, really tired of it. Taxes aren't the problem. Energy lobbyists are the problem. Maybe lobbyists in general. Maybe every corporation who has a hand out and sleeps in the Lincoln Bedroom under any administration watch.

Speaking of taxes, Streak's other friend and I were talking about SUVs on the way to Starbucks. She had a conversation with someone who had one and admitted that they bought it because they got a sizable tax break to buy one. Get that? Tax break to buy something that is harmful to the roads, environment, other drivers, and our future and current wars. Tax break. Not for teaching at a public school. Not for contributing to our society. Tax break for buying a detrimental product. Think how stupid it would be if you got a tax break for investing in a meth lab. People would be outraged.

So the next time you hear the Fake News people on the tax mantra, consider that. People need to start thinking about their taxes in less selfish and whiney ways. Sorry, but that is the truth. You aren't over taxed, and if you make a good living, you definately aren't over taxed. You all benefit to a certain degree from our system of government, economic freedoms, government subsidized highway system, education system (shitty as it might be), artificially low price of oil, etc. Make a goddamn difference instead of bitching about your taxes! Plant a tree for the future. Try to help our education system instead of complaining about "administrative costs."

Oh, and while I am on SUV's, STOP PARKING IN THE FUCKING HANDICAPPED SPOT AT STARBUCKS WHILE YOUR STUPID-ASS WIFE AND KID GO GET YOUR MOCHA FRAPPE! Laziness and stupidity and vanity are not handicaps--they represent a lack of character.

Ok, I feel better now. Missed these rants, didn't you? :)

March 1, 2005

Light Blogging

Going to be out of pocket for a bit. Will blog if I get the chance, but otherwise, see you on the weekend.

February 27, 2005

Interesting essay on the issue of history and religion in America

The New York Times > Week in Review > Putting God Back Into American History

"Barton is a very hard-working researcher, but what I guess I worry about is the collapsing of historical distance, and the effort to make really anybody fit directly into the category of the early 21st century evangelicals," said Mark A. Noll, a prominent historian at Wheaton College, a prestigious evangelical school."


I have the utmost respect for Noll. He is a solid scholar and thoughtful Christian to boot, but I think he is being far too kind here. Barton's "research" is all flawed because he starts with a conclusion and only looks for evidence to bolster that conclusion. As Noll notes, there are certainly Ivy League historians who do the same thing from the other side, but that is no excuse for Barton. History is written with good questions in mind, not with conclusions. Barton assumes that our founders and good Americans along the line have all believed like him, and so he picks and chooses the quotes to justify that. He also ignores anything that works against him--something all historians have to battle with. But he doesn't even try. After all, like Bush, he believes that God is on his side. The rest of the historical profession doesn't have that luxury. Please stop calling Barton a historian. He is a propagandist.

"People care passionately about the founders because they want the founders to be like them," Mr. Brookhiser said. "So you get this from Christians, and you get it from secularists who say the founders are like them and want them to be 'closet deists.' " His own view: "They probably couldn't conceive that the country could ever change so much. But, look, if they wanted a Christian state they could have done it. They were writing the rules. They could have put God in the rules."


Great point and one that is often missed when people look at the past. People like to identify with these figures in history--either completely positive or completely negative. We appropriate these figures, remove them from history, and use them for our own purposes. And, as he notes, people on the left do it too. I don't deny that. But Barton and his crowd do it exclusively. That is history to him.

Building on that point, we have to recognize that people in the past are complicated and often contradictory. They say one thing, do another. It happens. They want one thing, and act for another. Both sides in this debate forget that. Can't we acknowledge that Christianity made a huge contribution to our nation's founding, but that contribution was both positive and negative? Christianity pushed for moral values in our nation, but also defended and fought for slavery and Indian eradication? Both are true.

"Sure, God shows up on the bad stuff," Mr. Barton said in an interview. "We don't hear much about the five revivals in American history, but we always hear about the Salem witch trials." Still, he said, he only sought to dust off the fact of the founders' Christianity, not to argue for or against it. "If we are arguing off the premise that we have to be secular today because we have always been secular," he said, "then we are arguing off the wrong premise."


Barton is the king of bad logic. As a culture, we have always been and continue to be quite religious. But it is also clear that many people feared combining that religion with our public policy. And the Salem remark makes me really think that Barton hasn't read much history. Many historians, certainly Boyer and Nissenbaum do not blame Christianity for Salem. They approach it as a community problem that has more to do with economic opportunity. Here is where Barton's lack of training shows up. He doesn't really know the past except for what he wants to know.

Unfortunately, a lot of people listen to him. That may be ultimately the fault of the professional historian crowd who don't know how to communicate to the public. But it also shows how the conservative church has distanced itself from intellectual debate--or at least decided it doesn't have to listen to intellectual debate it disagrees with. I think that might be the definition of anti-intellectualism.

To avoid ending this post on a bad note, let me suggest some good readings. Mark Noll, as noted above, is a very good historian. His Scandal of the Evangelical Mind is a must read, though it will likely be confronting for some. He has co-written another book on American religious history--Search for Christian America, and others. Nathan Hatch's Democratization of American Christianity is a great book, and I have already plugged Paul Boyer's Salem Possessed, but it is a great read. He also wrote a great book on the historical background of the Tim LaHaye view of end times. When Time Shall Be No More. Please don't just listen to David Barton. Read some of these books. And there are more. Leave any suggestions in the comments.

February 26, 2005

Why am I not in church?

JWS raised an excellent question yesterday when he asked about my view of the church. As he and Anglican remind me, there are a lot of people in "the" church who share my values. The Anglican church was not pro-war, and has been progressive on many issues I care about. The two here in town are active about poverty and social justice and are not just local meetings for the republican party, though I know some repubs attend both.

I too often refer to "the church" and really mean the conservative church. That is my past and I am trying to make sense of it. There is much positive there, and I am not badmouthing or dismissing the entire conservative church, but as my other posts reveal, I am annoyed with their political and social direction. JWS referred to it (perhaps tongue in cheek) as prophesying. I don't know about that, but I do see things that bother me about the conservative church.

Why don't I go to church? As in many things, this is a complicated question with a complicated answer. (You really didn't think I would answer this one simply, did you? :) ) I grew tired of church at some point. The last church I attended was SBC in Houston and it was actually everything I love and despise about church all in one building. This was an impressive church--one that refused to leave the inner city of Houston for the suburbs--that didn't have bowling alleys or health clubs or restaurants on their grounds (things that 1st and 2nd Baptist did). The church spent a lot of effort on helping the poor, and the sick. Before many in the SBC had figured this out, this church was active helping people with AIDS.

The pastor was a true intellectual. I went to meet with him and we discussed literature, history and philosophy. He had read widely and those references showed up in his sermons. He was one of those truly gifted speakers, who almost sang his sermons--weaving in thoughtful and in-depth insights not just on the Bible, but on other issues of the day.

He was a rarity in my mind, because one of the reasons I no longer attend a SBC church is the weight attached to the sermon. Greg reminds me that sermons have a place in our churches for people to speak prophetically. (That don't mean predicting the future, either, but speaking critically of the day). And I recognize that. I think, however, that centering a service around a 30+ minute sermon is, in most hands, mind numbing. And that was one of the reasons I stopped going. Listening to people drone on with largely redundant sermons started to really bug me. Only so much day dreaming I could do. I finally decided that I preferred my Sunday mornings a different way.

But what about the rest of church, you ask? Well, Sunday School as long as I can remember (with some exceptions) was more of a waste than church. I really would like to find the person who came up with the SS Quarterly and have a few words. That thing was pure crap. I never realized it growing up, but it is part and parcel of the dumbing down of the SBC church. No complex theology need apply, SS becomes like the Simpsons parodies it. Most questions can be answered with "love, Jesus," or possibly "Jesus loves."

Certainly along the way, there were some teachers who stepped outside that pabulum and taught interesting and engaging lessons, but those were the rarity. Even at this church in Houston, the ss class we first joined was about as mindless as possible. We loved all the other couples in the class and our teachers were so nice. But the class blew. I was just starting grad school at the time and was developing a short fuse for mindless talk. I finally found an alternative class where there were some real ideas bouncing around.

The other issue was political. Having always been a SBC person, we watched in horror as conservatives took over the SBC and proceeded to gut it. After talking to Bruce Prescott, I realize we were right at the epicenter of the resistance movement, but didn't realize it. When we left Houston, I had enough of that denomination and was right in the middle of grad school. At that point, I had lost interest and simply didn't have it in me to start again.

Ok, where am I now?

I have toyed with some local churches and most likely would be an Anglican if I were to attend. I am still trying to figure church out and determine what we are supposed to be or trying to do there. That is why I asked the worship question, and I am interested in what people think of prayer and even the purpose for church. I am not badmouthing those who go, but I haven't figured it out for me.

I think I will attend a church in the future. Let me say, however, that there are certain churches that need not apply (or visit).

1) not interested in a church that is built around a personality. I don't think that is the purpose of the church anyway, but when that person leaves, the church is usually hosed. This includes liberal churches. And while I am speaking on that, as much as I dislike most sermons, I want someone with theology training, not communication. This isn't a performance.

2) not interested in a church that is still arguing about the following things: women's equality, women pastors, or having men as head of the family. I am not saying you can't talk about those things, but I am done with it. I have spent far too much time around bright and thoughtful women (even married one) to tell women to submit or not speak. Like I said, if that is what you want, cool. But don't expect me to be interested. I don't want to change your church, but I won't be attending.

3) Likewise, if the discussion is still about innerrancy I am not interested.

4) I also don't really want to attend a church with the American flag next to the alter. I am a proud American (except when Bush speaks), but I don't like this combination. I think it is dangerous to both the church and our democracy. No pledge of allegiance, no pro-military celebrations, no Toby Keith (though I think that goes without saying).

5) while I am on a list of don'ts, here are a few more. No PowerPoint, no CCM (Contemporary Christian Music), no canned music, no crosses on rollers (really saw this in Texas).

In the meantime, I am still trying to figure out what Church is about. I have a pretty strong community around me--made all the stronger by the blogworld, I might add. I find contemplation in other areas, and can study theological issues on my own. I engage with other "believers" all the time. Like I said, I think I will be a part of a church in the future.

February 25, 2005

Comment and interesting question

JWS left an interesting comment on my selling out post and asks a damn good question. One that I fully intend to answer. Just not tonight.

Streak's Blog: Thoughts on selling out: "Which begs a question. Just how is it that you find yourself so disassociated from the Church? To wit, a body of believers, the Body of Christ? Or are you just speaking of the Church, the political institution that meets under the auspices of religiosity?

February 24, 2005

Thoughts on selling out

I have been thinking about what I said in that post and think that it deserves a little more thought. Yes, I think the church has sold out, but I don't think it has received what it thinks it has. "Bait and Switch," should be the cry. You have given what appears to be unquestioned loyalty to this Bush guy in return for..... what? A few smattering of phrases in speeches about faith and Jesus? Working in some hymn phrases in State of the Union speeches? That seems to be all you are getting unless you really value the wealthy more than the poor, and you truly think that the environment doesn't matter. If you are that easy to buy, think about who else will be willing to pay.

I know, I know. I am too hard on the conservative church. I easily fall into the same trap they do, demeaning well-intentioned opposition and dismissing their claims. It's hard not to when your Compassionate Christian Bush has a budget that cuts benefits for the poor while padding the pockets of the rich.

But I am redundant. I know you won't become Democrats, and I can respect that. Not only are there many problems with the DNC, but there is a long and worthy tradition of conservative thought in this country. (Remember I said that when you badmouth liberals, btw).

But, you in the church have become distracted by unsolvable or imaginary problems while ignoring real moral and social ills that can be helped. You need to stop this badmouthing of gays. You aren't stopping anyone from being gay--you are merely insuring that they will hate you. Is that really what you want? They laugh about you--how you talk about compassion and love, but are perfectly willing to badmouth them and their families. Stop it.

And you are easily distracted trying to convince the rest of us that a) America is a Christian nation, and b) that means that your views are superior. Everytime you load up busses of people to go support a fascist like Roy Moore, you look silly. When you organize protests about the "under God" phrase, you look silly.

Here is a radical thought. You want to prove that America is a Christian nation and that your view of Christianity is so very powerful? Do it. But not by rallying around televangelists and opportunists. Not by buying Tim LaHaye and Rick Warren books. Not by lionizing a nut like Mel Gibson.

Do it, as the kids say, "old school." Take as your challenge to America to dramatically reduce poverty and uninsured people in this country. Work with liberals and Catholics who are concerned about this and let your actions be your witness. Eradicate child poverty. Reduce the uninsured so the poor can attempt good health. Eradicate infant mortality. Investigate and act when corporations endanger the poor by dumping carcinogens into drinking water.

You say you want them to work? Fine. Don't confuse the work with deserving to live, but we all agree that work and some degree of autonomy is a good thing. Teach the poor to read and help them get jobs. Help them avoid the traps of consuming themselves into poor health or bankruptcy. Help them form sustainable businesses that make a difference to their community. Put pressure on Congress to force insurance companies to open up these pools to the poor and working poor.

All these things I just said? They are possible. And if these were your priorities, you would not only demonstrate Christ's love, you would validate yourselves as institutions across this land. You would not have to battle over whether we were a christian nation or not, because even non-Christians would respect you as doing good work.

Unless, of course, you prefer to be disliked. And if you do, maybe you need to talk to a therapist.

February 23, 2005

This is funny and sad all at the same time

"feed the rich. The other day I was walkin down the street an I saw another one. He was practically freezin in the bitter cold; all he had was a tin cup, a three-piece suit, and a limousine with no minibar. He had a sign that said WILL CHEAT EMPLOYEES OUT OF RETIREMENT PLANS FOR FOOD. It was another homeless CEO. "


read the whole thing here

Greg is shrill, and I like it!

the parish: Villagers! Pitchforks! Torches!: "We're entering into a new age of academic (and ecclesial) coercion. The Southern Baptist Convention has been at it for a while. I understand the Nazarene Church is considering a measure to subject theology and religion professors to examination by regional or district superintendents. Great! Guys with business degrees and D.Min.'s cross-examining theologians about theology. The conservative, evangelical churches are not going to be happy until this purity movement has eliminated all traces of 'liberalism.' That's a scary, scary way to do church, theology, and community. It squashes theological investigation, silences prophetic voices, and exalts a sort of theological mediocrity that coheres to least common denominator ecclesiology. When we all look like a Purpose Driven Church, when we all sound like Bill Hybels, when Krispy Kremes are available at every visitor information center, when the Bible is once again inerrant and infallible, when women will keep silent in churches and men will scream 'Maximus!' while fencing with the devil, and when the damn homosexuals and liberals are finally cast out of the churches, then the Al Mohlers and Boards of Regents and Presidents of universities and bishops of denominations can rest content that the kingdom has come. Maranatha, Hazel Motes."

Out of curiosity

I visited several of the religious right web sites curious to see how they were dealing with the Guckert/Gannon story. They are ignoring it. Completely.

Several commentators have made an excellent point. The gay prostitute angle is really distracting from a much more important and bigger question--one I might add that conservatives are avoiding like the plague. How did someone get a press pass (requires Secret Service clearance, mind you) under a false name? He could be a Bible salesman and this question would still be pressing.

Make no mistake, had this happened under Clinton, we would be hearing about impeachment at the very least. The outrage would be deafening. The right would be up in arms about liberals and their lax security--playfullness with the truth, etc. But when a conservative President is the one with the fake reporter having access to the highest office, mums the word. This administration is so arrogant, I would not be surprised to find more fake reporters. They hold the press and the public with such disdain, we are amazed.

Once again, I ask, will my conservative readers show half the outrage they mustered for Clinton? Will they consider how they would have responded to this had it happened to Clinton? Will they at least try to adjust that disparity?

Conservatives, you are the only ones who can stop your party from a complete hijacking. If you really care about moral values, then you are responsible for demanding that your party act that way.

February 22, 2005

One more on Gannon/Guckert

Wichita Eagle | 02/21/2005 | LEONARD PITTS: ALL THE NEWS THAT FITS THE REPUBLICAN LINE: "Three weeks later, I'm still waiting for a good explanation of what Jeff Gannon was doing in the White House. And for you to be upset about it."


Exactly. I was going to bed, but thinking about this bothered me so much. Not that the guy is a partisan hack. Not that he is gay and has worked as a gay prostitute (though the last is troubling--simply because it is so self-destructive) and it isn't even the connection to Karl Rove. I have long since been surprised when this guy does something sleezy.

No, my frustration is once again with my conservative friends. The same ones who were indignant with self-righteous anger when Clinton cavorted with Monica (and they were correct that his actions were immoral). Had this happened under Clinton (no pun intended) imagine the outcry. I can hear my conservative friends tsking, "Well, that is what you get with an immoral person like Clinton." and "What do you expect. He can't control his pants, has no morals and hangs around with liberals and lesbians." Hell, I heard on Christian radio that Hilary was gay (and a Marxist).

But for some reason King George continues to escape their outrage. I am beginning to think that they have turned their brains completely off. No need to even question Bush. No need to question Rove. No need. He is talking to God, afterall, unlike Clinton. Or Carter. Of course, Jimmy found a way to attend church--something this Bush is too busy to do. But he is talking to God. And God tells him to protect the rich and bomb other countries. And the evangelical community is silent and even approving.

That is horrible, horrible theology and even worse reasoning. I blogged once that Bush was the worst thing for evangelicals in recent memory because he had fooled them so much and lured them into being shills for a ruthless politician posing as a pius Christian. This most recent event just reinforces that thought. Bush could do just about anything except cheat on Laura and the Bushites would just nod and talk about how moral he is.

The evangelical church is done. Finished. It sold its soul to something far more earthly and base. Might as well start selling ad space next to the steeple. Hey, if you sell out, might as well sell out!

Violence not a good idea, but I feel for this guy

this is aberdeen - news, entertainment, jobs, homes and cars: "A disabled driver who lost his leg in a horrific motorbike smash today defended his decision to smash a teenage girl's car windscreen. "


It pisses me off when I see some fat ass park in the handicapped zone outside Starbucks, so I can imagine how this made this guy feel.

I will say this: people talk about the most important thing that kids should learn? I say compassion for other people should be number 1.

Doesn't impress me

Just curious. Do these people ask that Bush act like a Christian? Or just use some words? And one last thing. Were they praying for Clinton?

Let's just consider this: Compassion? Christian?

I am a bit churlish today. Stressed to the gills and annoyed with this administration. I continue to be stunned that people who wouldn't hang out with, respect, or support a man as arrogant and ruthless as GWB for PTA, continue to support and defend him as President.

But the thing that disappoints the most is the disconnect between what is supposedly moral and christian and what this administration does. This administration talks about being Christian, but doesn't act it. Consider this story about that budget. Jim Wallis is right, budgets are moral documents and this one is immoral.

We are cutting benefits for disabled poor people while increasing support for abstinence only programs that don't work and making tax cuts for already wealthy people permanent. Could someone please fill me in on the Christian morality here? Is there a verse that I am missing about teaching the disabled to beg while rewarding the wealthy? Is this really what Jesus would do?

The New York Times > New York Region > Bush Budget Proposes Halt in Housing Aid for Disabled: "With little fanfare, the Bush administration is proposing to stop financing the construction of new housing for the mentally ill and physically handicapped as part of a 50 percent cut in its housing budget for people with disabilities.

The proposal, which has been overshadowed by the administration's plans to shrink its community development programs, affects what is known as the Section 811 program. Since 1998, Section 811 has helped nonprofit developers produce more than 11,000 units of housing for low-income people with disabilities, including more than 700 in New York State."


And like I said the other day, I am expecting my conservative friends to speak out on this stuff. I don't expect you to become a liberal, but you should ask your representatives or President to act in ways that represent this faith. And this faith isn't to bolster the rich, is it? If it is, I am not interested.

But I don't think it is. This faith calls us all to make a difference in our world and that means reaching out like the Samaritan--not passing up the poor and needy. There is no passage that says "God helps those who help themselves," but there apparently is one that says "Let us help the Rich and leave the poor to their own misery."

This is wrong, and I think you all know it. if you want me to respect this faith, you have to show at least some concern for the poor--at least a portion of what you will show for Roy Moore's ridiculous 10 commandments idol or the "under god" phrase in the pledge. Those are all trivial items. The poor are not. We can disagree about my gay friends, and we can disagree about the best way to reduce abortions. But how do we, as the wealthiest country in the world, turn our backs on the poor?

And what is more troubling. We are doing that even as Christian talk is used in the highest offices in the land. I would prefer to be led by compassionate and thoughtful athiests any day than having to follow compassionless Christians.

Go Reggie

Blame America? When Necessary, Yes. : "However, as a critic of the president, I speak for a lot of people when I say that it's not simple partisanship that motivates us. Many of us believe that President Bush is doing great harm to the United States, and we're concerned about where our nation will stand four years from now."

Interesting column. Two points. One is that many people are writing that they are convinced that Bush is planning to invade Iran soon. Do my conservative readers still think that is a good idea? Will you really give Bush a free hand to do whatever he wants?

Second, as Reggie notes, the "blame America first " accusation is a weird one. Why can people bash the Clinton administration's policies, yet have a cow if someone criticizes Bush's policies? Why are our foreign policy decisions over the last 50 years off limits? Can't you suggest that some of our current problems have to do with bad decisions in the past without being assumed to be anti-American? Put it this way. People love to bash the New Deal. How do you do that and not be America bashing?

February 21, 2005

For my conservative readers

I know that my conservative readers are hardly to vote for a John Kerry. You just won't. You are conservative and I can accept that. So, I don't write this to urge you to switch parties, but merely to urge reasonable policy from your own.

Consider this. What would you do if your president said that there was some evidence that child immunizations were the cause of some medical problems and he was no longer funding them. In fact, he was providing more funding for "alternative" programs that pledged to keep kids safe from polio and rhubella sans immunization. What would you do?

I suspect that most conservatives would say that was dangerous public policy that flew in the face of accepted knowledge on disease and endangered children's lives.

The analogy is not perfect, but it points exactly to what the Bush administration is doing with sex ed. As Nicholas Kristof points out (thanks, btw, to Bad Catholic for the link):

"You see, for all the carnage in President Bush's budget, one program is being showered with additional cash - almost three times as much as it got in 2001. It's 'abstinence only' sex education, and the best research suggests that it will cost far more lives than the Clinton administration's much more notorious sex scandal."


The research shows that the abstinence only programs do not stop kids from having sex. It might be delayed a year, but they are still having sex. And they are far more likely to have unprotected sex when they do.

Make no mistake about it, this is not a wash. This is not just a different way of doing policy that conservatives have won by controlling all branches of government. It isn't just an academic or moral discussion about premarital sex. It is a policy that ignores evidence and puts kids at risk--just as much as if it were suggesting that these kids not be immunized. Or if they were telling parents to not buy car seats. Sure, the kids might be fine in their parent's arms, but the evidence says that the odds are in their favor in a well-made car seat. They might not contract polio, but the odds are in their favor if they are immunized.

They might not have premaritial sex, but the odds are in their favor if they have the tools in hand to make that decision understanding the risks and options of contraceptives.

But Bush is pushing this for his conservative evangelical supporters. Nevermind that he didn't follow that abstinence only program as a kid, understand that he is only pandering here. You can change that and still support him as president (as much as that thought boggles my mind.)

Write your rep and senator and urge them to oppose this. Write the President. Tell him you supported his war, that you voted for his reelection. And tell them you support abstinence and want kids to not be sexually active, but these ab only programs are dangerous and real children will die if we enact them. More than if we don't. It is really that serious.

Worship discussion continued

This post spurred some interesting discussion. Thanks for the comments, everyone. I am still a bit confused about worship. I liked many of the answers. Kevin seems to say that it is an act of respect? Maybe? That we practice worship, regardless of how we feel about ourselves or God at the time. Anonymous also suggests that it is an act that causes us to focus away from ourselves.

GirlGrace, Kathy and JoeG seemed to say that worship is something you experience--kind of that connection to the creator? I am probably misstating your beliefs here, but that is kind of what I heard. I liked Kathy's statement that it "bypasses the reasoning part of the mind and stops where wonder is born." JoeG suggested that it was something that transforms your own life and actually changes how you live. GirlGrace argued that worship is the demonstration God's love toward other people.

Very interesting and, again, I apologize if I misstated anyone's thoughts. Feel free to correct me. I am still unsure what form it takes, but think these are some good places to start. Like GirlGrace, I have experienced something like this outside the church setting, but as Kevin noted, I have found great meaning in church ritual.

I like all of these. Like I said myself in the comments, the one thing I distrust about the word is involved in things like "praise and worship" that, in my mind, manipulate the emotional state of people with music. I have been to enough concerts and even political rallies to know how easy that emotional state can be to create. It isn't a bad thing, mind you, but not necessarily something I would call worship.

I really liked one of GirlGrace's comments on the idea that God doesn't need to be told how great he is. Reminded me of this post from Micah McCarty on the subject.
"But one of the things that he said in the interview really stuck with me. I have had this problem with the whole worship movement of the past several years. I tend to think it is rather shallow and self-serving. Father Boyle seems to feel the same way. He was talking about how we are always singing songs about how good God is and how kind or forgiving or caring, etc. Father Boyle thinks Jesus just looks at us and laughs because He would rather us just be good ourselves and kind and forgiving and caring instead of singing about how He personifies those characteristics.

Therein lies my main problem with the whole worship movement thing. Doesn't it make sense that we are supposed to DO and BE these things instead of singing about how God does them or IS them? That seems to me to be the point of spiritual formation, you know, the whole becoming like Christ thing. But so often we are satisfied with just telling God that we recognize his goodness without ever letting his goodness transform us into being good ourselves. Maybe I'm crazy. I definitely don't think this is a popular idea in most current evangelical circles."

February 20, 2005

Back

We are back from our weekend. A few quick observations.

*First night had dinner at an amazing Taos restaurant. I have tried to eat there before, but the wait was always a problem. Waited outside with a nice couple from South Carolina and then another couple from Denver. The first two were both women and watching them with each other was nice. Hard to observe people who clearly love each other that much and dismiss their experience. Anymore than the second couple who were straight. South Caroline must be a tough place to be gay.

*Texas sucks. During our day and a half in Taos, we ran into several people from Texas and they all annoyed us. (Sorry KL!:)
One of the guests at our B&B wore a UT sweatshirt to breakfast this morning. I made an OU joke, one that acknowledged that they had a better bowl season--she was still a bitch. UT sucks. One nearly ran us off the road pulling his snowmobiles. How obnoxious is that? Snowmobiles are obnoxious to begin with, and then towing them from Texas? Suck.

*Taos is amazing. Great ski hill and really nice town.

*New Mexico still has many racist elements. The entire I-40 drive showed us great old Native American symbols (used to sell trinkets and hats) like, Running Indian (complete with headdress and tomahawk). Horrible. Of course, given that Ann Coulter (tolerated by good Republicans everywhere) wrote an anti-Ward Churchill essay entitled "Little Injun that could", we should not be that surprised. Think of all the analogous references for African Americans or Jews or Italians and then ask if those would be used in a column. Native Americans aren't mascots or punching bags--they are people. I wish that Ann Coulter was.

*Still a great trip. Met some really nice people. Glad to be back.

February 18, 2005

Light Blogging

I will be offline for a bit. Keep coming with the worship definitions. Hah, I gave blog homework.

February 16, 2005

Uh, guys, what the hell is going on?

This from Alternet and found on Kevin's site deserves a hearty, What the hell?

This really speaks to what I have been saying to my conservative evangelical brethren (loosely speaking). You believe in serious stuff. I know that and don't agree with all of it. But the scary part are the people you support and vote for and defend: they don't believe what you believe. They are honoring people like the "Reverend" Moon--people you know are wack jobs and cultists. In a different context, you would be calling for Moon's deportation, which, oddly enough, Jerry Falwell called for prior to the Wackjob Reverend rescuing of Falwell's "college."

But read this story. Has to do with a movement to remove crosses from churches. Not schools. Not courthouses, but churches.

You guys need to start defending your faith.

Soundtrack of my life

Brandon had a nice post on his soundtrack, a soundtrack that includes Patty Griffin which made me happy. Those of you who haven't heard her stuff should. It is good stuff.

I grew up with two older brothers who introduced me to a lot of music that was, well, older than most of the crap my contemporaries listened to. I listened to Pure Prairie League, Fleetwood Mac, Emmylou Harris and Linda Ronstadt, while my friends were listening to disco. I won.

No one in my family seemed to like loud music or electric guitars, so I was pretty convinced that I only liked folk or country music. In high school, I listened to a lot of stuff that makes me wince now. Def Leppard (though the first album was decent) Rush and a few others. After high school, I returned to my folky roots and listened to Bonnie Raitt, Nitty Gritty Dirt Band and others.

My experience with the CCM (Contemporary Christian Music) occurred really in college. I was an Amy Grant fan and saw her in concert a few times. I still like her voice, and we listen to her Christmas album every year. I liked Wayne Watson's voice and really liked him until I met him at a Christian Music camp in Estes Park. What an ass! Michael Card was another one I listened to a lot until I saw him in concert and listened to a 20-25 minute sermon. He wasn't a bad guy, just got on my nerves a bit. Don Franscisco still stands out as one of the few folky Christian writers that I kind of liked.

Ken Medema came to our church in Houston and just blew me away. His music was fine, but it was his frustration with contemporary Christian music and discussion that really spoke to me. He talked about the pabulum of churchese and I knew exactly what he was talking about.

I stopped listening to CCM pretty much in the late 80s. My music stagnated a bit, really. I added Neil Young's vast repertoire to my collection (or much of it) and his Freedom album helped me survive doctoral exams. In the last few years, I have discovered so much great music that really keeps me going. So, what is playing in the soundtrack now?

Steve Earle is my muse. His politics are as liberal as mine, and his writing is great. Plus, he works in the mandolin in some amazing ways. Transcendental Blues is one of my top 10 albums, and usually the album I reach for when things feel out of control and frantic. I am not sure why, but it helps. (If anyone is interested, there is a dvd of this album that includes an amazing live version of Copperhead Road. I am trying to learn that on mandolin right now.)

Kasey Chambers. Perhaps the most unique voice in country today, I am in love with her albums. We recently purchased Wayward Angel and it is playing in our car constantly.

Scott Miller and the Commonwealth. This guy is Southern, and probably conservative (or more so than myself) but what a great voice and talent. He was in a band called the V-Roys and their stuff is great as well.

Ryan Adams. What can I say. I suspect this guy is a real tool in person, but that voice! His voice can soothe me in a way that others cannot. Amazing stuff, as is his old band, Whiskeytown.

Wilco. This may be one of the best bands that I have ever heard. Jeff Tweedy was originally in a band called Uncle Tupelo, and Wilco is his second band. What a band! From the poppy sound of A.M., to the really interesting rhythms of Summer Teeth and Being There, or the thoughtful and political Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, or personal and reflective A Ghost is Born. It is all great.

The Jayhawks, Old 97s and Slaid Cleaves round out the soundtrack, at least for now. There are others: Chris Smither and Keb Mo for blues, Alison Krauss and Tim O'Brien for bluegrass, and Emmylou is one of the constants over the years. I still love U2 and REM, and have been listening to Bruce Springsteen's "Atlantic City" recently.

Everything dies baby that's a fact
But maybe everything that dies someday comes back
Put your makeup on, fix your hair up pretty and
meet me tonight in Atlantic City

Inner voices

Thinking about inner voices lately. Today they seem loud and annoying.

You aren't as smart as you think you are.
You are going to be found out.
Everyone will know you are unremarkable.
You are a fraud!


Those voices were a big part of my dissertation writing process. I customized my home page to greet me with the simple statement: "Inner Voices Lie." That helped some.

But those voices are back today. The snakes are out of their cages.

I know more about them now. I know they can be managed and compartmentalized.

They lie. And they need to shut up.

February 15, 2005

Serious topic: worship

I am serious now. No longer mocking Arkansas.

What is worship? I want to know what you think. Anonymous or not. What is worship? What isn't worship?

Or else I will continue to mock Arkansas marriage.