January 17, 2005

Yahoo! News - Poll: Americans Hopeful on 2nd Bush Term


Yahoo! News - Poll: Americans Hopeful on 2nd Bush Term
: "Ahead of Bush's inauguration on Thursday, six in 10 people said they felt hopeful about his second term and in response to a separate question 47 percent said they were worried. Most said they were neither angry nor excited about his final four years in office."

Sorry, I just don't get this. Everyone I know is either angry or excited about Bush--I know very few people who are ambivalent about Bush.

But broader point. How can so many people be hopeful about this guy's second term? He has made disastrous decision after disastrous decision. Why the American people continue to support him. Teflon President? Good grief, let's see:

1) outed a CIA agent who was working for us on wmd as a political dirty trick. That alone would have gotten Clinton impeached again.

2) invaded a country on made-up justification--that same justification that they recently had to admit they had stopped looking for. Oh, and when they didn't immediately find wmd, they changed the justification to some crap like, "wmd capabilities." Orwellian, to be sure, but under Clinton or Kerry, that was called, oh yeah, flip flopping.

3) invaded said country with plenty of military to win the war, but not near enough to win the peace. and it isn't like they weren't warned about it, but this administration is nothing if not arrogant. (one of those things I am waiting for Christians to denounce)

4) has run his campaigns with a Machiavellian efficiency. Excellent politician, I concede, but no concern whatsoever for the truth. the most recent on that really puzzles me when I hear people tell me how serious Bush is about his faith. The white house says no social security privatization and badmouths the Kerry camp for suggesting it. Bush makes that the cornerstone of his second term (if he not thinking of invading Iran), and no one calls him on the lie. Oh, and I am still ticked about how he ran his SC primary against John McCain. You know, the one where he allowed his minions to spread the rumor that McCain had fathered a black baby out of wedlock. Anyone who does that is not moral, and anyone who allows that isn't either.

Ok, enough monday morning anger. more later.

January 16, 2005

Boston Legal

I have a thing for David Kelly dramas. Well, that one with all the chicks was lame, and Allie McBeal started to really get on my nerves, but the Practice and Picket Fences are solid gold. Well, not solid, but good. I loved the Practice for exposing the insanities in the death penalty system and thought it addressed our society in a very interesting way.

Boston Legal has bugged me a bit. Reminds me at times a little too much of LA Law, which I really started to hate at some point in time. But James Spader is so unbelievable in this one that I keep going back to it. The addition of Candace Bergin really helped here too, and Captain Kirk is perhaps the biggest scene stealer in the cast.

Anyway, digression, digression. The last two episodes have been great. Last week, the show talked about the killings in the Sudan and why Americans seem to not care--kind of in the same way they don't care about WMD. This week, was a debate on intelligent design v. evolution. Two great points--well, actually a great point, and a really funny line.

Great point: our society has kind of lost the art of intelligent rebuttal. Led by the Fox News Network, everyone is in a hurry to say that every point has an equally valid alternative point, regardless of its stupidity. With Fox News and actually network news as a whole, the Swift Boat Veterans (proven liars in numerous cases) were put against Kerry's war record (boring guy who drones on and probably flip-flopped a few times but WAS ACTUALLY A WAR HERO) as if they were equal in merit. They weren't. In tonight's episode, the idea that you can put intelligent design (untestable and theological concept to boot) on an equal footing with evolution (testable and flawed, but still TESTABLE) is annoying. We have the same bizarre debates over America's Christian Roots, and even in the American South over the role slavery played in the Civil War (that's right, some people think the south would have seceeded over internal improvements). Those aren't equal and we should stand up and say something about that. In the case of the Intelligent design/evolution, I have no problem with talking about God's role in creation as a deeply important theological idea, but putting it in a science class bugs me. Just as I don't want to teach an American history class where I would be forced to say that God played a role in our founding. That would probably make me mad. Or something.

Ok, Really Funny Line: Candace Bergin's character, talking about evolution said, "who among us didn't believe seriously in evolution when watching the Presidential debates?" Or something like that. See, humor? And that one, I believe is a shot at Bush, but Kerry gets some of it on him too.

Music Plug, or what we are listening to right now


Kasey Chambers recently released her third album. Her first two are good, but this one, Wayward Angel, really works. If you haven't heard her, she has one of the most interesting voices in music today. Give her a listen if you are looking for something new.

More on Bush's comments

Associated Baptist Press - News: "WASHINGTON (ABP) -- President Bush said recently he doesn't understand 'how you can be president without a relationship with the Lord.' But that testament brought a protest from one of the country's top Jewish leaders.

Bush made the comment in an interview with editors and reporters from the conservative Washington Times, reported by the newspaper Jan. 12.

David Saperstein, director of the Washington-based Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, told reporters Jan. 13 he is 'deeply troubled' by Bush's remarks. 'Such an assertion violates the spirit of the Constitution’s ban on religious tests for political office and endangers the strength of the religious pluralism and tolerance that the president has so often affirmed -- and re-affirmed in the same interview,' Saperstein continued."


Interesting, and not surprising. It is a problem, because the Constitution clearly bars a religious litmus test for election. I think Bush needs to be more clear about his endorsement of religious tolerance.

Bush and accountability

Bush gave an interview to the Wash Post, and stated his position on a lot of issues. They are interesting, and in many ways, counter to what his campaign said.


Yahoo! News - Bush Says Election Ratified Iraq Policy
: "President Bush (news - web sites) said the public's decision to reelect him was a ratification of his approach toward Iraq (news - web sites) and that there was no reason to hold any administration officials accountable for mistakes or misjudgments in prewar planning or managing the violent aftermath.

'We had an accountability moment, and that's called the 2004 elections,' Bush said in an interview with The Washington Post. 'The American people listened to different assessments made about what was taking place in Iraq, and they looked at the two candidates, and chose me.'"


This is only partially correct. It is clear that he was reelected, but to state that his couple of percentage point victory means that the people endorse his Iraq policy is a stretch. Especially since many of those who voted for him expressed concern about that policy.

But the broader issue is still that he sees accountability this way. I don't understand that or the conservatives who support him accepting that. Accountability is good, and we certainly demanded it from Clinton.

One other very interesting note was that he said he would not pressure the congress on the gay marriage amendment. This seems to contradict the administration's use of that as a campaign issue, though I wonder if social conservatives will see this bait and switch. This strikes me as a further character issue with this president. His campaign also attacked the Kerry camp when the idea of privatizing social security was raised before the election. Why can Bush state that he won't privatize social security and then make that the cornerstone of his second term? Why is that not a credibility issue? He runs on gay marriage and says he won't privatize, and then switches after elected. I think that is called "flip flopping" as I recall. Why won't conservatives hold him accountable? Oh, right. He doesn't feel the need to be accountable.

January 15, 2005

Jesus and football

I am watching the Jets and Steelers playoff game and taking a break from the genocide debate. (BTW, I don't need no stinking bible verse to tell me that genocide is bad--just as I don't have to find a verse to support gender equality, racial equality, or that slavery is wrong.) I have decided to cheer against Pitt because I kind of like the Jets, and also because I find the Ben Roethlisberger "I have never lost as a rookie" annoying. I know, he is donating his playoff check to the tsunami recovery, which is great, but he still bugs me. Plus, he once wanted to play with "P-F-J -- meaning play for Jesus -- on his shoes." Seriously, what does that mean? As I watched the Jets miss two possible game winning field goals, I could hear Big Ben thanking Jesus for that. It inspired me. So here is a list of things I expect from conservative Christians if they want my respect:

1) Stand up and complain every time some NFL, MLB, or NCAA athlete suggests that his/her athletic endeavors is all about God. When Kurt Warner did it, it was annoying, and it is annoying when others do it too. If that is what God is about, let me out. You want my respect, then step up and speak out against trivializing our faith.

2) Make Bush actually act like a Christian. You could all sign a letter in the NYTimes (or some periodical that Bush actually reads, if that is possible) and say something like: "Mr. President, we appreciate that you support our faith and thank you for that. But we also think that you must also follow through on those pronouncements with fruit. It is time for you to acknowledge your mistakes and sins before the nation you lead. You may have thought you had the justification for the war in Iraq, but you were wrong, and you must take responsibility for that. It is important for the integrity of our faith."

Is that so hard?

3) Say something about the environment. You believe that God created the earth, now step up and do something to protect it. If that means you don't drive an SUV or consume unabated, that might be a sacrifice you should make. But say something. Do something to take the Jerry Falwell doofus idiot off the stand.

4) The American death penalty is horrible, and the Christian endorsement of it risks turning the faith into a laughingstock. Think about it, we know that we have had people on death row that the jury, prosecutor, and executioner were completely convinced were guilty, only to find out because of other evidence that they were about to kill the wrong man. What makes you so sure that hasn't happened already? And if you are so willing to allow possible innocent life be clinically executed by the state, then what does that say about you? Stand up, dammit.

5) Step up and show that you value depth. If you are more concerned about the f-word than you are about global warming or executing innocent people, what does that say about you? Not much, that is what.

I don't think I am expecting that much. I am asking you to actually look at what you say you believe and act on it. Write a letter to the President. Write your congressperson or senator. Do something beyond reading "The Purpose Driven Life." Please. Come on!

January 14, 2005

Bush to Liberals: I am tolerant, but you should be a Christian (paraphrase)

Oh, George, you rascal you! Thanks to both Bad Catholic and Carlos at Jesus Politics for this one. According to the paper owned by a cultist freak, Bush thinks that you really need to be a Christian to be President. He reaches out to liberals saying, "The president said there is no reason to fear his conspicuous practice of his Methodist faith or his approval of religious expression in the public square."

I am not afraid of his "conspicuous practice" of his faith, but just wonder when it will actually turn into action? Have we yet any evidence that his faith is more than a political card? Has he treated his political enemies with anything approaching Christianity? Hmm. Maybe he thinks that his faith really is just public quotes and appeals to the religious right.

Mainstream Baptist: Gays a Threat to National Security ?

Bruce points us to a story about priorities.

"The Guardian is reporting that the "Military has discharged 26 Gay Linguists" for violating the military's "Don't ask, don't tell" policy. 13 of them were Arabic translators -- a skill-set that has been in desperately short supply since before 9/11.

Obviously, homosexuals are more threatening to our national security than all the terrorists in Al Queda, all the insurgents in Iraq, and all the weapons of mass destruction that they desire to obtain.

Hmm. It is also seems apparent that key decision-makers have determined that Jesus' command to let the tares grow together with the wheat was ill-advised."

What the hell?

January 13, 2005

American Death

Yesterday, Streak's other friend and I had a bizarre driveway moment. She drove into the driveway to find me sitting in the truck with the radio on. Both of us sat in our cars and listened to NPR's interview with Sister Helen Prejean about her new book. She was mesmerizing, and her story is one of horror. Americans pat themselves on the back about their virture and morality, yet allow a flawed system that kills people to continue.

What do we know about our Capital Punishment?

1) The states that execute the most are from the old Confederacy.

2) Those same states had the most illegal lynchings as well.

3) Our system is biased on both class and race. If you are poor and can't afford good counsel, you have a much higher possibility of being executed (especially in Texas).

3b. If the victim is white, much more likely to result in execution. Victims of color don't count as much.

4. Since the advent of DNA testing, the Innocence Project has exonerated 154 people who were on death row. Remember, DNA evidence only comes into play when there is, well, DNA to be tested. That doesn't mean those are the only wrongful convictions. Especially with what we know about eye witness testimony, it is inconcievable that we can claim that we only execute the guilty.

Most Americans know these problems but continue to allow this to continue. Why? I am tired and jaded, but allowing a system that is racist and classist and likely executing innocent people shouldn't be allowed to continue.

Is God Love? (or did he commit genocide?)

Natalie started her post about the nature of God and the tsunami. Several people jumped in with some comments and jvpastor and I got into a bit of a discussion. We disagree on the nature of god, perhaps, or maybe just the accuracy of the bible as historical record. Read the comments here. I am not dogging on jvpastor. I have no doubt that he is a decent guy. But I really don't understand this debate and hope that some of you can help me out here.

Here is my main point, and I will await some brighter people's opinion. I think anytime other humans are involved, the statement "God did...whatever" becomes suspect. Not saying God doesn't say or tell or do stuff. But when humans kill other humans, it is incredibly hard for me to accept that God was involved. If God reached down and told the Israelites (who, of course, thought they were god's chosen people) to go wipe out some badass neighbors, then what is to stop him from telling some Rwanda tribe to wipe out another, or some German guys to wipe out some other guys, or some Arab strong man to gas some Kurds. I say that has happened more times than we care to remember, and jvpastor suggests that the fact that others have misused the Bible does nothing to undermine the text. That is probably correct.

I still say that God as architect of genocide is hard to take. That isn't very good evidence, I understand, but it is the best I can do on a weary day.

Help me out here. Did/does God endorse ethnic cleansing?

January 11, 2005

When Christians do really really bad things

Just as I post a positive story, I find this one. But it is worth reading. For those who don't read Slacktivist, you should. Fred Clark has a cautionary tale on Rwanda. Some people in the comments have some more interesting things to say. Anyway, read it.

"The church leader is said to have responded, 'Your problem has already found a solution. You must die.'

Ntakirumana did talk with the mayor, and with his son, a doctor at the hospital. They worked together to coordinate the attack that slaughtered the seven pastors, their families, and nearly everyone else in the mission at Mugonero.

Elsewhere in Rwanda the victims were huddled in churches. Some were in Catholic churches, some in Protestant churches, but all in Christian churches because, you see, Rwanda is a Christian nation."

Great story

Most of you probably already read the RealLivePreacher, but here is one of his great stories. This one is about his middle daughter and her love of lemons and fake leather jackets. Anyway, it is a good one.

Another comment

Salaam posted a challenging comment to my depression post that I think deserves some response.

He said:
"While many times labeling behavior and attitudes as evil might be accurate, it is fraught with many traps. Once this type of labeling occurs, I must realize that I have, for all practical purposes, ended discussion with the other party. We are now adversaries and only one of us can move forward after the other is dominated. Your action is evil. You must repent and make it right. If I go so far as to consider the other party as being evil, then I am further justified in dealing with them violently without any remorse. In ridding the world of them I am reducing the evil in it which is a noble cause. I am free to use any methods to get rid of them just as long as my tactics stop just short of theirs. What is lost in this exchange is any opportunity for us to recapture the sense of "we"."


Great points. Let me respond. First, I agree that my use of the word "evil" was probably ill-advised. I used it, I think, for two reasons. One was simply my depression-induced frustration. The second actually relates to your other point--that I run the risk of furthering the "us v. them" mentality that I think this administration has used to govern.

You are correct. When we start to separate into us and them, we do start to disintegrate into dismissal and I am not trying to do that. I am partially frustrated by the clear sense that my opinion does not matter to the Republicans, but I am more trying to appeal to my friends and neighbors who align with Bush. I am not trying to pull away, but challenge them by holding up a mirror and saying "this is what you say you believe. Is that true?" That was the main way I used the word "evil." My friends and relatives who are conservative have been quick to use that word along with Bush, and you point out the perils of such use. I was using it to challenge that belief and suggest that we have to look inside if we are to talk about evil. Because I truly believe that we are all capable of evil and must always be aware of that potential. Evil is not just some abstract out there that we can project onto a Saddam or Osama, it also hides inside all of us. I was trying (again, probably illadvisedly and angrily) to pose the question: "you say that you believe in fighting evil, yet you tolerate this."

I really don't think that the Bush administration is evil, nor do I believe that their supporters are. I think they have done some very bad things, mostly because of this separation that you articulate so well. I am reminded of the lesson of Jimmy Swaggart--who we all remember liked to preach loudly about sexual sins while carrying on with a hooker in a hotel room. My conclusion from that was to be warned about our own weakness--that those who are convinced they are incapable of such actions are the most vulnerable. Bush and his supporters, I think, have so convinced themselves of their own purity that they cannot look inside with any integrity. That is a warning to all of us.

Again, your points are well taken. Even after I plugged your blog! :) As for the value of your points (combined with a buck getting me a cup of coffee), that does not apply to my Starbucks coffee. Hmm.... Starbucks......

January 10, 2005

Family Values question

Leighton left a question in my comments. Streak's Blog: I think I get depressed every January: "So here's a question for someone who actually studies history: at what point did an obsession with marital fidelity become part-and-parcel of the family values package? I want to say it's been around since at least the fifties, but I don't really know. One thing that makes me wonder is that quite a few of my conservative peers who are roughly as old as I am were first 'politically awake' during the Clinton administration, and their preoccupation with adultery is one very clean, convenient a posteriori way to demonize Clinton and idolize Bush. They sure as hell didn't care what married people do on their own time before the Lewinsky fiasco."

Good question and one I will continue to mull over. Family values is a touchy issue and I think you are right that this current obsession is a relative new thing. The emphasis on fidelity has a long life, however, and I don't think that many of the religious right just realized they didn't like adultery when it was Clinton. No doubt, they have been rather selective in who they demonize--even going after some people for being divorced, but loving Ronald Reagan. But they made family values a big deal well before Clinton--remember the Gary Hart fiasco?

But the broader question of family values is an interesting one. I remember one historian commenting that when students asked her about family values, she responded with "depends on which family you are talking about." Conservatives like to see family as a concrete and consistent institution that is only recently under attack, but it--like every other institution--is constantly in flux. Flash back 200 years and marriage is more an economic than emotional union. Kids are a potential work force, and are hardly doted on.

I think the modern obsession with family starts during the Progressive era. It is during this time that immigration, industrialism and the advent of some modern birth control produced a tremendous anxiety about family. It is here, I believe, that we see the disparaging of feminist womens as being gay. Normal women were not supposed to question the family. New industrial occupations and economic fluxuations push more and more women into the work force and change the way that economic unit begins to function. The 1950s increases all of this anxiety, by increasing the emphasis and obsession with children and their nurturance. Suburbs allow the facade of moral values families, but we see the tremendous upsurge of self-medication during this same decade. Alcohol and new tranquilizers become used in huge numbers by these suburban women.

The 1960s probably just exacerbates all of this. For many conservatives, the conflation of anti-war, counter-culture, racial hostility, and feminism represent all that is bad about America. Many of them have been working to reverse those changes ever since. The irony is that both Clinton and Bush represent that decade.

I am not sure this answers any of Leighton's question. As he notes, many of his contemporaries are responding to the more recent iteration of this family values crusade. I think the conservatives have triumphed in many ways, simply by repeating some things until they become accepted as truth. They repeat over and over that the American family is under attack, but rarely if ever question either their assumption or their possible contribution.

RANDOM THOUGHTS on Politics: Bush Values: Screw the Poor

RANDOM THOUGHTS on Politics: Bush Values: Screw the Poor
"I hope all those values voters that supported Bush are comfortable with the values represented in cutting programs designed to protect the neediest and weakest among us while we continue to protect the wealthiest and the corporations. It's particularly cynical to cut increases for disabled veterans, thousands of whom were injured in the war in Iraq. It's more than cynical - it's disgraceful. (And I NEVER want to hear one more statement about how the Dems abandon the troops while the Pubs support them. Never.)"


This is what I am talking about (and yes, I realize I am still shrill. I am mildly depressed--not because of the Sooner or Broncos--but because of a variety of reasons) and I still wonder about the family values of this administration. Let's look at what the Bush administration stands for:

1) invading other countries--because we want to.

2) increasing nuclear weapons (sorry, nukular) rather than decreasing them

3) giving the president the authority to permanently incarcerate people (even American citizens) if they are deemed enemy combatants. Deemed, that is, by the President.

4) reducing environmental regulations because they hurt the corporations. Nevermind the increase of mercury or arsenic. nevermind that some fish are changing sex because of the toxins in their environment. Nevermind any of that. Bottom line is all that matters.

5) taxes are bad. we are all on our own.

6) Public education is bad and should be undermined.

7) we can torture our enemies because they behead people.

8) the death penalty is good. best way to avoid executing innocent people is to execute more and ignore mitigating circumstances.

9) when people around you are incompetent but loyal--promote them.

10) when people around you question your God-like status--fire them and then savage their reputation.

11) racism is bad, unless you need it to get elected.

12) keep saying you are a good compassionate christian. even (and especially) if you are never expected to act like one.

January 9, 2005

I think I get depressed every January

I am often depressed in the new year. Probably not that uncommon. After all, we spend the second half of the year gearing up for Christmas and when it is gone, it leaves a hole. My family has had a rough year, and I am still tired from the last half of the year. My job isn't great. I am grateful to have one, but feel like I am treading water.

The news hasn't been good for people who think like me. I know that may be a small group, but it matters to me. Tsunamis, torture, etc. All depressing. I know I have written about this before, but I still struggle with the religious right and their abdication of moral responsibility. I can't answer why that bothers me so much. Why do I care what Jerry Falwell or the SBC church down the street thinks? I think I still see them with moral authority. You don't grow up in a SBC household without internalizing a lot of the religious thinking. For years, even as I disagreed with my friends and family who were in conservative churches, I conceded a sense of morality to them. I no longer do that.

When conservatives chided me about Clinton's sex life, I knew they had a point. I argued (and continue to argue) that Clinton's immoral act was personal. I don't condone it, but neither did I think it rose to the level of impeachment. I understood that this particular argument held very little credence to my conservative friends who saw in Clinton an embodiment of the moral decline of our country. That moral decline was intensely personal and my conservative friends wanted that to stop or change. I could respect that. I disagreed, but respected that.

That respect is gone now. The same people who chided me for Clinton have bent over backward to excuse Bush. As the bumper sticker goes: "When Clinton lied, no one died." That pretty much sums it up. Bush has dissembled with arrogance. He has ignored advice. He has contributed to the deaths of thousands of Iraqis. He has put America in a vulnerable place by invading a country disconnected to the war on terror. He has been less than honest about his motives, and the cost has been massive.

What does this have to do with my depression? I have written recently about Albert Gonzales and his support of torture, and the inconceivable notion of appointing him to AG and possibly the Supreme Court later. Here is yet another story about Gonzales. I wrote about this sometime ago, but Salon is rerunning the original story. When Gonzales was counsel to then Governor Bush, he edited or so poorly represented the death penalty clemency appeals, that Bush had no problem sending these people to their deaths.

Gonzales' memos, running anywhere from three to seven pages, are, in many cases, so slapdash, incomplete and inaccurate that no one relying on them could possibly make a fair, balanced and intelligent decision as to whether clemency should have been a consideration. Anyone relying solely on Gonzales' briefings would have probably done exactly what Bush did -- put a little black check next to the word "Deny" at the end of the summary and send the offender to his death. True, Gonzales and his staff of lawyers were handling an unprecedented number of executions. But Gonzales' omissions appear less the oversights of overworked attorneys than the deliberate design of a lawyer who knew what his client wanted -- an open-and-shut argument for execution -- and was all too happy to deliver.

How otherwise might one explain Gonzales' summary of the Terry Washington murder case? Washington was executed on May 6, 1997, for the murder of Beatrice Huling, a 29-year-old mother of two. Huling was stabbed 85 times and nearly eviscerated. For many people those facts alone would be sufficient to fry Washington. But Bush seemed to set forth a higher moral standard of review. In his autobiography, "A Charge to Keep," he wrote that he wanted to be informed if "there are new facts or evidence of which a jury was unaware, or evidence that the trial was somehow unfair."

Yet in Washington's case there was a sizable body of evidence the jury never heard, which should have made it glaringly obvious that Washington's trial met even the most conservative definition of unfairness. Jurors weren't told that Washington was mentally retarded and brain damaged, that as a child he and his 10 siblings were repeatedly whipped with water hoses, extension cords, wire hangers and automobile fan belts. Gonzales apparently concluded that this evidence was insignificant, because he didn't bother to mention it in the summary he prepared for Bush. Instead he wrongly suggested that there was "conflicting information" about Washington's mental state. Gonzales also didn't bother to mention Washington's forceful claim of ineffective counsel, arising from his attorney's failure first to present jurors with the mitigating evidence of Washington's childhood abuse and mental retardation and, second, to call a mental health expert to testify to these facts.


Back to my depression. The moral people I used to respect have bent over backward to excuse someone who supported torture--and someone who made it easier to consign to our dubious death penalty system. The Christians--who claim to believe in life and truth--have made excuses for someone who lies and kills. How does that happen? How do moral people look the other way while one of their political heroes acts with such callousness toward life?

It is hard for me to come to any other conclusion than these people don't care about life or truth as they say. I think this qualifies as evil. If you can callously look the other way when possibly innocent people are executed, that is evil. What does it make you if you promote someone who does that? And if you look the other way as an American, then........

January 8, 2005

A plug

You all might want to stop in at my friend's new blog, Salaam. I think he has a lot to offer to our discussion on faith and politics.

Administration propaganda machine

How does this administration still have any credibility?
According to news reports
, "The Education Department paid commentator Armstrong Williams $241,000 to help promote President Bush (news - web sites)'s No Child Left Behind law on the air, an arrangement that Williams acknowledged yesterday involved 'bad judgment' on his part."

How can we trust this administration. It used the budget document last year to promote the Bush administration; has turned public policy panels into partisan engines; and now is covertly paying "commentators" to shill for their policies. Shame on Williams, but shame on this administration.

Update: I just realized where I first saw this story. Bruce over at Mainstream Baptist has some thoughts.

Torture and Tsunami

This article on Christianity and torture is interesting and worth reading. Also interesting how the comments (at least the ones I read) were so critical. One defended our actions as important to protect our troops, another is offended that we are criticizing our country while not recognizing the evil that we fight. All of this came up during the tsunami debate as well, with some critical of American stinginess and others absolute in their claim that America is superior. That last part is what gets me. It is as if Americans have so incoporated their own sense of superiority that they are unable to conceive that their institutions might be capable of evil. Unfortunately, for many, it is tied up in this sense of Christian nation, which if you believe, would probably preclude us being evil.

These two themes provide us some interesting ways to talk about American and Christianity. For me, it seems that both speak to basic Christianity 101 issues; or what makes Christianity unique and worth discussing. There are two Bible stories (I am sure there are many more) that make the argument for Christianity as a unique and radical faith: the Good Samaritan, and the "Love thy enemy" charge.

Streak's other friend and I were discussing the Samaritan story the other day. The context of the story is our responsibility to our neighbors. A man is beaten and robbed, and left on the side of the road. Two consecutive religious leaders avoid this man laying in the dust, but the Samaritan helps him. The focus of the story, however, is not on the robbers. They are clearly bad (as are the terrorists we face today) and capable of great evil. No excuse is made for them, but the focus of the story is the responsibility of the neighbors. The priest and Levite fail this test miserably. Those who focus on the evil of terrorists who behead innocent people miss the responsibility of the rest of us. Our charge is to love our neighbor as ourselves, and if that does not apply to the Iraqi prisoners or the tsunami victims, then it means nothing.

Likewise, the Bible is clear on how we are to address our enemies. “You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I tell you: Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you." That is pretty radical and hard to combine with a statement like I have read so often suggesting that the enemy's evil is our focus.

I write this with humility in that I know I have failed both. Not only have I passed those on the street who need help, but I have hated my enemy. I am working on that. But what bothers me the most about the Christian dialogue I read is the complete dismissal of these texts. Love your enemy doesn't apply to us because....well, I have never received an adequate reason. But I suggest that if you dismiss these key challenges, you are dismissing the heart of how to live as a Christian. If you are not commanded to love your enemy or neighbor, what good are you? What good is your faith? How is it different than the local Country Club?

January 7, 2005

At least one Repub not happy with Gonzales

Undiplomatic Immunity - Did Al Gonzales say the president can authorize torture? By Chris Suellentrop: "Sen. Lindsay Graham is the lone Republican to blast Gonzales. His boyish face comes paired with a kindergartner's hyperactivity, as he impatiently rocks his chair while waiting for his turn. During Gonzales' answers to others' questioning, Graham sometimes wears a look of confusion mingled with disgust. 'I think we've dramatically undermined the war effort by getting on a slippery slope in terms of playing cute with the law,' Graham, a reserve Air Force JAG officer, says. He adds later, 'And I think you weaken yourself as a nation when you try to play cute and become more like your enemy instead of like who you want to be.'

Gonzales senses that Graham has made a mistake and seizes on it. 'We are nothing like our enemy, Senator,' he protests. They behead people, like Danny Pearl and Nick Berg. Graham notes that this is a pretty low moral standard for America to aspire to. I agree that we're nothing like the enemy, he says. 'But we're not like who we want to be and who we have been.' (During Graham's second round of questioning, Gonzales tells him that government lawyers did the very best they could when they wrote the memo. 'Well that's where you and I disagree,' Graham retorts. 'I think they did a lousy job.')"

December 31, 2004

This is better


Yahoo! News - Bush Raises Tsunami Aid Tenfold to $350 Million


I am glad to see Bush respond better. I have been reading the blog world on this issue and see a wide ranging discussion. Many conservatives have been very angry at the criticism, and some of their points are not bad. The US does pony up a lot in disaster relief, though the percentages are still worth noting. We can be better about how we respond to the world. Too many conservatives treat global poverty as a result of weakness, rather than looking at the broader issues of the global economy. We should be far more active in addressing these issues. And Bush's lackluster response to this disaster is in contrast with his rhetoric of Christianity.

But $350 million is a much better response.

I also want to address my most recent post. Critics over at Chuck Curry's blog pointed out that many other websites including MoveOn.org and other lefty groups were also not advertising the tsunami. That is a good point. Unfortunately, it echoes with what seems like a standard conservative response to criticism--the other side is doing it (or not doing it) too. This works on the playground, but still obscures the point that people who wrap themselves in the mantle of Christianity are incredibly shallow. I know that many people on the right are doing good work and are actually putting up their own money to help out people in need. But make no mistake about it; Jerry Falwell, D. James Kennedy and James Dobson are not good people. Nor are they good models of Christian faith.

December 30, 2004

This is exactly what I expected

The Family Values crowd is shockingly silent on over 100,000 deaths. What kind of God do they worship?

WorkingForChange-Christian right's compassion deficit: "These powerful and well-funded political Christian fundamentalist organizations appear to be suffering from a compassion deficit. Organizations which are amazingly quick to organize to fight against same-sex marriage, a woman's right to choose, and embryonic stem cell research are missing in action when it comes to responding to the disaster in southern Asia. None of their web sites are actively soliciting aid for the victims of the earthquake/tsunami."

Update The more I think about this the more I resent it. How can anyone call themselves Christian and not be stunned by this? How can political agendas not fade to the background? Maybe they aren't about faith at all. Maybe they are about power.

Private donations are big! That is good.


Yahoo! News - Rush of donations from USA is immediate and immense


Now, if Bush takes credit for this.......

America Stingy? That's Unpossible!

Thanks again to Black Sheep Christian comes this editorial from the NYT. I am glad to see this story have some legs and now respectfully wait for the conservative evangelical community to express their outrage that we are not helping more than we are. Right?

Couple of key points from this editorial:
"According to a poll, most Americans believe the United States spends 24 percent of its budget on aid to poor countries; it actually spends well under a quarter of 1 percent."


That is very interesting when you add it to the fact that we give less as a percentage of our GNP than any other industrial nation. Americans, I think, have so internalized our superiority, that they simply assume that we give more than others. Kind of like the joke about everything being bigger in Texas, Americans just assume that we are better. But we aren't.

The sad part is that there is much good in this country. But Bush isn't it. And those who support him are not helping our cause. In fact, Bush has been playing with your perception of your own superiority. Our so-called moral superiority is more about show than about reality--especially under the brush cutter.

"Bush administration officials help create that perception gap. Fuming at the charge of stinginess, Mr. Powell pointed to disaster relief and said the United States 'has given more aid in the last four years than any other nation or combination of nations in the world.' But for development aid, America gave $16.2 billion in 2003; the European Union gave $37.1 billion. In 2002, those numbers were $13.2 billion for America, and $29.9 billion for Europe.

Making things worse, we often pledge more money than we actually deliver. Victims of the earthquake in Bam, Iran, a year ago are still living in tents because aid, including ours, has not materialized in the amounts pledged. And back in 2002, Mr. Bush announced his Millennium Challenge account to give African countries development assistance of up to $5 billion a year, but the account has yet to disperse a single dollar."


This does not take into account some of the great things that individual Americans have done. We can and should do more as a country. But we can also give of our own wealth.

December 29, 2004

Amazon: this is more like it

While our Prez cycles (to show how fit he is) and clears brush (to show how much of a fake cowboy rugged son of wealth individual he is, some of the rest of society is stepping up. Amazon has put a 1-click donation page front and center.

update
Streak's other friend noted this from MSNBC's blogger just to show that we aren't the only ones ticked off:
MSNBC - : "The United States government is the wealthiest on the planet. At this time of worldwide horror and grief for the more than 60,000 people killed by the tsunami, and the millions of others who are now homeless, why not start with a billion dollar pledge? Compared to 35 million dollars, a billion would generate worldwide headlines and amazement... and it would  immediately give people across this earth a reason to be thankful for the United States.  And given recent polls showing that hatred for the U.S. is at an all-time high, we could certainly use a better image.

Besides, to put the 35 million dollars in context, consider this: To 'help' the citizens of Iraq, our government is spending 5.8 BILLION dollars each MONTH.  That translates to more than 8 million dollars an hour. Or put another way, the $35 million we have pledged in disaster aid for Southeast Asia is less than the amount the U.S. military spent during the six hours it took on Sunday for the tsunami to cross the Indian Ocean.

I can hear some of you complaining about American 'priorities.'  Hmmmm.  Let's look at our 'priorities.'  Last year, Congress appropriated the following:
$3 million for 'shrimp aquaculture research.' (Since 1985, this program has received 61 million dollars.)
$3 million for the Utah Public Lands 'Artifcact Preservation' program.
$50 million for an 'indoor rainforest project' in Iowa. Yes Iowa.

I could go on and on about our government's 'priorities,' and in 2005, I promise that I will.  But in the meantime, it's embarassing that at the moment, a disaster affecting more than a million people is only ten times more important than preserving artifacts in Utah or studying the behavior of shrimp, and is valued less than building an Iowa rainforest (or occupying Iraq for 6 hours.) 

I'm sure our government will eventually readjust this... and I know the generosity of the United States will exceed that of any other nation.   I just don't understand why we aren't making that statement right from the start, when the message of hope is needed most.  The United States I know is the one that leads and sets an example for the rest of the planet — not one that sits quietly and waits."


And Black Sheep pointed us to a great point about the missed opportunity:
Aid Grows Amid Remarks About President's Absence: "Noting that the disaster occurred at a time when large numbers of people in many nations -- especially Muslim ones such as Indonesia -- object to U.S. policies in Iraq, he said Bush was missing an opportunity to demonstrate American benevolence.


'People do watch and see what we do,' he said. 'Here's an opportunity to remind people of the good we do, and he [Bush] can do it without changing his policy on Iraq or terrorism.'"


Time for America to step up. Yes, Bush should do far more. But we can't wait for him to clear that ranch in Crawford. That place must be infested with brush. We have to do what we can. Take that tax cut and put it to some good use! Go to Amazon, or Doctors without Borders or one of the many other great organizations out there trying to help. Do what you can.

Christianity--another version

This one seems good enough to include the whole thing. Thanks to Black Sheep for this one.

Scary Times

STEVE LOPEZ / POINTS WEST


Scary Times, Even for a Preacher
Steve Lopez

November 10, 2004

In my lifetime, there's been one constant in American culture. We've always needed a good target — someone to blame for all our fears and unmet dreams.

African Americans, hippies, communists, Mexican immigrants, homosexuals.

I missed a couple of groups, but you get the point. And the reason I bring this up is that I met with a retired preacher the other day, and he put it all in perspective.

The Rev. John H. Townsend, pastor emeritus of the First Baptist Church of Los Angeles, had dropped me a line after the election. He was grieving over what he called the current "corruption of Christian faith."

I drove to Townsend's house near Hancock Park to hear what he was talking about. Townsend, a slight and soft-spoken man with spectacles, greeted me at the door along with his wife, Carol, a retired schoolteacher.

The retired pastor began by explaining that when he joined First Baptist near the Bullocks Wilshire department store in 1962, the adjoining neighborhood wasn't yet known as Koreatown. Both the church and the neighborhood were still going through wrenching changes.

Before Townsend's arrival, the predominantly white congregation was bitterly split over the acceptance of African Americans into the parish. Some members walked away when First Baptist decided to open the doors to one and all.

Under Townsend, the church went United Nations, passing out headphones for Spanish-language interpretation of services. Then Townsend brought in a Korean minister, followed by a Filipino minister, and the church became a beacon in a time of racial division, celebrating cultural differences in God's name.

So it should come as no surprise that Townsend wasn't too happy with the role "Christianity" played in the recent presidential election. From where he sits, Christianity was used to divide and conquer.

"This is a scary time," he said. He wonders if the spreading stain of hypocrisy will drive some people away from faith, because under the guise of morality, bigotry was used to get the vote out for President Bush.

"I felt manipulated," Pastor Townsend said in reference to the "hubbub raised by the religious right" over homosexuality in particular. "There was this attitude of triumphalism."

Townsend said he was having a conversation with colleagues before the election when someone asked what they should say about the gay issue.

"The answer was that we should say what Jesus said about it. Nothing."

One corruption of the faith, Townsend says, is the selective use of biblical passages by the religious right. Interpreting literally, he pointed out, you can use the Bible to perpetrate all manner of horrors.

"In Psalms, there's a passage about when the enemy comes, you should bash the heads of children against the stones," he said, going on to cite several more examples.

"The Bible must be read contextually, and the real test for us today is: What would Jesus say or do? If he's our touchstone, and Jesus says love your neighbor, that seems more Christian to me than judge your neighbor."

On the very day I write this column, the Rev. Jerry Falwell has launched something called the Faith and Values Coalition to capture the momentum of the Nov. 2 election.

The idea of this "21st century Moral Majority," as Falwell called it, is to "maintain an evangelical revolution of voters who will continue to go to the polls to vote Christian."

One might question the wisdom of an evangelical uprising at a time when we're trying to convince the Arab world we're not anti-Muslim oil raiders. It also seems fair to ask what exactly it means to punch a ballot like a true Christian.

Is it Christian to vote for a man who is pro-life and yet calls himself the war president; who gives tax breaks to millionaires while 40 million people have no health insurance; and who has not exactly been the most faithful steward of a fragile planet that was ostensibly the work of the creator?

There's nothing wrong with vigorously debating Christian values, Townsend says.

"Absolutes escape us."

But President Bush has left no room for that discussion.

"This business of Bush's about reporting to a higher authority, well, I don't say he shouldn't feel that way. But why does he have to tell us? That's what I mean by triumphalism. How can I answer his claim if he's getting this from direct revelation? It pulls the plug on reasonable discourse.

"Isaiah said, 'Come, let us reason together, says the Lord.' "

So how exactly does one reverse the tide of an evangelical revolution and the cheapening of Christianity?

"By lifting up other voices," Townsend says. Last Sunday, he gave the sermon at Fairview Community Church in Costa Mesa and called for "a new hearing of the gospel."

"As has often been said," he told the congregation, "the ground is level at the foot of Jesus' cross. No one is superior there; no one is inferior."

Townsend ended his sermon with the same simple idea he shared with me at the end of our conversation — an idea that has guided him since he began his L.A. ministry more than 40 years ago. "Jesus laid it out when he said, 'Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.' "


Steve Lopez writes Sunday, Wednesday and Friday. Reach him at steve.lopez@latimes.com and read previous columns at http://www.latimes.com/lopez .

RIP Jerry.

Again, The New York Times > Arts > someone I didn't know died. But it feels me with great sadness. I have watched him for a long time and will miss his work. Sometimes, the death of someone hits you hard, and this is one of those. I am sad.

Comparative costs

As of my last reading, the US had doubled its initial pledge to 35 million dollars for flood relief. Roughly the same amount, as the RLP noted today, the Bush Inauguration will cost (minus security costs!). But that isn't all. The last

Republican National Convention cost upwards of $150 million while the DNC did hardly any better costing $95 million to put on their dog and pony show. If, when it is all said and done, and we spent more on these stupid conventions than helping the poorest in the world, I will hang my head in embarrasment for my country. We are the richest. We should do better.

December 28, 2004

US donates A-Rod's salary to Tsunami victims--almost

Streak's other friend alerted me to this, and we both hope that we are wrong about this. We hope that this is just the first payment and there will be millions and even billions to follow. We can afford tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans, the continued use of Hummer's that pollute and show off waste, but can't give the poorest and most devastated nations more than our pocket change.

CNN.com - Donations to tsunami relief 'generous,' U.N. says - Dec 28, 2004: "Powell told CNN's 'American Morning' that the catastrophe was 'unprecedented in scope and scale.'

He said the United States had responded to an appeal by the International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent by providing $4 million of the $7 million it initially requested worldwide.

The U.S. State Department said an additional $20 million in aid will be added to the $15 million the United States has already pledged for nations hit by the tsunamis."

This fucking pisses me off. I was just writing somewhere else about the whole Christian nation controversy. Well, if we want to be a Christian nation, this looks bad.

Now, contrast that with this little story (I will add the link later):

"Franklin Raines, who was forced out as Fannie Mae's chief executive after five years, is slated to receive a monthly pension of more than $114,000 for life, according to documents the mortgage lending giant filed Monday with the Securities and Exchange Commission."

This asshole gets over $100,000 PER MONTH for the rest of his life! Are you fucking kidding me?

December 27, 2004

Democracy may not work very well

Some of you will remember this post where I wrote a letter to my congressman regarding the CRA. Well, he wrote me back. I opened it with a certain anticipation--remembering a similar letter I got from Don Nickles that was surprisingly responsive and decent. Well, Tom Cole wrote a letter about CHANGES TO ETHICS RULES. That's right, he responded to a concerned letter about red-lining with a justification for his support for Tom Delay. This doesn't make me think too highly of our democracy.

I know, I know. It wasn't Representative Cole. it was one of his idiot staffers. But think about it. Some Poli Sci major read a hand-written letter about access to capital and thought, "I don't know what this is about, so I will just send our form letter about Tom Delay." Which is worse? Our education system that provides the idiot staffers for these geniuses? Or the geniuses that make up our elected officials?

I am saying it is a push.

December 23, 2004

Christmas indeed

Natalie posted some of Oscar Romero's writings and they are worth reading at this time. It made me think of Pura Vida and their work in Costa Rica. We found them through Sojourners and have bought a few pounds of their Fair Trade coffee. They make a difference in people's lives. They reduce environmental destruction and help those coffee farmers actually profit from their labor. Their mission statement says it all: "To create good by using capitalism to empower producers, motivate consumers, inspire business leaders, and ultimately serve the poor. We believe in a different approach to business. One driven by good than greed."

Indeed. If you are looking for some hope in this world, there are many good people out there doing good work. Order some coffee or just send them a little money.

December 22, 2004

I didn't know him, but I am sorry

Welcome to Ethics Daily.com!: "Roy Honeycutt, who championed women in ministry as president of Southern Baptists’ oldest seminary, died Tuesday at age 78."

I didn't know his name, but heard a lot about this controversy during my slow move away from the church. Ultimately, this was the biggest thing for me. I am not sure where I got the feminist impulse. This was before grad school and my exposure to the great issues that feminists worked for. My family was adamant on this issue, as were so many that I admired, and they would have nothing to do with women in ministry. I even remember holding sexist views. I thought I was supposed to be that head of the family. Somewhere along the way, however, I realized that at 5-7, 130 pounds, I was hardly some prototypical male defender. I also had the luxury of spending time with smart women. I eventually married one of them. Ideas of male superiority just became less and less logical until they became offensive.

I am sorry that Roy Honeycutt was pushed aside by the likes of Al Mohler. The SBC has turned into an object of ridicule. It ignores and rejects the intellect, and now has its own Mullah as head. It didn't have to be this way.

Iraq war and Morality

Interesting discussion over at the Jesus Politics. I entered into a little debate about the morality of the war. "Christy" was mad about a post criticizing the American war and asking where the Prince of Peace was this Christmas. She wanted to know if the writer was as upset about Saddam's rape rooms, etc. I responded that all of us agreed that Saddam was bad, but how did that justify our actions? She was unimpressed. I decided to put it in a different way.

"Let's put this in little morality play. Say that your children are playing at a local playground (not the hated and evil government school) and there is this one Bully who likes to humiliate and beat up certain kids--including friends of your children. Now, he has stopped beating up new people, but continues to humiliate certain kids. Your children band together and stand up to Bully and make him stop.

[Now, so far, this morality play represents how you see Iraq, I believe, but not necessarily how I do. But I am giving you the benefit of the doubt here. Like I said earlier, this is how many people see the Iraq war.]

But here is where the story takes an odd turn. Your children and their friends not only have stopped Bully, but they have decided to turn their sights on people who supported Bully. But they really don't know for sure which of the other kids did that. So they start humiliating (making them eat bad stuff, pulling down their pants, punching them in the stomach) these other kids--most of who were also victims of Bully. They come back home and tell you what they did. They say that they stood up to Bully and you are proud of them. They then say that since Bully had humiliated kids, they had decided to also humiliate other kids--but weren't sure if they were really guilty kids or not.

How do you respond to this? Do you pat your kids on the back and tell them that as long as other people started acting evil, it is okay for you to? Or do you say, well, you weren't as bad as Bully, so you are ok."


That is with the generous interpretation of the Iraq war. For the rest of us, it looks more like a really big bully comes along (let's call him Tex) and decides that while he had enjoyed and tolerated Bully in previous years when the victims had been people Tex didn't like either, now Bully has to go. So Tex dismisses the concerns of other, older kids, and smacks Bully down. In the process of the Bully beat-down, many of Bully's victims are caught in the swinging fists and kicking feet. Tex tells them that they are better off and should thank him. Then he appoints a different Bully to act as their playground leader. When some object, Tex starts doing some of the very same acts of intimidation and humiliation that Bully had enjoyed doing--to the very same kids. Then Tex wonders why the kids who had been bullied by Bully don't like him. Of course, if we are true to the story, Tex believes that these kids do like him and admire him even as his henchmen abuse them.

December 19, 2004

To: Conservative Christians. RE: WWJD? CC: Your Conscience

Streak's friend L reminded me of this. She was so mad she was nearly in tears. Me too. Most of my adult life I have been lectured by conservative Christians about morality--mostly from the perspective that their belief in the Bible and their stance on abortion and homosexuality was moral, and my hippie friends were taking our country to hell. Well, the next conservative Christian who lectures me on morality better be wearing a mouth guard.

Case in point. Race in America. Conservative baptists like to talk about their racial sensitivity now. Richard Land brags about his support of the SBC apology on race in 1995. Nevermind that when civil rights workers were dying over race, these same smug bastards were in support of segregation. Nevermind that the entire SBC came into existence because of their support for slavery. Nevermind that even when my friends grudgingly acknowledged that segregation was wrong, they still clung to their opposition of interracial relationships.

Well now we have something is really about economics. You know, putting your money where your mouth is? From Bruce Prescott's fine blog is this story about redlining. Please read it. For those who didn't know, banks used to practice red-lining quite widely. This excluded certain neighborhoods and people from credit. Remember your President Jesus? Well, his administration--deeply steeped in their Christian faith, remember--is now trying to undermine the government efforts to curtail this racist and evil policy.

"In October, a set of proposals by Bush administration appointees threatened to raise the minimum asset level of banks before they are required to participate to $1 billion, up from $250 million, freeing nearly 90 percent of all banks from complying with CRA. For leaving working-class Americans completely on their own, this proposal earns a place in this year's 'Worst of Public Policy.'"


That's right. Mr. Bush and his "very important faith" is trying to make it harder for poor people to get access to credit. Yeah, the same president who has been talking nonstop about the "ownership" society where he wants to encourage home ownership. He must mean for his friends in the wealthier suburbs.

Here is a news flash. This isn't Christian. Not even close. This is easy. No deep philosophical discussions about when life begins or whether your sex inclination is inborn or learned. Simply about access to the American dream. Is your adoration of the market so deep that you really think that racist bankers will extend credit to these people of color on their own?

You voted for him. You told me he was a good Christian man. You assured me that you hated racism and that my cynicism of the suburban church was unwarranted. Read this story and tell me that this is Christian. I dare you. Justify this by any moral standard that wouldn't make the Klan proud.

But Streak, you say. Unlike liberal blogging dogs, I don't have access to the policy makers. What kind of magic can I do? I live in a red state and these things aren't going to change. What can I do?

Write a letter to your congressman. Not an email. Not a form letter. Take out a pen and piece of paper. Right now. I am going to do it as I finish this blog, and I am going to do it in a very old fashioned way, with my Cross fountain pen given to me by my Anglican friend. But I don't know who my congressperson is, you say? I could be really derisive and point out that you have no difficulty finding a theater showing Mel Gibson's snuff film, so I think you can find your congressperson if you want. Go here and put in your zip code. Then write that name down and go to the link for representative offices. Find this person's name and then their address. Mine is Tom Cole from Oklahoma.

But what do I say? Here is what I just wrote:
December 19, 2004

Dear Representative Cole,

I recently read about efforts by the Bush administration to adjust the CRA (Community Reinvestment Act) provisions to let 90% of the lenders off the hook in their efforts to extend credit to the poor. Need I remind you of the irony of the President's push for an "ownership society" while removing some of the access needed?
Nor should I have to remind you of the horrible legacy of racism in this country. We can do better. Please do what you can.

Streak

December 18, 2004

Church v. Bars

Several have contributed great comments here on my post on the magical moments. I think some clarifications are in order, because Chloe brings up some good points about the violence that often accompanies drinking. As I noted in the original post, alcohol isn't the magical elixir here. I have also experienced terrible bar moments. But Brandon makes the point clear in his own followup, noting that he and others "have been put off by the fact that it feels like we both find community more forthcoming at places of meeting other than churches." That is the point. It isn't that you need to add alcohol to church, but somehow get that sense of honest exchange and community that can happen in a bar or coffee house.

One other story. I have Episcopalian friends and one invited me to something called "wild man." Every month, the guys in the church met on Friday night and grilled steaks and had a cooler of beer in the fellowship room. One night, we did get into a rather vocal argument about race, American foreign policy and politics. A much older man looked like he wanted to challenge me to a Zell Miller-like duel for my criticism of our Latin American policy. The priest and another man had a shouting match on the nature of racism (the priest thought everyone is partially racist--the other man really objected). All in all, I would say that it was a rough night, but many of them included great conversations.

Story addendum: I told family members about this monthly ritual--family members who are Baptists. One looked concerned, but said something about moderation and how he agreed that Baptists had gotten overly uptight about drinking. The other one looked at me and said, "if it were cheap beer, it would be wrong."

December 16, 2004

Bars and magic

Brandon over at Badchristian mused about what makes bars better than churches. I kind of agree, though with one caveat. I have experienced the same kind of exclusivism and backstabbing that we all hate about church. Some of my former friends have treated me about as bad at our favorite bar as I was ever treated in a church.

But that isn't Brandon's point and his post reminded me of a story from Robert Fulghum's Everything I needed to know, I learned in Kindergarten. I read that book a long time ago (and need to pull it out sometime) and remember a couple of essays that really worked. One was about raking leaves, but the other one was (I think) called "Bar Story." In that one, he describes the kind of loose and honest experience that can happen in a good bar. The alcohol is only one part of the magic--the connections and honesty of the people is the biggest part.

I remember a wedding in Colorado. My cousing was married outdoors at about 8,000 feet. His wedding party rode in on horses and the bridal party came in a horse-drawn wagon. There was a keg of beer and barbecue. A country band started up and the dancing began. It was mostly stilted and awkward at first. Then we had one of those Colorado summer showers that are so common in the mountains. Only rained for 20 minutes, but everyone stopped and headed for cover until the rain lifted. The band started back up and something magical happened with that rain. The dancing after that was real. My folks danced with a kind of pleasure I hadn't seen in a long time. Others took to the dusty yard. It was truly magical.

My family has some problems with alcohol, and that was there too. I have seen that ugly part in bars, of course. But I don't think I have ever felt that kind of magic in a church setting. Never that kind of gleeful honesty where you see people being so clearly themselves.

Air America might have something going for it after all

The Original Unofficial Steve Earle Site

I have not thought well of Air America even though I certainly share more of their political views than I do with fat boy over on the EIB network (or whatever it is called). (Speaking of which, Jon Stewart showed a clip of Jerry Falwell last night and I think he has turned into either Jabba the Hut or his own Fast Food Nation!) I don't like the style of talk radio regardless of the content and wish we could go back to a day when stations had to balance their content.

But, I found this thanks to Jeanne over at Body and Soul. I am a big huge Steve Earle fan and think that Transcendental Blues is one of my all-time favorite albums. I also appreciate his politics and his dedication to fighting the death penalty. Well, Air America gave him a weekly radio show to talk music and politics. As Steve put it: "Oh my God, what is the world coming to? They're giving commie hillbillies radio shows." Many of his shows are available in mp3 format here. I listened to the show with Emmylou Harris (another favorite) and heard her talk about the protest music that informed her own career. Very nice, and some great music. From the Byrds "Turn, Turn, Turn" to a really biting song by Kris Kristopherson, to a Woody song I had forgotten about a plane wreck carrying migrant workers.
Is this the best way we can grow our big orchards?
Is this the best way we can grow our good fruit?
To die like the dry leaves and rot on my topsoil
And be known by no name except "deportee."

Josh Rubin: Cool Hunting: SHHH!




Ohmigod this is funny. I printed one out and am ready and primed for the next loudmouth! The pdf includes several with check boxes to account for the various conversations we overhear, and one that has in big letters: "The rest of us Don't Care what he/she said to you."

December 14, 2004

"It's not Racist"

Alex, What is known as great way to identify racism.


JS Online: News:: "Custom Now, a store in the River Hills Mall, has been selling a bumper sticker that reads, 'Save a Hunter Shoot a Mung.'

Though misspelled, the slogan was seen as a reference to last month's shooting in Wisconsin. St. Paul resident Chai Soua Vang, a Hmong man, has been charged with murdering six deer hunters after a dispute over a deer stand.

Shopper Jessica Flatequal said she complained to management and was told the store sells many offensive items. 'When I asked to talk to someone about it, they said it's in reference to the hunting incident,' she said.

Flatequal said she was then asked to leave the store.

Some local Hmong residents said the bumper stickers disturbed them.

A store manager who declined to give his name said the word 'mung' in the bumper sticker was actually an acronym for 'minuscule unseen naughty gnat.'

'It's not racist,' he said."

December 13, 2004


Yahoo! News - Wal-Mart Sued Over Evanescence Lyrics
: "The complaint, filed Thursday in Washington County Circuit Court, seeks an order requiring Wal-Mart to either censor or remove the music from its Maryland stores. It also seeks damages of up to $74,500 for each of the thousands of people who bought the music at Wal-Marts in Maryland.

'I don't want any other families to get this, expecting it to be clean. It needs to be removed from the shelves to prevent other children from hearing it,' said plaintiff Trevin Skeens of Brownsville."

That's right. They are suing because of the f-word! Forget suing over the kids that work to manufacture Walmart's cheap crap. Forget worrying about the environmental damage that is harming your kid's future and health. You will sue over the fucking f-word! Are you kidding me? But hey, if they were able to score 75,000 because their poor stupid kid was exposed to the f-word, shouldn't they? I am sure their kid has never heard that word before!

This pretty much seals the deal on how stupid people are. Not that I had any doubts, but good holy god!

December 12, 2004

Best Ornament Ever!

Cold in Laramie will remember this from a trip to San Antonio.

December 10, 2004

Centers and peripheries

I just sat in on a highly technical IT meeting. Gbics, single-mode fibre channel, Brocade switches, SAN fabric, etc. I understood a little. Very little. But I knew what they were talking about.

Walking home I was thinking about all the different groups that I have had at least a partial membership. In high school, I took an AP course, but was not one of the AP "nerds." I remember some of my fellow class mates laughing loudly at a cartoon someone had clipped out of a magazine. The cartoon showed some people exiting a theater, saying "cliches, cliches." The play was Hamlet. I got the joke. But I didn't think it was nearly as funny as my fellow classmates. But the top students in my graduating class knew me, and I knew them.

I was in the band. But the core band people--the serious ones who went on to play in college bands were a different group. They knew me, and I knew them.

I was an athlete. I lettered in tennis and gymnastics; wrestled for a year. The jocks knew me, and I knew them.

But I wasn't really a full member in any of those groups. I kind of feel that way now. I know the full-out IT geeks, and they know me. They laugh when one of my historian friends refers to me as a techno-geek. They know true geeks, and I don't even come close. I am comfortable in academic settings. In fact, that may be my biggest membership now, but since I don't have a full-time teaching job, I am still only a partial member. When I am around fundamentalist Christians, I understand the language. I don't like it, but I understand it. I understand it a little more than I think they realize. But I am also quite comfortable around so-called "unbelievers" and completely understand when they wonder aloud why the fundies believe in a 6,000 year old earth. I understand the pro-life and pro-choice conversations. I am comfortable in mac and windows environments. :)

I really don't know what this means. I know there are numerous groups that award me no affiliation or understanding or comfort level. I know there are groups that I am largely intolerant of. I guess, I feel a certain outsider status today. What that means, I don't know.

December 9, 2004

The more things change...

From Cold in Laramie, this historical quote that sounds suspiciously like GWB or Ann Coulter on our current war with terrorism:

Stephen F. Austin wrote, “a war of barbarism and of despotic principles, waged by the mongrel Spanish-Indian and Negro race, against civilization and the Anglo-American race.”

December 8, 2004

Capitalism and Christianity

Greg plugged Natalie's blog and she raises some very good questions about capitalism.

"In light of the reading I've been doing for a paper about liberation theology, I have been doing a lot of thinking about capitalism and the American church. I was raised to believe that capitalism is the only way to go. I never knew until recently the grave injustices that occur as a result of this system. Why is that? Shouldn't the church be the place where the voiceless have a voice, where we get energized to fight for justice?"

Yahoo! News - Bush Asks Americans to Support Soldiers
: "'In this season of giving, let us stand with the men and women who stand up for America, our military,' Bush said."

Nice little speech, Mr. President. What makes you think that we don't support our troops? I think you would show more support if you had listened to experts in the field, fully funded their effort, provided the number of troops that the "real" military said, and not undermined veteran health benefits. How do conservatives still get the pro-military badge?

December 7, 2004

Christianity and the environment?

I have been grappling with this issue for some time. I grew up in a conservative (though moderate in many ways) Baptist home. My parents read Hal Lindsey and Tim Lahaye. I grew up learning pretty negative things about environmentalists (hippies) and liberals (also hippies). I remember very well the debate over the snail darter, a small fish that held up a dam project. In my family, we found that ridiculous. Some little fish that we didn't even know existed could not stand in the way of human progress.

So, it is with that background that I read Bill Moyer's essay on the religious right and the environment. It is a disturbing vision of the future, but worth the read.

This issue of the environment used to be more on the front burner. 9-11 pushed it back. I am afraid that it will take some catastrophic disaster to move it back. After all, with what we know about global warming and the future depletion of oil, how do Americans drive a Hummer without punching themselves in the face?

I have asked and continue to ask, however, what the Christian community is doing about the environment. As my friend Anglican reminds me, the Christian community includes a lot of different people. That is a good point. This community includes people like Sally Bingham, an environmental minister in California. She is pushing churches to be more enviro-friendly.

Unfortunately, more well-known are the Jerry Falwell's who once famously bragged about driving a Suburban and said his next vehicle would be a Hummer. Oh if he would only punch himself in the face. He better pack a lunch, because that is one pretty large face!

But back to the question. Why do the same people who believe evolution is an unproven theory and Creationism is somehow proven, also oppose attempts to save that same Creation? If God created this world, then why do so many of his followers not care about its destruction? Moyer speaks to part of it--the belief in an imminent rapture making environmental care unimportant. But I don't think all conservative Christians think that way. So, why do they drive their Hummers and live in their polluting suburban neighborhoods and vote for Republicans who make it easier for business to destroy our environment? Anyone?

To be continued.....

December 6, 2004

Sympathetic imagination

Just reading Bruce Prescott's blog this morning and ran across this. I have often wondered if the key thing that kids have to learn is the ability to have compassion for another person's experience. Bruce puts it pretty plainly as his definition for a conscience. I think that is very interesting. If more people had this, they might not park in handicapped spaces!

Mainstream Baptist: "A few years ago I wrote an essay with that title in which I defined conscience as the ability to put yourself in the place of others (in technical terms, sympathetic imagination) and look at yourself through the eyes of an Other (in technical terms, reflexive self-consciousness). I derived this definition from my exegesis for a sermon I gave on what some think is the central biblical text for an understanding of conscience -- 2 Corinthians 5:10-11 (I'll post that sermon and link to it Monday morning)."
Dinosaurs on the Ark?

Monday morning humor, though this is not intentional humor. Thanks to Boing Boing for this Creation Museum | Walk-through.

My favorite: "A real Survivor story. How did Noah and his family survive 371 days alone on an animal-filled boat? Equip yourself with answers through a revealing video."

Evangelicals, you should know that this doesn't help your case.

December 4, 2004

Bring back the public stocks

I don't mean trading IBM openly. I mean the puritan's choice for public humiliation. Seriously. Now.

Why? I will tell you why.

This has happened most at Starbucks. They have a handicapped parking space (actually 2) out front. In the civilized world, we recognize that there are some people who need the access. It is not a big thing for the rest of us to walk the extra 50 feet--especially in Oklahoma where parking is plentiful.

But not everyone abides by that. At the Starbucks we frequent, I have seen this occurrence at least three times. Two times it is the same rich woman driving a big-ass luxury SUV. She keeps the engine running with her rich bitch friend sitting in the passenger seat while rich bitch number 1 goes in to get her coffee. I guess in her mind since she is idling, she doesn't have to worry about taking up space in the handicapped spot. Yesterday, at the beginning of a rather frustrating day, I see another woman just pull into the spot. I glance for the sticker or tag. I even walk around to the back of her car while we are waiting to see if I am missing something. She is large, grant you, even fat-ass as she orders her Carmel Machiatto (that has more sugar in it), but hardly handicapped. I wanted to say something, but also didn't want to make a scene.

Here is my plan. I will print up some stickers for "tagging" (like the fake tickets for SUV drivers) the back of people's car. It should say something like "I park in Handicapped spots, because I am an asshole." or "I park in Handicapped spots because the world truly revolves around me." Maybe just a simple "I hate the handicapped and will take their parking spaces."

I know, I know, this is a dangerous plan. What if someone has a legit permit but isn't displaying it that day? I am not sure I want to actually do this, but it just makes me angry. The biggest problem I see with today's society is the inability to consider how another person experiences their world. That is the problem with homophobia, racism, dismissal of the poor, etc. And if you cannot have compassion for someone who has a real physical handicap, then you better take that fucking fish off your bumper!

December 3, 2004

UCC and Big Media

I received an email from a friend wondering if I was going to blog on this issue. Some other bloggers have weighed in on this, and they have some good observations.

At GetReligion they are largely critical of the media decision, though note that during the 80s, gay activists successfully stopped advertisements concerning gay people converting to straight. At The Parish, and Mainstream Baptist, the word is pretty negative on the lack of inclusion in our religious world today. For me, I agree and see this as symptomatic of broader themes in America. Tolerance is out. Certainty without doubt is in. If you have Ann Coulter rehabilitating McCarthy and Michelle Malkin rehabbing Japanese Internment, one can only speculate if slavery and segregation are next on the table. Conservatives seem to be trying to not only stem the tide of change, but actually roll things back to a previous time period.

As, I think Get Religion pointed out, the irony is that this uproar will give the UCC exactly the coverage and watercooler discussion that they had hoped their ad would produce. Even more. I know I am concerned with how the religious community seems to be flocking to a stance of discrimination and, yes, ignorance (See previous post). I am also concerned with the general tenor in America. MoveOn.org's Super Bowl ad was denied and it was a critique of labor and economic issues. The right was able to squelch a (probably terrible) bio drama on their beloved Reagan. Howard Stern is off the regular air (not that I care) while Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity are able to say whatever hateful thing they want to say. Yet, a church wants to suggest that Christians might embrace my gay friends and that is not worthy of the "marketplace of ideas."

December 2, 2004

Evangelical reputation takes another knock

Since the election, I find myself reading less political news. I just don't have the stomach for it. For now, I am trying to focus on surviving this semester and maybe starting to write a little on the connection (or disconnect) between Christianity and the environment.

I had also been working (since Thanksgiving) on a posting as an open letter to my evangelical friends. We shared Thanksgiving dinner and post-Thanksgiving dinner with several friends and the general discussion about our culture was illuminating. I had hoped to express that in a letter, but it just isn't working.

But one of the major points had to do with my scientific friend's general dismay with Christian approach to science and history. We shared that frustration, that so many Christians were so willing to dismiss the host of scientific evidence (evolution) and historical scholarship (America's Christian heritage) despite having little scientific or historical training themselves. Faith, we all agreed, is a good thing. But when faith simply encourages you to selectively dismiss evidence or conclusions you don't like--that is anti-intellectual and not good for either your faith or our culture. Nor is it good when psuedo-scholars like David Barton present "historical scholarship" that begins with a conclusion and then combs the historical record for any supporting evidence to support that. That isn't how scholarship is made. Same with science. Scientists don't start with a conclusion and then keep doing experiements until they find those that fit the conclusion. They examine the evidence and the conclusion is the best explanation for the data they have. It is always open to revision--given new evidence or data. That is what historical scholarship is, and that is what a scientific theory is. It is not, contrary to how I hear many contemporary Christians talk about it, just one person's opinion on the matter. History may be subjective, but it isn't open to every uninformed theory out there.

Ok, enough ranting. What spurred this exact post was the report in the Wash Post about abstinence programs. I don't really have a problem with abstinence, and agree that many kids become sexually active way too young. Encouraging them to have sex before they understand the implications is problematic.

But, and this relates to the above rant, the difference between what you want something to be and what it actually is demands recognition. Wanting America to be a Christian nation doesn't make it so, neither does wanting a 6,000 year old earth. And wanting abstinence-only programs to be the ultimate solution for American youth doesn't make it so. And adhering to that in the face of contrary evidence just makes you look less intelligent and less reasonable. We have had ample evidence in the past that kids who take the "pledge" for abstinence are just as likely to have sex as those who don't. The problem is that many of the pledgers have less knowledge and tools for dealing with sex when they decide to, er, you know, do it. So, as a group, they were more vulnerable to STDs and unintended pregnancies. That isn't good. Seems like losing ground not gaining.

Now this report suggests that the majority of abstinence programs actually further mislead kids about some basic stuff--like how one becomes pregnant and how you catch or don't catch STDs. That isn't good either. Lying to kids usually ends up making them more vulnerable than less.

Thanks to Slactavist for the story.
Some Abstinence Programs Mislead Teens, Report Says (washingtonpost.com): "The report concluded that two of the curricula were accurate but the 11 others, used by 69 organizations in 25 states, contain unproved claims, subjective conclusions or outright falsehoods regarding reproductive health, gender traits and when life begins. In some cases, Waxman said in an interview, the factual issues were limited to occasional misinterpretations of publicly available data; in others, the materials pervasively presented subjective opinions as scientific fact.

Among the misconceptions cited by Waxman's investigators:

• A 43-day-old fetus is a 'thinking person.'

• HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, can be spread via sweat and tears.

• Condoms fail to prevent HIV transmission as often as 31 percent of the time in heterosexual intercourse.

One curriculum, called 'Me, My World, My Future,' teaches that women who have an abortion 'are more prone to suicide' and that as many as 10 percent of them become sterile. This contradicts the 2001 edition of a standard obstetrics textbook that says fertility is not affected by elective abortion, the Waxman report said."

November 30, 2004

Back

I haven't blogged for a while. Thanksgiving, classes, family stuff, etc. Alafair is fine, btw, for those who wondered. She has recovered from her fight with another jerk dog, and now only has the shaved surgery area to show for her misadventures. We all had a nice Thanksgiving week. We stayed here and enjoyed great food and conversations with thoughtful and wonderful friends.

I have some more to blog about later. Many of our conversations centered around the nature of our democracy and religious experience. Those are worth thinking about, but I don't have it in me today.

Though I am feeling a bit down today, let me post this link with a dual purpose. One is the very cool rechargeable backpack, but the other is the cool website for those of us who care about our environment. Anyway, enjoy. Treehugger: Voltaic Solar/Electronic Backpack

November 22, 2004

"Thank you Jesus!

Houston Texan qb David Carr said as his wide receiver turned a 10 pass into a 50 yarder. "Thank you Jesus?" WTF? Maybe this is why the world is falling apart before our very eyes. Jesus is busy helping rich-ass football stars complete passes.

Oh, and btw, 39 million working poor.

39 million Americans live in families that work, but can't get out of poverty. 39 Million! I am sure we can blame gay people for this one too, right?

November 20, 2004

What do Conservatives stand for?

This story is really disturbing. I have read and used this book. It is an interesting look at American culture. It hasn't stopped me from eating fast food, though I don't do it very much. How do conservatives boycott either Schlosser or his book? How do you say you are conservative and oppose information? Has corporate America become so entangled with conservative politics that nationalism and support for capitalism are confused?

Life and Deatherage: : "Nonetheless, three years later, Schlosser still needs extra security to speak on college campuses, and the Young Thugs Clubs try to block kids from hearing the message of his best-selling book by - I'm not making this up - shouting 'choice.' They're in favor of your choice to eat fast food, but not to know the truth about it. Read what happened at Ball State University this week:

'It's kind of embarrassing that I have to have security,' Schlosser told The Star Press. 'To me, it's a symptom of what's wrong with this country at the moment. My book has inspired some people to call me a socialist or communist or un-American. Wehad a Civil War in this country, and when you look at how other countries fly apart, it's because people start being called traitors, un-American, and demonizing one another. That's very, very dangerous.'

[…] Amanda Carpenter and several other conservative student protesters handed out free McDonald's burgers and fries at the front doors of Emens Auditorium on Thursday night before Schlosser's speech to hundreds of students, faculty and townspeople. The protesters also distributed pamphlets, one of which depicted Uncle Sam in his 'I Want You' pose. 'Eric Schlosser told me you were too fat!' the pamphlet read. 'Put down tha tchicken tender, fatty!'"

November 18, 2004

Search words

Just found that someone found my blog by searching for "mission accomplished satanists." Little too long for a good band name, but might make an album?