June 18, 2005

Grownup Christian, Grownup Republican

Lord knows I am tough on the conservative Christians, but with good reason. When people who claim ownership of the faith look the other way for a Tom Delay or ignore John Ashcroft's racist leanings, or make excuses for Bush--well, I think they need to reassess. You cannot, with good conscience, pillory Clinton for his sins and absolve Bush for his.

But I digress. Thanks to Carlos, I find this editorial from former Senator Danforth--who I never really liked when he was in office. Now I miss him. He seems far more moderate than anything the GOP can offer now. Like Alan Simpson, (who thinks that the religious right are all nuts) he represents a dying breed of conservative moderate. Anyway, he has some things to say.

"People of faith have the right, and perhaps the obligation, to bring their values to bear in politics. Many conservative Christians approach politics with a certainty that they know God's truth, and that they can advance the kingdom of God through governmental action. So they have developed a political agenda that they believe advances God's kingdom, one that includes efforts to 'put God back' into the public square and to pass a constitutional amendment intended to protect marriage from the perceived threat of homosexuality.

Moderate Christians are less certain about when and how our beliefs can be translated into statutory form, not because of a lack of faith in God but because of a healthy acknowledgement of the limitations of human beings. Like conservative Christians, we attend church, read the Bible and say our prayers.


A good articulation, I think, of the differences.

But for us, the only absolute standard of behavior is the commandment to love our neighbors as ourselves. Repeatedly in the Gospels, we find that the Love Commandment takes precedence when it conflicts with laws. We struggle to follow that commandment as we face the realities of everyday living, and we do not agree that our responsibility to live as Christians can be codified by legislators.


Yeah, this seems lost in the conservative mantra. Loving our neighbors as ourselves is important. for all of us. But the conservatives want the harshness of the OT emphasized rather than the words of Christ. He also mentions a lost virtue--humility--that we are hard pressed to find from the Dobsons, Mohlers, Robertsons, or Delays.

And here, he has some strong words for the impact the Religious Right has had on our political landscape:

In the decade since I left the Senate, American politics has been characterized by two phenomena: the increased activism of the Christian right, especially in the Republican Party, and the collapse of bipartisan collegiality. I do not think it is a stretch to suggest a relationship between the two. To assert that I am on God's side and you are not, that I know God's will and you do not, and that I will use the power of government to advance my understanding of God's kingdom is certain to produce hostility.

June 16, 2005

More anniversary notes

My folk's anniversary proved very enjoyable. Family get-togethers are always a bit interesting, and this one was that, but I for one enjoyed myself. The folks had a good time, and I am glad for that.

A few random thoughts:

***

Great memory of my cousin (who I had not seen for 30 years) playing a song he wrote years ago on a borrowed guitar. (He did so without the ring finger on his left hand. He lost it on his ranch when his wedding ring caught on something. Yikes.) But his song was great and it was a neat moment.

****

Westerners talk about "moisture" and rainfall all the time. Yeah, Oklahomans do it too, but in Colorado it is part of the opening exchange. It had been a while for me, so it caught me a bit off-guard, but everyone was able to tell me what their average rainfall numbers were and where this year falls. (Yeah, I know, my own research is on water in the West, so I know about this, but I was still a bit surprised).

****

As I write this blog entry, we are watching a huge wind "event" coursing through Oklahoma. No tornadoes, but wind at 80+ mph, and hundreds of miles wide. But this is not a normal storm. But several of my relatives all spoke of Oklahoma as if it was one big tornado or flat plain.

****

Religion and history

Driving home today, I caught part of Jay Sekulow's show. I know, I know. CIL told me not to listen to religious radio. But today was interesting.

During his show, he answered calls from people running into problems starting bible studies at public schools when other groups don't have that kind of problem. I understand their concern and think that most of us want Christians to have the same equal access that other groups enjoy. Of course, many of the Christians who listen to his show are also being told on other shows to find out if schools allow gay and lesbian clubs to know if they should yank their kids out. I guess freedom is only for Christians then?

But I digress. During the show, Sekulow did an ad for his boss (Pat Robertson) and Regent University. He had a clip of former AG John Ashcroft shilling for the school, and his promotion was interesting. He said that studies there would not avoid issues of faith in history.

Do people really think that grad schools at non-Robertson backed schools ignore religion? Do they think that we don't talk about religion or faith in history? We do. We read widely about religious expression; how that changes, and how it impacts the political culture around it. We read about the variety of religious expression and how people approach faith.

What we don't do, however, is explore the role God played in American history. Why? Because that is well outside what our discipline can do. We cannot determine what God thinks about anything. We can't determine what God did or did not do about anything. If that is what Christians want from history, they will be disappointed, and I am afraid will often turn to David Barton and Regent University for an answer they prefer. They shouldn't, but if they don't like the answer, that seems to be the choice.

One other note, btw, was a guy on the radio after my mando lesson. This is the same guy who said some ridiculously stupid things about gender roles. Tonight, he was talking about taking God's name in vain. He certainly talked about profanity, which I expected. But I was surprised to hear him chide those who use God's name to raise money. He even used the example of someone who claimed that "God would take them home if you don't send money." Oral Roberts getting slammed! Wow. About damn time. So tired of people saying stupid stuff like "God told me that you should do this."

Anyway.

Stem cells? Oh my.

Thanks to Feministe for this link. The moral outrage over stem cell research (a topic I often hear on religious radio) seems to be more complicated than the Bush supporters suggest. The language about destroying life for research hides the fact that the in vitro process creates numerous extra embryos that are often destroyed.

BTW, the story yesterday on the Schiavo autopsy was interesting given how many on the right called this murder and said that she was awake and conscious. I checked out the 700 club's web site. The story was very short and ended with a priest saying that the autopsy didn't remove the moral issues of ending life. I agree. Those are serious and not clear. But it is clear that people like Robertson and others misled their viewers into believing, as Stephen Colbert put it, "Schiavo was a Pilates class away from recovery."

religious right watch: America "Left Behind"

Update: this link isn't working right now.

I am sure I found this link over at Jesus Politics, but hadn't read it until today. Interesting review of the similarities between the Left Behind series and the Neocon foreign policy. Worth reading.

religious right watch: America "Left Behind": "The narrative that Bush and his biographers tell is clearly modeled on the parable of the prodigal son -- the young man who fritters away his early life on alcohol and sin, only to find God and return to his rightful place in his father's former occupation. As he recounts his own redemption narrative, Bush had been mired in the world of business and overuse of alcohol, and so turned in his darker hours to the study of scripture. The beginning of his conversion occurred during a summer weekend in 1985, when evangelist Billy Graham visited George and Laura at the Bush summer house in Maine. The reverend, with his magnetic presence and warmth, planted a 'seed of salvation' in W.'s soul that soon blossomed into a new birth and helped him 'recommit [his] heart to Jesus Christ.'"

June 15, 2005

Wow, this is really scary.

Welcome to the grind: Stealth legislation, anyone?

I think this betrays the idiocy of the far right--not recognizing that this could come back to haunt them in a big way. Also, I really doubt that Bushy can pull another one off. But then again, I thought a draft-dodging war monger would lose to a war hero.

Sensenbrenner puzzles me, btw. I remember his role in the impeachment, but also remember him being very hard on Ashcroft and the Patriot act. Or maybe I am confusing him with someone with principles.
Senate Apologizes for Lynching-Ban Delays - Yahoo! News: "To the victims of lynching--4,743 people killed between 1882 and 1968, three out of four of them black--the Senate issued an apology Monday night for not standing against the violence."


I guess apologies are something. I am reminded of the SBC's apology for their role in slavery and segregation. Something about it coming so long after it matters that bugs me. But add to that the list of conservative Republicans who refused to sign the apology (including both Texas Senators and good old Trent Lott) and you wonder what is going on with them? Is this a principled stance? Are they echoing me and saying that apologies don't matter? Or are they beholden to klansmen who will be very angry if the GOP takes a strong stance on such things?

June 14, 2005

Holy Cow!

This is more evidence for those who doubt that American Christianity is blurring the lines between Christianity and Jingoism.

Anne Lamott has the same problem

What do you call yourself if you don't like being lumped in with Jabba Falwell?

TPMCafe || Politics, Ideas & Lots Of Caffeine: "So I think for the time being, I would like to be referred to as The Artist Who Formerly Called Herself a Christian.? If anyone asks, I will explain that I do love Uncle Jesus, and I live for my church, and other churches that, like the early Christians, celebrate mystery and diversity, and believe that we are here to take care of our brothers and sisters."

More anniversary blogging

My aunt and uncle were sitting around the dinner table. I love those two. They are incredibly funny and also fun to be around. But they are also a bit quirky. My uncle refuses to go to eye doctors (I knew this already) and buys all his glasses at the drugstore. But I didn't realize that my aunt also avoids the eye doctor. But she gets her glasses when my mother gets a new prescription.

Streak's Aunt: I may have to go to an eye doctor soon. My eyes are getting bad.

Streak's Mom: Wait, I have a pair in the other room.

SA tries on SM's old glasses: These are great.

Then, as an aside, this:

You know, I can't walk around with glasses. Makes me queasy!

At this point, I gently suggest that glasses might not do that if they were her actual prescription.

Ah, family!

June 12, 2005

Actual Overheard Conversation at Anniversary

Streak's Niece confronted by Person She Doesn't Know.

PSDK: "You look just like your daddy."

SN: "Yeah."

Unrecorded casual conversation.

PSDK: "Who is your daddy again?"

June 9, 2005

LIMON COLORADO!

I have no idea why they chose this picture, but Limon, Colorado is quite the hot spot. The night life here is intense. Oh wait. I think that is a prison.

Back to the game......

June 8, 2005

50 years!

Light blogging this week, as some of you have probably noticed. SOF and I are preparing to go to Colorado this weekend. My parents are celebrating their 50th anniversary.

That is pretty impressive. I think any of us who have been married recognize that 50 years is not easy. But my parents have made it, and they have treated each other well along the way. I appreciate that, and think that it has made a big impact on my life. Those two listen to each other, and I am glad I had that as a model.

On the road, I may have access and may try to do a bit of blogging. But just know the reason for the drop off.

Congrats, Mom and Dad! We are all impressed. I know that my blogging friends agree.

June 6, 2005

Deep Throat redux

My previous post on Chuck Colson's odd response to Deep Throat spurred some interesting commentary. Hokie suggested that Watergate really only caught people's attention because of the weight of previous issues--namely Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers. He wonders if Bush will face a similar fate. Eventually.

I hope so. I certainly hope for our republic that there is some cost to a fraudulent war--that future politicians might rethink something because they don't want to pull a "W." But I wonder. One of the things Rove and Co. have been so very effective at is manipulating the Religious Right. Of course, most Christians I know take lying very seriously, and war even more so, but for some odd reason they are steadfastly in Bush's camp. The moral values that they waved with such righteousness when Clinton got a Lewinsky are no where to be seen. Well, not exactly. They are still displayed and waved, but not at the President. Gays, abortion, Ten Commandments, and teaching evolution are the focus of that "moral fervor."

Christianity is in crisis--at least the American version of it. The most dominant voices in the faith come from the far right where the tenets of Capitalism must be etched on their copy of the 10 commandments. Sin has been redefined to be mostly about sex, while the "sins" of this administration--arrogance, self-righteousness, greed, anger, war, violence--have faded into some kind of religious museum.

There are a lot of things we can talk about and even negotiate. You want to talk about abortion? I am listening. You want to discuss my gay friends? I will talk. You want to talk about an over-sexualized society and popular culture? I am here. But to paraphrase Kasey Chambers, if you aren't pissed off about this administration's activities, then you aren't paying attention. And that goes doubly for people of faith. If you can watch this administration play fast and loose with the truth and not be concerned, then you are not paying attention. If you watch Bush bully people who disagree with him and don't wince, you are choosing to do that. If you listen to him mouth the tenets of your faith but never look for "fruit" then what is the point?

June 5, 2005

Under the Banner of Heaven : A Story of Violent Faith



Kristen blogged the other day asking what kind of reader we are. Perhaps it is the residual effects of grad school, but my reading has been intermittent. One of my goals for this summer is to immerse myself in good reading.

This was a great start. As an intermittent reader, it has been a long time since a book (other than a pot boiler) caught my attention. Krakauer's examination of Mormonism certainly did that. Starting the 300 page book Friday night, I finished it Sunday afternoon. Part of that is undoubtedly the fact that he can write, the other was the material.

Growing up in the American West, I have had some exposure to the Mormon Church. I have relatives in the church, and remember our family discussions hapless Mormon missionaries who stumbled into a family that a) liked to argue, and b) knew something about Mormonism. Looking back, many of those young kids had no chance!

But even with that background, I had no idea (as Hokie suggested in the comments) of the fundamentalist wing of the church (or more accurately "wings"). Krakauer looks at the widespread fundy sects that populate North America and continue to practice polygamy (and worse). One such nutcase was the one who kidnapped and "married" Elizabeth Smart.

But what does this tell us about faith in general? Why did Krakauer's book catch so much attention?

Part of it is the nature of the Mormon church. While I find their theology suspect (to say the least), it is their institutionalism that bothers me the most. The church is famous for its secrecy and refuses to allow scholars access to the best sources fearing, of course, that the church will be portrayed badly. As Krakauer recounts, the church sees their history as sacred and wants it all to be, as they put it "faith promoting." A leader said in 1981: "There isa temptation . . . to want to tell everything, whether it is worthy of faith promoting or not. Some things that are true are not useful. . . . In an effort to be objective, impartial, and scholarly, a writer or a teacher may unwittingly be giving equalt time to the adversary. . . . In the Church we are not neutral."

As a historian, I find that approach chilling, and this may explain why I get so annoyed with those who would impose their religious beliefs (Christian, Mormon, whatever) on the past.

Several other points from the book resonated. One was Krakauer's assessment of Mormonism as quintessentially American: intensely individualistic and collective all at the same time. The Mormon belief in direct revelation from God means that each individual can, and often does, devise their own separate theology or divine call. But to counter that, Joseph Smith and the modern church try to clamp down on that individual revelation with the conformity of the institution.

Like I said, the theology of the LDS church (fundamentalist or other) leaves me cold, but I also find parallels with the mainstream evangelical church. The emphasis on the personal relationship with God has, in my opinion (and certainly not just mine), led to intensely self-directed theologies. The evangelical church sounds very similar to conservative Mormons in their direct embracing of capitalism and wealth, as well as their insistence on direct revelation from God. Of course, in most people, that direct revelation (or belief therein) is innocuous, but there are those who take that to heart in a destructive way. Certainly, Dobson, Falwell and LaHaye (to name a few) have the arrogance of someone who thinks they have the ear of God. That certainty should be a caution to all of us.

On education: one of the men interviewed in this book was a part of the most fundamentalist sects (and had plural wives, etc.) before he was excommunicated. He relates the wonder of going to college and learning about other things. He returned to tell his "prophet"
"there's a professor over there trying to tell us the earth is four and a half billion years old, but the religion says it is only six thousand years old. . . . Which shows you why education is such a problem for the Work [fundamentalist sect]. You take someone like me, who was always as stalwart as could be, and then you ship him off to get an education and the guy goes and apostatizes on you. Happens over and over again. And every time it does, it makes the leaders more inclined to keep people from learning."


Evangelicals have done something similar, but in their case by simply purging the schools of thought. Southern Baptists stripped their seminaries of anything thoughtful until the seminaries and many of the other schools have become places of indoctrination rather than education. Homeschooling and attempts to limit exposure to scientific and historical knowledge has, unfortunately, had the same impulse. If you listen to religious radio (which I am trying to give up) you will hear people talking about how to keep your kids from "turning" when they go to college. Education is something to be feared. Don't listen to people like me.

On victimization. One of the more fascinating parts of the book had to do with the Mountain Meadows massacre--a famous event in the American west where Mormons killed an entire wagon train of non-Mormons and blamed it on the Indians (naturally). Some blamed it on the wagon train's affluence and the Mormon's relative state of poverty. But, as Krakauer says: "the wagon train from Arkansas was probably imperiled less by its affluence than by the Saints' carefully nurtured sense of persecution." I immediately thought of the repeated mantra that conservative Christians are being persecuted in a country where they control much of the political landscape. As I have suggested elsewhere, it is much easier to rally the troops by calling on their sense of victimization or persecution than by telling them that they control most of what they want. If you concede the latter, much harder to take responsibility for the things you don't like.

Enough for now. If you haven't read the book, I think it is well worth the time.

More Lamott

TPMCafe || Politics, Ideas & Lots Of Caffeine: "However, I do feel passionately about a couple of things right now, so I'll just share those things. One is Jesus, and his message of peace and love and kindness and taking care of the poor: I cannot reconcile my faith with that of the theocrats in the White House, because I think they have gotten it so wrong. For instance, I read the New Testament nearly every day, and yet cannot find anything about handing out guns to everyone, especially to the angriest and most bigoted Americans. Also, I cannot find anything about tax cuts, imperialism, or destroying the forests. But then, I do not claim to be a good Christian, and in fact, have been referred to in the press as being a crabby believer, and this is true. However, I do know that Jesus always, a hundred percent of the time, stood up for the least amongst us, not just the stock and bond traders. Jesus always maintained that hitting first was the mark of evil, and yet, our country and Iraq are both being destroyed by America's pre-emptive war. Hasn't this administration ever heard of the word 'karma'? And I've said this way too many times already--but not to you, so maybe it is--but you KNOW that you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people that you do. Yet Jesus didn't hate anyone."

June 4, 2005

From Kevin: Remembering Reagan

wasp jerky: Saturday Comics Blogging

Summer reading

Given my change in employment and the end of the semester, it is truly time for some summer reading for me. With some birthday money, I picked up a few new books at Borders the other day.

On the light side, I read Carl Hiaasen's new (well, new in paperback) Skinny Dip. If you haven't read his stuff, you should. Not deep reading, mind you, but some of the funniest stuff out there. Dark humor, no doubt, but still incredibly funny. Tourist Season is one of my favorites, as is Native Tongue. He wrote Strip Tease and the book is (no shock) much better than the movie. His brand of humor is not for everyone, but damn it is funny.

Back to the more serious stuff. I also picked up Jon Krakauer's Under the Banner of Heaven and am having real trouble putting it down. For those who don't know, it is about Mormon fundamentalism, including people who kill based on supposed messages from God. Chilling stuff.

It reminds me of the perils of patriarchical and hierarchical religion. In the case of the fundy Mormons, it is easy to see. But the women who are forced into polygamous marriages as young teens do so because they have been indoctrinated since birth to accept the leadership of their faith. They are incredibly vulnerable to people who can discuss Mormon theology and use it to justify their actions.

I don't think anything I have ever experienced comes close to this, bit it does make me think of the church speak that is so easy to use and so hard to dismiss (if you are inside those churches). I think a pretty good rule of thumb for any faith is that it should encourage dissent and thought. If it doesn't, and especially if it plays the gender card, stay away. Just say no.

Anne Lamott on Bush

TPMCafe || Politics, Ideas & Lots Of Caffeine: " But he was peerless today -- arrogant, clueness, stupid. My heart soared like an eagle, which is probably politically incorrect, but it is also the truth. You could see exactly what Jim Hightower meant when he said that Bush was like someone born on 3rd base, who thinks he's hit a triple. It was mesmerizing to watch him lie and mispronounce words; I couldn't take my eyes off him: it was cobra-hypnosis.

Of course, the line that stole the show was about the lying detainees at Gitmo, 'people that had been trained in some instances to disassemble -- that means not tell the truth.' But there were many other equally astonishing lines. It did me a world of good: watching him, you couldn't help but think that Act II is nearly over. Of course, there will be some tiny flies in the Act III ointment, such as the coming lack of oil, and the fact that the whole world hates us. But I say, pick, pick,pick, because the right wing of the GOP is disassembling right before our very eyes. While I continue to believe that mass demonstrations (coupled with cyber activism) can help bring the end of this terrible administration, we also seriously need to keep the faith, and we can't do that if we lose our senses of humor. Laughter really IS carbonated holiness. So THANK you, Mr. Bush, for the last few days."


I hope she is right. It is clearly the worst administration since Harding. Maybe Grant.

Republicans....bah

The last time I heard about this particular Republican was on religious radio where a fundy was talking about how they finally had a governor with principles.

Chuck Currie: Missouri Governor Matt Blunt Hoists Up Racist Confederate Flag Above State: "When you look up extremist politician in most any dictionary you'll find Missouri Governor Matt Blunt. He is one of those guys who prays for unborn babies and then cuts health care and educational spending for actual live children."


Now (and thanks to Chuck Currie for alerting me to this story), the good Governor is demonstrating more conservative principle:

Missouri Site to Fly Confederate Flag - New York Times: "Gov. Matt Blunt of Missouri has ordered that the Confederate battle flag be flown Sunday at a state cemetery where former rebel soldiers were buried, a move denounced by black leaders."


Just as Jesus would do.

June 3, 2005

Oh Come On!!!

This guy is our President?

"'It seemed like to me they based some of their decisions on the word of -- and the allegations -- by people who were held in detention, people who hate America, people that had been trained in some instances to disassemble -- that means not tell the truth.'"


People made a big deal about Bush's partial grasp of Spanish. Too bad he isn't fluent in English. Aren't all of you conservatives embarrassed everytime this guy speaks. When did it become a good thing to elect a President who is dumber than you?

Reminds me of two great lines from the Simpsons and King of the Hill.

Simpsons: Principle Skinner tells Ralph Wiggum he is failing English. Ralph responds: "Me fail English? That's unpossible."

Hank in King of the Hill: "Failing English? Bobby, you speak English!"

Best take on Deep Throat

Opinions You Should Have - June 2005 Archives: "Paul Revere A Despicable Tattletale, Says GOP

Republicans today criticized Paul Revere for his famous ride, saying that he had violated professional colonial ethics by divulging military secrets in violation of his duty to his lord, the King of England.

'These were sensitive informations about military troop movements with which he had been entrusted,' said G. Gordon Liddy, an expert on ethics in government and a professor at several unaccredited law schools.

'Paul Revere was a traitor and a law breaker,' said Anakin Skywalker in a confidential interview shortly before his limbs were lopped off and he burst into flame.

Conservatives all over America pointed out that Revere also endangered people's lives by riding willy nilly all over Massachusetts at a full gallop in the dark of night. 'He could have trampled someone,' said Bill O'Reilly. 'Paul Revere was a reckless and irresponsible nazi,' he added.

Pat Buchanan derided Revere as a 'coward' and a 'snake' who was unwilling to be direct with the British government regarding his complaints about the monarchy. 'There were channels,' he said.

Peggy Noonan shook her head. 'There's nothing sadder than Americans who have no respect for the rule of law,' she said."

Theocracy on the march

It isn't just in Ohio.

Coffee out the nose funny

Well, not quite. But damn funny. Kevin pointed us to Support Our Ribbons site that, well, certainly makes fun of the ubiquitous ribbon on the back of cars. As I keep saying, my favorites are the ones trumpeting their love of God or Bush (or both) on the back of some monstrosity.

Here is an example.

June 2, 2005

As SOF said, a must read

Monastic Mumblings, a Friar's Journey: Sea of Scarlet: "So, the question for me, is how are Evangelicals using their new found power? Is the Church more spiritual, holy, living a vibrant Gospel or have we failed? Has the Church been seduced by Wealth and Power, and consumed with Lust for more? Do politicians that are supported by the Christian Right live open, holy lives? Sadly I think not. I see too many politicians living dark lives, full of hidden sins, while they openly proclaim faith in Jesus and preach against the very things they are doing. (See list below) What I find amazing is that Conservative Christians shrilly complain at 'secular leftists' but slyly wink at sinners in their own ranks, and trade spouses at a rate that makes most of those same 'secular leftists' blush with shame. The hypocrisy of their lives, lived in front of their children is rasing up a generation of people that want nothing to do with organized Church of any kind!

I would say that called Christian America has become such a farce and a hypocrisy to their children and the entire world, I wonder why any one would want to become a follower of Jesus!

Somehow something has changed in American Christianity. We no longer believe in the gentle Shepherd from Nazareth, we have put our faith in politics, guns and bombs. We have lost our way on a sea of scarlet sin, and have no one to blame but ourselves. How, and in what way will any amout of Law or Politics roll back the effects of the Fall?"


Well said, Monk in Training. I would add to this the fact that the itinerant rebel Jesus, in some inexplicable way, has become the icon of choice for wealth suburbanites.

American culture may be sorely in need of help. There is little doubt that our political system is sick; our popular culture is obsessed with sex, and worse, filled with bad art. But it is our churches that seem to be the most sick. Becoming more and more Republican and Americanized, Jesus is becoming less the Shepard and more the Militant overlord.

I like the shepard.

In other news, Chuck Colson has forgotten his morality lesson

I expect this kind of crap from Buchanan and Liddy, but Colson is the guy who wears his faith on his sleeve, and has no problem chiding the rest of us. To demean Mark Felt for exposing WaterGate is amazing. The quotes below tell the story. Colson didn't learn the lesson at all. I think he may need to read a little more of the book he likes to hit people with.

Felt Jeopardized Public Trust, Former Nixon Aides Say -- 06/01/2005: "Colson said he's shocked and saddened to learn that Mark Felt was Deep Throat. Colson said he's sad for Felt, with whom Colson worked - and whom Colson always considered a 'consummate professional.' 'I never thought anybody with such a position of sensitivity at the Justice Department would breach confidences,' Colson said in a Today show interview.


What about what Colson did?

Colson disagreed with the notion that Felt is a hero. 'A hero is someone that you want other people to emulate... and to say he was a hero because he broke his trust...he broke the confidence of the president of the United States.'


This sounds like the ravings of someone who likes to blame everyone but himself. You want to know who broke the confidence of the President? The fucking President when he lied and broke the law.

In the same Wednesday morning interview with NBC's Matt Lauer, Pat Buchanan - a former adviser and speechwriter to President Richard Nixon -- said Felt was 'full of bitterness and resentment' because he'd been passed over for the FBI director.'There's nothing heroic about breaking faith with your people, breaking the law, sneaking around in garages, putting stuff from an investigation...(Lauer interrupts).


Right. You rather have an administration using the power of the government to spy on private citizens. Buchanan is an ass, we all know that.

Buchanan noted that J. Edgar Hoover 'knew all of the lurid secrets of Jack Kennedy, but thank God, he didn't go out and give them to the Chicago Tribune. That would have been an awful thing to do.Buchanan agreed with Colson's assessment of Felt: 'As Chuck [Colson] says, the FBI knows every secret almost about everybody they've ever investigated...if you want the FBI putting this material out on the record when somebody wants to - what kind of country do you want?'"


Here is a hint, Pat. I want a country where asswipes like you aren't in power. The gall of people who defended Nixon (and now often defend Bush) for attacking the guy who helped expose the biggest modern Presidential scandal (until Bush worked the intelligence to justify an invasion) is unbelievable. Not surprising. But still annoying as hell. Of course, what do I expect. Bush lies about the Iraq war from the beginning; we all know about it; and yet the American people reelect the creep. (Yes, I recognize the use of that word. I think it fits. Bush is, in the words of John Dean, even worse than Nixon.) But for Chuck Colson to react like this shows just how arrogant he is.

Why is it that no prominent religious leader in our country understands the virtue of humility? They can lecture us ad nauseum on sexual purity and other sins, but what about basic humility? Gone. Instead, we are left with Phyllis Schaffley, James "King" Dobson, Jerry "Jabba" Falwell, and Pat "Wackjob" Robertson.

Thank God for blogs--Else I would feel all alone in this craziness

From the parish we find that people are repeating more stupidty over and over, like Jesus loves private property, and our founders never intended for religious freedom to extend to anyone but Christians.

"Had cause to interview a theocrat yesterday for an upcoming story. He called himself that. Just like that: 'I'm a theocrat.' He wanted to qualify what that means, which I appreciate, although I wasn't real comfortable with the qualification, especially as it included the statement: 'The founding fathers never meant to give religious freedom to Wiccans, satanists, and atheists.' Yeesh...


Dude. Greg, if you didn't have an impulse to slap this guy, then you are a bigger man than me. I wonder if he has any sense of how many of the more fundamentalists sects that are "mainstream" today would have been on the list had our founders decided to pick and choose religions. Baptists might have made that list. Certainly Mormons would have. Probably Catholics as well. Oops.

He also mentioned an idea I've been hearing quite a bit about lately. Capitalism is biblical. That's right, the idea of private property is in the Bible and therefore God-ordained. The best way to run a country is according to biblical principles, and since private property is a biblical principle, why then, capitalism is God's chosen form of government. As I recall, and Kristen will have to help me here because she has the article now, Jeff Sharlet has a quote from Ted Haggard in his Haper's piece about economics and evangelicalism. I expect to see quite a bit more about this in the next year or two. It seems to be a growing trend. The theocratic spin-machine is in fifth gear and roaring away. Pretty soon we'll be hearing from mainstream pundits that America should be a 'soft' theocracy and that capitalism is the heart of Christianity (or vice versa). Never was Barth more necessary to a Church's theological identity than right now in America."


I am afraid Greg is right. Bruce has written about this a lot lately, and we are hearing the theocratic language coming more and more from people who should know better. Grownups? Time to speak.

Favorite quote of the day comes from Micah and Kristen's blog: "What Flannery called Christ-haunted, I'm beginning to feel is Christ-bludgeoned." Me too.

What's the matter with Kansas? Stupid Senators, that is what.

Feministe ? Anti-Suffragist H-Y-P-O-C-R-I-T-E: "I think the 19th Amendment, while it's not an evil in and of itself, is a symptom of something I don't approve of. The 19th Amendment is around because men weren't doing their jobs, and I think that's sad. I believe the man should be the head of the family. The woman should be the heart of the family.
-- Kansas State Senator Kay O'Connor, 2001--


As Feministe points out, the hypocrisy is that this woman has been elected before and as now running for Secretary of State. Isn't it heartwarming when someone this stupid is running for office? After she has said that she herself shouldn't be able to vote? I am starting to agree. I know too many smart women to stoop to gender stereotypes, but I am beginning to think that we should have an IQ test for the polls. She would fail in an instant. The Kansas political scene would improve over night, evolution would not be challenged by half-assed, watered-down creationism, and we might have a little hope.

"Heart of the family?" Talk about historical ignorance. Read a little, Kay, before you go and chastize both sexes. Maybe try to understand that that little stereotype you just articulated is a short artifact in time--part of the 19th century Cult of True Womanhood. And, Senator, you are an idiot, and a hypocrite.

June 1, 2005

conservatives hate ideas

Feminste pointed this out. Phyllis Schaffly and her group of rocket scientists have decided that certain books are dangerous. Hey, what do you know? Marx made the list twice. Any criticism of capitalism is unwelcome.

My favorite? That Betty Friedan's Feminine Mystique made the list. Whatever you do, don't challenge male domination. Dare suggest that all women may not find suburban housewifery fulfilling and you are dangerous. Nevermind that historians know that, well before Friedan, women were struggling in the suburbs. Valium and other tranquilizers were used in huge and growing numbers, as was the growth of alcohol among those women.

Here is what bugs me the most. What is so wrong about suggesting that not everone wants to live the same way? Why suggest to all women that they have to live a certain way? Why not recognize that some are going to be wonderfully fullfilled as housewives, but others will not? What is wrong with that?

There seems to be this hugely popular meme going around conservative women, which suggests that those who have decided to not pursue careers are put down by feminists. I am not saying that never happens, but in all the feminists I know, I have yet to see that. I know my experience is annecdotal, but it seems to be growing as an urban legend. Part of the difficulty is that so many of the feminist women I have known are often stay-at-home moms or certainly committed parents. Yet the meme persists that feminists hate families and motherhood.

Why is Phyllis Schaffley even taken seriously here? What credibility does she have on the average woman's life?

May 31, 2005

Father Jake Stops the World

Perhaps this is what makes many of us nervous.

Best Memorial Day post

Caleb presents the historical context for Memorial Day. I include part here (emphasis mine):

Mode for Caleb: On Memorial Day: "As historian David Blight shows in Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory, the earliest Memorial Days were concerned primarily with making sense of the unprecedented death and destruction that the Civil War had wrought. In those earliest celebrations, with memories of the war's wounds still fresh and open, Northerners and Southerners had different ways of making sense of their scarred battlefields, ruined cities, and over 600,000 deaths. For many Northerners, the death and destruction were made meaningful by the ideals that had been championed by the Union--loyalty, nationalism, and emancipation. Southerners had their own mythical ways of making meaning out of defeat, and former Confederates quickly assembled the major components of what would later be known as the Lost Cause ideology. In Southern Memorial Days, soldiers were portrayed as chivalrous defenders of their homes and families, and secession became coded as a valiant movement of resistance to Northern tyranny and aggression. In the immediate aftermath of the War, Memorial Day therefore served as a convenient index of how different memories of the war and its meanings could be. How Americans chose to make sense of the war, to themselves and to others, depended on how they viewed the war in the first place.

Blight also shows, however, that over time the rituals of Memorial Day became less sectional and divergent. In the 1870s, as resistance to radical Reconstruction became more organized and virulent in the South, and as commitment to Reconstruction became more disparate and lax in the North, Memorial Day increasingly became a ritual of reconciliation. Northerners and Southerners celebrated the day together, staging patriotic displays of national reunion. The Blue and the Gray were both praised for their valor and sacrifice, and both colors faded into red, white, and blue.

But that blurring of the lines between blue and gray went hand in hand with the retrenchment of color lines in the South, as state governments and paramilitary chapters of the KKK disfranchised black citizens and terrorized African American communities. From the perspective of the dwindling number of Radical Republicans in the North, the sentimental pathos of Memorial Day was dangerous because it covered the secessionism and racism of the South with a patina of respectability. Reconciliation became a code word for retreat from the promises of Reconstruction and racial egalitarianism."

May 30, 2005

Don't let this slip too far down the page

With all of my continual ranting, I didn't want my first guest post to slip too far down the page. SOF speaks and it is worth reading.

Monday misc.

Some good news from a church. Greg talks about a Memorial Day service that was Toby Keith free. Glad to hear that some churches out there recognize that the purpose of church is not to worship America.

*****

The Indy 500 ran yesterday. As Cold In Laramie is well aware, I care very little for racing. Actually much less than that. But like many others, I was intrigued by Danica Patrick's rookie Indy. She came in 4th and, according to people who know, did very well. After the race, interviewers tried to make it about her gender, but she made it about the team and her ability. We got the sense that she wasn't doing it to make some feminist statement, but simply because she is good at racing cars. Isn't feminism interesting? While New Life Church in Colorado Springs continues to preach the submissive wife, and evangelicals everywhere bash feminism, women continue to make inroads into male-dominated areas. And why not? This 40 year old White male says, "hurrah!"

*****

As you might notice (or not) on the right side of my blog, I have added a new feature. Thanks to LG, I have created a random quote java script. I only have a few quotes, and would like to add some more. So, this is a call for good quotes--religious and otherwise. So, send them on.

I think this is funny

I saw this link first at Bruce's blog and then at Jesus Politics. I think it is a pretty good presentation of some of the main problems with the GOP. My favorite quote is at the end in bold.

Why I'm Joining the GOP: "After a lifetime voting for and working for Democratic candidates and independents, I'm finally going to make the switch and become a Republican.

The reasons are many, not the least of which is age. I turned 55 recently and, having lived more than half my life, I can't afford to worry anymore about the other guy. It's time for me. As a Republican, I can now proudly -- indeed, defiantly -- pledge to never again vote for anyone who raises taxes for any reason. To hell with roads, bridges, schools, police and fire protection, Medicare, Social Security and regulation of the airwaves.

President Bush has promised to give me more tax cuts even though our federal government owes trillions of dollars to its creditors. But that's someone else's problem, not mine. Republicans are about the here and now, and I'm here now.

As a Republican, I can favor exploiting the environment for everything she's got. No need to worry about quaint notions like posterity and natural legacy. There are plenty of resources left for everyone, and if we don't use them, someone else will.

-snip-

As a Republican, I can swagger and clamor for war -- in Iraq, Afghanistan, Colombia, wherever -- even though I've never fought in one or even been in the military. I can claim that we're fighting for Democracy, ignoring reports of torture at Abu Ghraib, Bagram Air Base and Guantanamo Bay, and a spreading gulag of secret detention centers around the world.

-snip-

As a Republican, I can insist on strict moral values when it comes to sex and ignore the growing moral chasms in business, politics, sports, journalism and the leadership of the Roman Catholic Church.

-snip-

As a Republican, I can favor strict punishment of criminals, except for those who happen to be my friends or neighbors. Isn't that the very definition of community -- looking out for friends and family?

I will be pro-death penalty and anti-abortion, pro-child but anti-child care, for education but against funding of public schools. As a Republican, I'll have a better chance of getting to spout my opinions in the media, which for some reason seems convinced that since Bush was re-elected with the smallest electoral margin of any sitting president in history, liberals are passe.

As a Republican, I'll say goodbye to 'old Jesus' and hello to 'new Jesus.' Sure Christ started out as a liberal Jew, and look where that got him. Compassion, love and diatribes against the rich only encourage the weak and punish the most successful among us. The Jesus that Republicans worship is a muscular, decisive, pro-war crusader hard at work cleansing the world of evildoers, not, God forbid, turning the other cheek.

-snip-

I regarded taxes as dues we pay for better roads and schools, safe inspection of meat and dairy products, maintenance of parks and protection of wilderness areas. I see now that looking out for the common good resulted in shortchanging the most important element in this formula -- me. "

May 29, 2005

Streak's Blog: More on Ted Haggerty

Thinking about this post I ran across another post on the Colorado Springs evangelical, er, uh, whatever it is.

This blogger who visited one of those churches in Colorado Springs. Yeah, it is interesting. The pastor goes to India and then talks about all the things that are wrong with the Indians. Not enough Christian, not enough American democracy, and evidently not enough White Americans.

Guys, I have heard for sometime that evangelicals have renounced their racist past--though none of them seem to have taken note of their racist past and vowed to learn from it. But it is clear from Haggerty and this doofus, that the American church is filled with people who look at American wealth and assume that the wealth and power are a product of being white and Christian. Not because countries like America have benefited from developing country resources. Not because we have successfully exported poverty to other countries. Not because we consume well more than our fair share of world resources. Why is it that AmeriChristians are so blind to this? Why is it that they go to another country and bad mouth it?

Grownup Christians? I am waiting for you just as I wait for the Grownup Republicans. The GC's, as I will call them, need to step up and reassert a model of humilty. They also need to recall Jesus's business model. As I recall, it wasn't diversify and cut labor costs. It was about giving away wealth to take care of the poor and follow Christ. It wasn't, as Haggerty seems to think, to pursue the market wealth. And, it wasn't as this guy seems to think, that white Christians are destined by God to be wealthy.

The modern Conservative Evangelical movement seems to be wallowing in horrible theology and McChurches with Happy Sermons and Big Macs for all.

First Guest Blog here at Streak's--SOF

Streak's other Friend (SOF) is my guest blogger this Memorial Day weekend.

Streak and I’ve talked about this “love your enemy" topic quite a bit of late, so I thought I’d type up my thoughts especially as it relates to Tom DeLay.

A dear friend of mine shared a thought provoking statement regarding people whose lives take a destructive turn. She said that no child grows up choosing to be a murderer, abuser, or to destroy people. But through a series of small decisions, somehow they end up out on a limb. At some level I think Tom DeLay believes he's doing the right “Christian” thing, but at another level it seems his actions betray his real motives.

Mr. DeLay would see me as his enemy because my political philosophy and view of the practical application of our shared faith differ from his. From my view, his actions destroy (reputation, livelihood, etc.) any who stand in his way. His actions seem more like Peter’s zealousness in the Garden of Gethsemane when he chops off some guy’s ear. Jesus admonishes Peter very strongly, “Put your sword away! Shall I not drink the cup the father has given me?”

My confession is that I see Mr. DeLay as my enemy for exactly the same reason as he me. So what IS the right Christian response? Streak’s blogged before about Jesus’ call for his followers to love their enemies and to pray for those who persecute them (Matthew 5:44). This is a HARD teaching and one that is very hard to stomach. I’d much prefer that my enemy be punished and “fall from grace”. I prefer they be judged harshly by the same measure that they judge others. I’d prefer they experience the same as they’ve dished out.

However, I know in the better part of my being that this is exactly why Jesus taught his followers to love and pray for their enemies. Praying for them keeps the vindictive and bitterness from holing up in my insides and from infecting the good that does exist within me.

Streak, Anglican, and I went to see Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith this weekend. The more I think about the movie, the more I think the Anakin / Darth Vader saga illustrates this.

Anakin wanted to do the right thing, i.e. live the Jedi way, but the fear of loosing what he held most dearly would drive him to a series of tragic decisions as Yoda’s sage wisdom foretold. Unresolved disappointments and unmet expectations left him exposed. Soon what seemed right appeared wrong, and what appeared wrong seemed right. The very definition of ambiguity, conflict and confusion.

Yet, Padmé tells Obi-Wan, "there is still good in him" speaking of Anakin. Hard to believe when you observe actions that set a horrible wake of destruction in motion. To continue to hope and believe that each person "still has some good in them" is a tall task. Yet, to me this is part of “love and pray for your enemies”.
Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. (1 Cor 13:5-7)


In my darkest moments when I’m seething and even grieving over the destructive nature of Tom DeLay’s actions on this country and in the Church, today I commit to saying a little prayer for him because I still hold out hope that “there is still good in him”… somewhere.

SOF

May 28, 2005

More on Ted Haggerty

Vaughn Thompson at Icthus has a great post on this jerk Haggerty [also check out Waving or Drowning?: Private Property]. Good god. If he isn't worshiping the market (which he directly and openly embraces, not only for wealth, but for the way to commodify spirituality) he is saying amazingly stupid and racist things about Catholic (code for brown people) populations.

If this is the future of the church, be sure to count me out. Good god. Its like Vegas, Branson and the worst of Hollywood read a bad book on the bible and vomited out this church. Note the quote below. 'Worthwhile projects' include soup kitchens, which Ted is tired of hearing about. Much more important to "prosper in the free market." You know, it is just like Jesus said: "feed the poor after you make your millions and if you have time. What is really important is that is that you be happy and rich." Right? Didn't he say that? Because all of the evangelical world SEEMS TO THINK HE DID!

ICTHUS: "In Pastor Ted's book Dog Training, Fly Fishing, & Sharing Christ in the 21st Century, he describes the church he thinks good Christians want. 'I want my finances in order, my kids trained, and my wife to love life. I want good friends who are a delight and who provide protection for my family and me should life become difficult someday... I don't want surprises, scandals, or secrets... I want stability and, at the same time, steady, forward movement. I want the church to help me live life well, not exhaust me with endless 'worthwhile' projects.' By 'worthwhile projects' Ted means building funds and soup kitchens alike. It's not that he opposes these; it's just that he is sick of hearing about them and believes that other Christians are, too. He knows that for Christianity to prosper in the free market, it needs more than 'moral values' -- it needs customer value."


Thanks for the quotes, Vaughn, but I feel like taking a long shower.

Other issues--rage and bother

First, the rage. One of the big problems with Bushy is that he has never, never, never held anyone accountable for one of his mistakes. Sure, people have been pushed out, but usually for daring to question a Custer Bush decision. Those who have masterminded our recent foreign policy cluster fuck have all been rewarded. One of them is now Secretary of State--another is being appointed ambassador to the UN. Now this story:
"Two Army analysts whose work has been cited as part of a key intelligence failure on Iraq -- the claim that aluminum tubes sought by the Baghdad government were most likely meant for a nuclear weapons program rather than for rockets -- have received job performance awards in each of the past three years, officials said."


That's right. Performance awards. Working for Bush, evidently, you could come forward with the analysis that the sun revolves around the earth and still get the Presidential Medal of Freedom. Good way to not, however, is to actually suggest that up is indeed up, or that Iraq was not a direct or immediate threat to the US. That would get you fired. And savaged in the press.

Item 2: This is in the bother category. House Republicans (of the knuckle-dragging category) [side note: isn't it interesting that we use evolutionary imagery to describe people who probably don't believe in evolution?] and obviously those who are the farthest right and most beholden to King Dobson tried to limit the roles of women in the military. After actual women veterans (one of them a Republican in the house) and the Pentagon weighed in, Knuckle was forced to retreat. What bothers me is the discussion of women in combat. I hate combat and hate all of those deaths. But why are congressional republicans more worried about women dying in battle than men?

Item 3: Star Wars. If you haven't seen the Revenge of the Sith, you probably should. I was a doubter--really hating the first two--but after hearing from people I trust, we went to see it yesterday. It is quite good and has some amazing references to today's struggles (as most movies do--purposefully or not). I won't say anything more, but am still quite impressed that they were actually able to get Karl Rove to play his evil role on camera!

Evangelicals and economics?

Fred at Slacktivist has a great post on Ted Haggerty's definition of evangelicalism: "They're pro-free markets, they're pro-private property. ... That's what evangelical stands for."

Really? Hmm. That certainly corresponds with what we are seeing in terms of evangelical political action. Sure there are votes here and there on abortion, but most of the actual actions coming from this administration have been to strengthen the rich and undermine the poor.

Fred says:

"Clearly, Christian thinking on wealth and property has 'evolved' over the last 1,500 years. It is rather rare, these days, to hear a Christian assert or even defend the idea that 'superfluity is theft' -- yet that was the consistent and universal teaching of the church during the first four centuries of Christianity. This evolution or sophistication of Christian teaching is, likely, a concession -- the gradual, frog-in-a-kettle process of accommodation to this world. Yet despite that, again, I'm willing to entertain the idea that this evolution is also in some ways reasonable and justifiable. But it is hypocrisy and nonsense when contemporary Christians who have sold off and abandoned every vestige of the traditional Christian understanding of wealth turn around and insist that the Christian understanding of sexuality is fixed, immutable and eternal. These people strain at the gnat of same-sex love while swallowing the camel of credit card usury. They are so obsessed with their mistaken belief that they live in the most promiscuous society of all time that they have failed to notice they live in the most affluent, the haughtiest, proudest and least concerned with the poor."

May 27, 2005

From the RLP

Read this one. Love the sinner, my ass.

Love thy enemy--but man they make it hard

I have been thinking a lot about the divide we find ourselves in. As one story I read recently noted, the word "hate" is not too strong of a word to describe for both sides.

During the election, I wrote a lot about the divide between Bush's actions and what I think his faith teaches. We are supposed to love our enemies, and I have seen no evidence that Bush has ever even tried to do that. Say nothing about Bin Laden, just try loving your political adversary.

and I think about that for myself. Today, I read this story where the Pentagon confirms that interrogators did abuse the Koran. Not perhaps to the extent suggested in the Newsweek piece, but abuse. The White House and Right Wing Echo Chamber's attacks now stand as self-righteous and hypocritical.

and I feel hatred.

Yesterday, I heard a story about Tom Delay's legal difficulties in Texas. The NPR story discussed how the judge had ruled against his PAC and now the possibilities for criminal trials and even a possible indictment of the Hammer himself. As I drove to my mando lesson, I chuckled and said aloud, "I would love to see that asshole in prison." Then I stopped.

Is that really a good thing to wish on another human being? Even one as horrible and unlikable as Delay? I understand where my hatred comes from. I am stunned and horrified that people of faith--people who believe (at least some of) the tenets of Christ would champion someone who makes George Bush look like a Choir Boy. A person who revels in punishing his enemies. A man who is so ruthless that he inspires fear in others. A person who is so arrogant and filled with his own sense of power, that he once compared his political troubles with those of Christ.

I try not to hate. I know it is bad for me. I also know that if we really believe the teachings of Christ, we should not hate our enemies. But I have no idea how to love someone like Delay. Or Bush. I have been around Christians who could use the language, but underneath, you hear that they are mouthing something that isn't quite real.

I want to be honest. I don't want to hate. But I don't love Delay. I will work on it. Just as I will work to forgive the Christian conservatives who, in my opinion, have not only hijacked my faith, but dirtied and sullied it in partisanship and bigotry. People who tell me that Bush and Delay are in anyway representative of the faith have lost any credibility about the faith itself. Yet, I need to forgive that. I don't know how.

I asked once on this blog about forgiveness and what it meant. Greg, I think, responded very well with this little example. If you trust someone with your money and they let you down, you can forgive them and not hold it against them, but you will not let them manage your money in the future. I am still in the process of not holding it against the people of faith for the Bush RepubliChristians, but I will be cautious to open myself to them on issues of the faith.

One step at a time, eh?

May 26, 2005

Another busy day

Again, despite my recent employment change, I find myself prepping for another talk. I have been busier this week than any in the last several months, which, I think, proves just how bad that job really was.

Yesterday went really well. It started bad, or weak, but really ended well. I spoke to a group of Thai grad students on how to use technology to teach in class and online. They all spoke english so well I was shamed by my own lack of language skills. They were all so damned polite and smart and thoughtful....

At the end I realized why I like to spend more time in a classroom. I learned more than I think they did.

A grownup speaks

I have always liked (though not always agreed with) Alan Simpson. His is the moderate voice that used to be more common in the Republican party. Unfortunately, his type are very limited and we are left with idiots like Coburn and Brownback. Anyway, listen to this interview. SOF suggested it, and says that Simpson sees the religious right in pretty negative terms. NPR : Alan Simpson on Defying GOP Leadership

Now, if we could only get a few more grownup conservatives to speak out.

Speaking of NPR, Frank Deford, who bugs me sometimes, had a surprisingly good discussion on Indian mascots. I kind of expected the usual trivialization of the subject, but he said that mascots keep Indians trapped in history, "perpetually on the 'warpath'" and cartoon figures instead of real people. I agree.

May 25, 2005

Light blogging

I hope to write some more later this week. One would think with my employment change that I would be writing more, but instead I am busier. Two freelance gigs this week and one of them is profitable. :)

But before I head off, let me thank Zalm and Leighton for their substantive comments on the challenges between religion and science. I understand some of the difficulties, but am short on solutions. During a recent party, a few scientists discussed the problem of evolution (they remained puzzled and annoyed, I think, by ID) and admitted that the scientific community had done a bad job of educating the public. After all, if the mantra of "if evolution works, then why are there still monkeys" persists, then many of the critics don't really understand the process they are attacking.

That sounds familiar to me, as SOF has often noted that the public really doesn't understand the historical method either and so are easily distracted by the David Barton's pseudo-history.

So, if any of you have good answers and solutions to the above problems, please pass them forward.

May 24, 2005

Sider: Scandal of the Evangelical Conscience

Key sentence: "IN A THOUGHTFUL nod to Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Sider blames the problem on the evangelical 'cheap grace' that reduces salvation to an 'individual personal relationship with Jesus.'

The New 'Mainline' Church, Sojourners Magazine/June 2005: "Ten years ago, historian Mark Noll's important book The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind began with a powerful indictment: 'The scandal of the evangelical mind is that there is not much of an evangelical mind.' From there, Noll attacked evangelical anti-intellectualism and issued challenges to remedy the problem.

Ronald Sider, senior statesman of progressive evangelicalism, modeled his new book The Scandal of the Evangelical Conscience on Noll's earlier work. However, unlike Noll, whose concern was evangelical intellectual life, Sider claims that contemporary American evangelicals must confront a wider, more devastating issue. Evangelical moral behavior resembles that of other Americans. To paraphrase Noll, the scandal of the evangelical conscience is that there is not much of an evangelical conscience.

The scandal of evangelical behavior, and its parallel lack of ethical conscience, provides a stinging critique of conservative American Protestantism. Even Noll, with his unblinking attack on the evangelical subculture, shied away from criticizing evangelical morality. After all, as a Christian renewal movement, evangelical religion was justly proud of its piety and could take much historical credit for what early evangelicals called 'the reform of manners.' But Sider gives no credit for past successes. Indeed, he goes right for the evangelical heart with his claim, 'Scandalous behavior is rapidly destroying American Christianity' and 'With their mouths they claim that Jesus is Lord, but with their actions they demonstrate allegiance to money, sex, and self-fulfillment.' In other words, evangelicals are hypocrites - revivalists who need to be revived.

To support his claim, Sider looks at a host of polling data (mostly from the Barna, Pew, and Gallup organizations) that reveals that evangelical practice about divorce, materialism, sexual promiscuity, racism, and domestic violence does not differ from the practice of the surrounding culture. In some of these regards, evangelical rates of activity actually rank higher than their neighbors. And it is not just individual evangelicals. Regions of the country with large evangelical populations (the Bible Belt, for example) have the highest rates of divorce, domestic violence, and racism. Thus, the evangelical scandal is not only a matter of individual piety. Rather, it manifests as a cultural problem that erodes the church, undercuts the social power of the gospel, and contributes to the decline of American society.

IN A THOUGHTFUL nod to Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Sider blames the problem on the evangelical 'cheap grace' that reduces salvation to an 'individual personal relationship with Jesus.' If the church embodied 'the whole gospel' of kingdom ethics, community, humanity, and sin, 'greater biblical fidelity would help end the scandal.' But Sider goes further than the theological solution. He also argues that the 'church must be the church.' Instead of conforming to culture, he urges that evangelical congregations re-vision themselves as radically countercultural communities of holiness, Christian practice, and church discipline. In a short section, he proposes some practical steps of congregational accountability and church membership to move evangelicals toward greater moral integrity. The book ends with some rays of hope - a few less-bleak statistics about evangelical behavior intended to inspire confidence that evangelicalism can reform itself and, once again, be a powerful force of spiritual and social change."

Strange bedfellows, indeed

I have been waiting for grownup republicans. My readers know that. I am sure that Bush and Frist would no more listen to me than they would a French national--such is their arrogance. I am just as American as Mr. Bush, yet he cares not in the least that I want to save our environment, not destroy it.

but that said, it is clear that the religious right is unswayable. They have the Lord's own support, after all, and so need not be chastised or questioned by mere mortals. They should have the right to appoint their judges and their Presidents and the rest of us should shut up and convert. Dobson's response to George told the story. "We are God's own and need not take guidance from you." Balls.

It is clear that the only ones who can save our democracy from the theocrats and save our faith from the arrogant bastards are Republicans and conservative Christians. They are the ones with the power. They are the ones who can make themselves heard. They can turn to Bush and say "stop using our faith for political gain. Oh, and btw, maybe you should ACT like a christian!" They can turn to Dobson and say "stop being an arrogant prick. If you are going to profit off our faith, then at least act with some humility."

Well, until that happens, I will take the steps where I can get them. Trent Lott bugs me. It isn't just his hair, it is, of course, his connections with right wing racists (the very same right wing racists that Tony Perkins (Dobson's right hand political hack) has, by the way). But it is clear that even Lott kind of gets just how arrogant this Bush cabal is. He has felt the sting of their disapproval. And now, he is speaking out against Dobson.

USATODAY.com - Activists on right and left agree: No deals: "'James Dobson: Who does he think he is, questioning my conservative credentials?' Sen. Trent Lott, R-Miss., said in an interview. Dobson, head of the conservative group Focus on the Family, criticized Lott for his efforts to forge a compromise in the fight over the judges. Lott is still angry. 'Some of his language and conduct is quite un-Christian, and I don't appreciate it,' the senator said."


I really hate to include Lott in the category of grownup repubs. Can anyone send me the John Danforth letter? We need to collect every republican who dares to speak out against the Religious Right's agenda.

May 23, 2005

Somehow this seems familiar

I remember a little election in Florida where Republicans made a big deal about the Democrats being spoiled losers, even though a certain VP won the popular vote and graciously retired from the race rather than push the issue further. Now in Washington, this story.

All I would like is the party that lambastes me on moral values to show a little consistency.

May 20, 2005

I like this game

Ramblin' Educat: The Kind Of Tagging That Doesn't Involve Spray Paint: "The questions:If I could be a scientist...If I could be a farmer...If I could be a musician...If I could be a doctor...If I could be a painter...If I could be a gardener...If I could be a missionary...If I could be a chef...If I could be an architect...If I could be a linguist...If I could be a psychologist...If I could be a librarian...If I could be an athlete...If I could be a lawyer...If I could be an inn-keeper...If I could be a professor...If I could be a writer...If I could be a llama-rider...If I could be a bonnie pirate...If I could be an astronaut...If I could be a world famous blogger...If I could be a justice on any one court in the world...If I could be married to any current famous political figure..."


As I understand the rules, I will answer five questions and then tag three blog friends. (Or, you can do like I did and just take the challenge on my own):

Here goes:

If I could be a musician.... I would play guitar for Jeff Tweedy in Wilco and be very happy. Or I would be in the E-Street Band. Or I would play in a seedy bar with Alejandro Escovedo and watch closely for the bridge...

If I could be a painter... I would have an eye for the new. I would paint abstracts that would shock people--not scary or vulgar, just visceral works that taps into that inner soul--the kind where people end up walking away muttering...

If I could be a writer...I would write the pot boiler--the plane trash book that everyone read and no one could remember the author's name. Then I could afford to go to Starbucks every day and no one would ask me for my autograph...

If I could be an athlete, I would be the guy who occasionally made a good play but who never said that jesus was cheering harder for me than the opposition....

If I could be a llama rider...I would make everyone in my neighborhood jealous because of my cool llama. But I would give everyone rides until the llama bit the guy down the street I don't like. Then I would give him a peanut. And the llama too...

Now I am supposed to tag some people. I tag Jape, because it is about damn damn ass hell time he started a blog so I can leave anonymous comments on it. I don't know who else to tag. Tired.

Spammers!

I apologize, but I have had to hide the comment field on the Bible and Women post. A spammer was leaving pornographic comments. I deleted them, but they were persistent. We shall see if that helps. I contacted Blogger to see if they could help, but in the meantime......

I can be reached at the usual places. :)

May 19, 2005

The Bible and women

Thanks to Feministe for this link. SOF and I have talked about this a lot. Jesus seemed quite revolutionary toward women, but the church has been reactionary. Coming home from a mando lesson, I heard a preacher (I think his name is Chip Ingram) talking the gender role issue. It alwasy kind of tickles me, but also annoys when I hear these simplified approaches to gender. He is still pushing for wives to submit to their husbands even if the husbands fuck things up (paraphrase), because God's sovereignty will step in. Fine. But the examples are stupid. More like assinine. Idiotic. The wife shouldn't pay the bills? What? So, if your wife is a CPA or just has a natural (dare I say God given) head for numbers, you should still have the husband (with no such head for numbers) manage the finances? Right. It is right there in the Bible. Somewhere toward the back.

But of course, this is a trivial example. The fact is that the Bible has been used to justify the subjugation of women; the demonization of female sexuality, and the wholesale denigration of the female mind. It isn't the Bible's fault, but good God, we are living in the 21st century. Can't we get past this?

Anyway, Kristof reviews a new Spong book. Of course, conservatives will not take Spong seriously, but here he is addressing those "sins" of the bible that saw Christians using the ancient text to justify slavery, condone ethnic cleansing and genocide, and, of course, to keep women in their place. But, I think Kristof would ask, is this really what JWD?

Liberal Bible-Thumping - New York Times: "Bishop Spong, who has also taught at Harvard Divinity School, argues that while Christianity historically tried to block advances by women, Jesus himself treated women with unusual dignity and was probably married to Mary Magdalene. Christianity may have become unfriendly to women's rights partly because, in its early years, it absorbed an antipathy for sexuality from the Neoplatonists. That led to an emphasis on the perpetual virginity of Mary, with some early Christian thinkers even trying to preserve the Virgin Mary's honor by raising the possibility that Jesus had been born through her ear."

Evolution and history

Vast Majority of Scientists (VMS) are talking to Conservative Christians (CC).

VMS: Evolution is the best explanation for the development of natural life. It doesn't explain spirituality, just the development of the species.

CC: nope

VMS: nope? What do you mean, nope? We are the experts in this field, you know.

CC: nope. you guys are good at splitting atoms and mixing chemicals, but you are completely wrong on this.

VMS: We are wrong? What training do you have in cell biology or zoology?

CC: none.

VMS: what proof do you have that evolution doesn't occur across species?

CC: it just doesn't.

VMS: It just doesn't?

CC: yeah, it just doesn't. If it did, monkeys would be turning into people and dropping out of the trees.

VMS: sigh. Your turn, VMH (Vast Majority of Historians)

VMH: America is not a Christian nation.

CC: is too.

VMH: what is your proof?

CC: It says right so on our coins. And in the Declaration.

VMH: That is your proof?

CC: Yeah. And we like that conclusion. You and the VMS are really not that good. It doesn't take much to know history or science. Anyone can do it.

VMH: sigh.

May 18, 2005

Time for a little humor

The latest and last Star Wars film opens tonight after midnight. I am skeptical, but will probably see it eventually. But in the spirit of Star Wars, I present this link to the Triumph the Insult Comic Dog's take on Star Wars' fans. It is funny.

MilkandCookies - Triumph vs Star Wars

Thanks

Thanks to everyone who left a comment or dropped an email with the nice birthday wishes. I appreciate all of them. Very much.

Grownup Evangelist?

Thanks again to Carlos for this link. Intriguing take on Billy Graham. Kind of wonder how he sees his son's participation in this entire nationalism/religion stuff.

THE GREAT WHITE BEAR SPEAKS: REV. BILLY GRAHAM: "Seems he [Billy Graham] has some issues with the leadership of the Christian right, and they with him. So much so that he was snubbed by the Grand Ayatollah of the Christian right, James Dobson, and not asked to speak at his nationally broadcast JUSTICE SUNDAY event on April 24. This event, which featured virtually every religious-right leader of note, was organized to protest the Democrats plans to filibuster extremist judges. What the Dobsonians call a filibuster against people of faith."

May 17, 2005

40!!!!

Yep, today I am 40.

What a weird sensation. I am reminded that I used to view people who were this age as people of wisdom and authority. Little did I know that they were as clueless as me!

Well, not completely.

So, at 40, I feel pretty good.

More later.

May 16, 2005

Let's start with Republican inconsistency

Hey, if I am going to blog, might as well go right to my favorite rant, right?

Couple of things that caught my eye today. First was this story about Newsweek getting it wrong, evidently. They said that US interrogators defamed the Koran in Gitmo. This sparked protests that have killed ~20 people, and appear to be incredibly tragic. Newsweek should take this very seriously and do a better job of making sure their stories are right.

But the right wing echo chamber is off the hook on this one. Flipping through the news channels, you see conservative after conservative angry and ranting about the media and their lack of responsibility.

I agree, but wonder where that outrage was when that same media allowed Bush to mislead us into war? To say nothing of the fact that comments by Jerry "I am extremely fat" Falwell led to riots in India that left 5 people dead.

next item

I am really starting to wince when ever I hear about family values Republicans. Reminds me of the jokes about car dealers who call themselves "Honest Jack" when honest is the one thing they aren't. In Spokane, the family values mayor was trolling the internet for young boys. Jeesh. And then we have this Dr. David Hager (Thanks, Bad Catholic) who is well loved by Dobson and Beverley LaHaye's Concerned Women for America for his family values and stance on contraception, but who's ex-wife alleges that he raped her throughout their marriage--including unwanted anal sex.

Repeat item
Well, kind of. I am never surprised when I see a W sticker on a big gas guzzler. I always fill in this in my mind: "I voted for W, because he assures me that I getting everything I want is good for me and I deserve it." I saw a "We support the troops" sticker on a ginormous SUV on the drive back. I always see it this way: "We support the troops, because with our own oil consumption, we will need to invade more and more countries."

Oddball item

Cold In Laramie saw a bumper sticker in California that proclaimed "Jesus would slap the shit out of you."

I have seen them online, but never on a car. I am a little puzzled by the meaning. Seems like it could go either way. Anyone?

Ok, that is enough for this afternoon.

Back

Back. Some of you didn't know I was gone, but I am back. Went to San Antonio for a few days--though really didn't get to have any food that the area is famous for. Oh well. Did play laser tag (which was quite fun) and spend some time with family. Also had a nice drive home through the hill country and enjoyed that more than I thought I would. Very nice region.

I will get back to blogging this week, I am sure.

May 12, 2005

Jesus & Bruce

Thanks to Carlos (once again!) for this link. I like the take on Springsteen's new album as well as yet another rejection of this persecuted minority crap.

The Nation | Blog | Capital Games | Jesus & Bruce | David Corn: "Many fundamentalist Christians claim victimhood--even though they are free to worship as they like in tax-exempt churches, to send their kids to religious schools, to display the Ten Commandments almost anywhere (such as in their homes, on their front doors, on their cars, on their T-shirts), to vote for politicians who share (if not exploit) their beliefs, and to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a film that graphically depicts the bloody sacrifice of their savior."


Speaking of this, I heard Dobson's radio show the other night (I know, I know). He had Tony Perkins and Gary Bauer on his show and the three of them made quite an echo chamber. He surprised me by playing a clip from Imus where the radio guy criticized Dobson for being so arrogant to George Stephanopolous. But then they just talked about the "liberal" media and how they didn't get it. Never addressed why Dobson was above reproach. Of course, they never discussed Perkins' links to white supremacy groups either. Thinking of Bootleg Blogger's suggestion that the labels are really misleading, I am more than willing to say that if Dobson/Falwell/Mohler/Frist/Delay are what Christianity is, I am going to call my self something else. Not a renunciation of my faith--far from it--a reclamation. But I am not one of those guys.

May 11, 2005

Christian persecution, my ass!

I think Greg blogged about this or, something similar, not long ago. I was watching Jon Stewart for a bit of sanity, and switched the channel to our local NBC affiliate. They were interviewing a local pastor on his interpretation of Revelations. Complete fundy interpretation. Revelations is about now, and any dumbass (my words) can interpret it. No counter voice suggesting that the book be read in a context of the early church, etc. No discussion about metaphors and how controversial the book was to many in Church history. Just a reinforcement of fundy theology. And they are the ones who are being persecuted, right?

Please don't tell me that Conservative Christians are somehow left out of the public square. This idiot jackass had unfettered access to the airwaves, and was interviewed by a dolt--2 cents worth or so. A dolt who couldn't even challenge this, because in OKC, the fundy interpretation is the only one. They would teach it in schools if they could.

Made me think of Holden Caufield (Catcher in the Rye) who, when observing something supposed to be religious (help me out here, it has been years) said, "Jesus would have puked."

Exactly.

High Fidelity game

This is going around the web, and I thought I would play along. Kind of a more involved version of the "soundtrack of my life" game. If you haven't seen High Fidelity, then you should.

Anyway.

Top Five Lyrics that Move Your Heart
1) Springsteen, Thunder Road
The screen door slams
Mary's dress waves
Like a vision she dances across the porch
As the radio plays
Roy Orbison singing for the lonely
Hey that's me and I want you only
Don't turn me home again
I just can't face myself alone again
Don't run back inside
darling you know just what I'm here for
So you're scared and you're thinking
That maybe we ain't that young anymore
Show a little faith, there's magic in the night
You ain't a beauty, but hey you're alright
Oh and that's alright with me


2) U2, When Love Comes to Town
When I woke up I was sleeping on the street
I felt the world was dancing and I was dirt beneath their feet
When I looked up I saw the Devil looking down
But my Lord he played the guitar the day love came to town
I was there when they crucified my Lord
I held the scabbard when the soldier drew his sword
I threw the dice when the pierced his side
But I've seen love conquer the great divide


3) Patty Griffin, One True Love
Let's take a ride to the seaside
We can go out swimming in the high tide
Just wear your shorts and your long hair
Don't forget the lawn chair
Everybody's gone to the movies
Everybody's gone and its groovy
They went to the one about the big war
I didn't, I'd seen it before


4) Mindy Smith, Come to Jesus
Worry not my daughters,
Worry not my sons
Child, when life don't seem worth livin'
Come to Jesus and let Him hold you in His arms


5) Kasey Chambers, Like a River
You make me feel like a river
Like a water overflow
Wanna shout it out from the Mountain
Wanna sing it on the radio
I'll sell my soul like a sinner
If it means you'll never go


Top 5 Instrumentals
I don't really like that many instrumentals (or am having problems thinking of them) so will combine a few instrumentals with great licks or solos

1) Uncle Tupelo--Sandusky

2) Nickel Creek--Pastures New

3) Steve Earle--Mando intro to Copperhead Road (live album) I am trying to learn this one.

4) Pure Prairie League--intro lick to Amie

5) Whiskeytown--solo in Turn Around (Stranger's Almanac)

Top 5 Live Musical Experiences

1) Wilco. Of course, this is the most recent concert, but it clearly stands near the top of the list. Amazing show that incorporated dissonance and wonderful harmony.

2) Springsteen. Saw him once in Houston. Was really interesting to see someone who had honed his craft that well. His stage presence was great and he flat wore us out.

3) Steve Earle and Shawn Colvin. Not together, but both occurred at Austin City Limits Music Festival and so were only 1 hour sets. Earle put together a great set of his great music, mixing old and new and, like Springsteen, showed the way to put on a show. Colvin, who's albums are so-so, put on a heart grabbing show that included funny stories, amazing guitar work (just her, no band) and a duet with her niece. Cool.

4) Old 97s. Saw them at a bar in Austin and what a show! Not close to the depth of a performance that I saw in Wilco, but energy to spare. Rhett Miller is a joy to watch. The next day, btw, at the festival, Old 97s stepped into finish a tepid Johnny Cash tribute set, and set my hair on end with a great version of "Ring of Fire."

5) Alejandro Escovedo. Another guy that many have never heard, but this guy is an amazing artist who put on one of the most amazing shows I ever saw in a small OKC club. If you are interested, give his album Gravity a listen.


Top Five Artists You Think More People Should Listen To

1) Wilco. People who want creative music that challenges you should listen to this great band.

2) Scott Miller. Everytime I listen to his stuff, I am reminded how many people who listen to Toby Keith and Kenny Chesney and those two dopey guys--Montgomery Gentry--are missing really good music that is so much better than that crap.

3) Jack Ingram and Robert Earl Keen--ditto.

4) Ryan Adams--great artist with a wide variety of song styles

5) Kasey Chambers and Kathleen Edwards--country music for people who don't want crap.


Top Five Albums You Must Hear From Start to Finish

1)U2's Joshua Tree. Solid songs, but I think this one has to be heard as a single album and not broken up into a shuffle playlist.

2) Springsteen's Born to Run. Still one of the best all-time albums and needs to play all the way.

3) Emmylou Harris, The Ballad of Sally Rose. Probably a lot of Emmylou fans out there that missed this album, but it is one of my favorites. Telling a semi-autobiographical story about a young girl, the album has some great songs and homages to good country.

4) Both of the recent Wilco albums, (A Ghost is Borne, and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot) are great from beginning to end. Yankee is best played in a setting, I think.

5) Lyle Lovett's Step Inside this House. This one is kind of cheating because it is actually a dual disk of covers. Lovett covers everyone from Robert Earl Keen to Townes Van Zandt and Eric Taylor. But they all work together and it is a fantastic album.

Top Five Musical Heroes
1) Steve Earle. I have said this before, but he writes great songs and I like his politics.

2) Emmylou. I can't think of anyone who has the longevity of this woman. One of the best harmonizers in the business, her own work is solid and she has been putting out albums since the early 70s. She is also involved in the movement against landmines.

3) Neil Young. He has had some really bad albums, but his willingness to take musical challenges still amazes me. The same guy who toured with Crosby Stills and Nash also toured with Perl Jam.

4) Ryan Adams. This "hero" tag is an interesting one. I am not sure that Adams is that impressive as a human being, but his musical ability and, like Young, to a degree, willingness to experiement with different sounds is impressive. And one of the most amazing voices in the industry.

5) U2. I think they have turned out a pretty impressive body of work.

A final musical note.

This took me a lot longer than I thought, and I am sure I would answer many of these differently in another couple of months, but that is part of what makes it fun. I was reminded again just how integral to my sanity this music is. I would love to read other people's answers to these questions.

panta ta ethne: The inerrancy of Falwell and Bush...

Natalie has a great post on the language of fundamentalism:

panta ta ethne: The inerrancy of Falwell and Bush...: "Another excellent example of the author function in Falwell's context occurred when he claimed that he had asked then-President Jimmy Carter why he had homosexuals on staff at the White House. Audiotapes proved otherwise, so Falwell explained that he was speaking in allegorical form. This apocryphal story highlight the author function that Falwell has assumed, because his followers notice the discrepancies, yet continue to be loyal to him. Because Falwell is a man of God, ordained and blessed by God, the works that he contributes to the overall discourse do not have to be literally true."